
Breach of Fiduciary Duty Lawyer in New York
Disputes with partners, LLC managers, officers and employees over loyalty and money


Breach of Fiduciary Duty
Yassi Law P.C. brings and defends breach of fiduciary duty claims in New York: partners who keep secret profits, LLC managers who deal with themselves, corporate officers and directors who misuse company money or opportunities, and employees who are disloyal to their employer. Attorney Reza Yassi handles each matter himself, for clients in New York City and Nassau and Suffolk Counties.
Cases are heard in New York State Supreme Court, including its Commercial Division, in federal court in Manhattan and Brooklyn, or in arbitration when a contract requires it. Fiduciary claims are one part of the firm's commercial litigation in New York.
What is a breach of fiduciary duty?
A breach of fiduciary duty is a failure by someone who must act for another person or a company to put that person's or company's interests ahead of their own. A fiduciary is held to a higher standard than an ordinary business counterparty.
Two duties come up most often. The duty of loyalty means not dealing with the business for your own benefit without proper disclosure and approval, not keeping secret profits, and not taking for yourself a business opportunity that belongs to the company. A partner, for example, must account to the partnership for any benefit, and hold in trust any profit, made without the other partners' consent from partnership business or property (Partnership Law § 43).
The duty of care means acting in good faith and with the care an ordinarily prudent person in a like position would use. New York sets that standard for LLC managers (LLC Law § 409(a)) and for corporate directors and officers (Business Corporation Law § 717(a); § 715(h)). Courts generally will not second-guess an honest, good-faith business decision made without a conflict of interest (the business judgment rule), so a decision that simply turned out badly is usually not a breach.
Examples of breaches that come up in New York business disputes:
Paying yourself, a relative or a company you own from business funds without disclosure or approval
Steering clients, contracts or deals to a side business
Using company money or property for personal expenses
Keeping the books, or the true state of the business, from co-owners
Using confidential information or client lists to compete while still in the role
Is there a 'material breach' test? Not as a separate element. The questions are whether the conduct broke the duty and whether it caused a loss or produced a gain the fiduciary had no right to keep.
Who owes fiduciary duties in New York
In business, fiduciary duties are most often owed by partners, LLC managers, corporate directors and officers, majority shareholders of a closely held corporation (toward the minority), and employees and agents. An ordinary arm's-length deal, such as buyer and seller or lender and borrower, does not by itself create a fiduciary relationship.
A partner wrongfully shut out of the business can demand a formal account (Partnership Law § 44); buyouts and dissolution are covered under partnership disputes.
In a member-managed LLC, the default unless the articles provide for managers, each member who exercises management powers has a manager's duties (LLC Law § 401). Control, records and exit disputes are covered under LLC member disputes.
Employees and agents owe their employer or principal a duty of loyalty while they work for it, the basis of the faithless servant doctrine below.
An LLC operating agreement can limit a manager's personal liability for damages, but not for bad faith, intentional misconduct, a knowing violation of law or a profit the manager had no right to (LLC Law § 417(a)). A certificate of incorporation can limit directors' liability with similar exceptions (Business Corporation Law § 402(b)).
Elements of a breach of fiduciary duty claim in New York
To recover money damages for a breach of fiduciary duty in New York, you generally must prove three elements:
A fiduciary relationship between you (or your company) and the defendant
Misconduct by the defendant that breached the duty
Damages directly caused by that misconduct
Two remedies do not require proof of your own loss: giving up profits the fiduciary had no right to keep, and a disloyal employee's or agent's forfeiture of pay.
Deals with insiders shift the burden. Take a deal between an LLC and a manager, or another business the manager runs or has a substantial financial interest in. If the manager's interest was not disclosed in good faith or otherwise known to those who approved the deal, or if the interested manager's vote was needed to approve it, the LLC can undo the deal unless the parties prove it was fair and reasonable to the LLC when approved (LLC Law § 411). Business Corporation Law § 713 applies a similar rule to interested directors.
Who can sue for breach of fiduciary duty
Only the person or company to whom the duty is owed can sue. Money diverted from the company is harm to the company, so the claim belongs to the company; an owner sues directly only for harm to the owner personally.
When the people in control will not sue, an owner can bring a derivative action on the company's behalf. For a corporation, Business Corporation Law § 626 requires that you held shares when you sue and at the time of the challenged transaction (or received them by operation of law, such as by inheritance), and that the complaint state with particularity your effort to get the board to sue, or why you made none. A court must approve any settlement, and the recovery goes to the corporation.
Business Corporation Law § 720 also lets the corporation, or a shareholder suing derivatively, make directors and officers account for violating their duties in managing corporate assets.
LLC members can also sue derivatively for harm to the company, even though the LLC Law has no derivative-suit section. See the guide on suing managers who harm your own company.
The faithless servant doctrine in New York
Under New York's faithless servant doctrine, an employee or agent who is disloyal in performing their job is generally not entitled to the salary or commissions for that work. The Court of Appeals stated the rule in Feiger v. Iral Jewelry, Ltd., 41 N.Y.2d 928 (1977): it applies even if the services benefited the employer and even if the employer cannot prove any damage.
In the same case, an employee who only planned and took early steps to compete, without reducing his work or taking business secrets, was not disloyal.
Yassi Law P.C. handles faithless servant and other employee-disloyalty cases on either side: for employers, and for employees and executives accused of disloyalty.
Damages and remedies for breach of fiduciary duty
A court can order a disloyal fiduciary to pay for the loss caused and to give up gains they had no right to keep. Remedies include:
Compensatory damages for the money the company or owner lost
Return of improper profits (disgorgement)
A formal accounting of how money was handled (Partnership Law § 44; Business Corporation Law § 720)
A constructive trust, which makes the fiduciary hold diverted money or property for its rightful owner
Undoing an insider deal that was not properly disclosed and approved, unless it is shown to be fair (LLC Law § 411; Business Corporation Law § 713)
Forfeiture of salary or commissions under the faithless servant doctrine
When the money or property in dispute is being moved, or clients are being taken with company information, ask about an emergency court order such as a TRO or preliminary injunction.
A civil fiduciary case does not lead to fines or jail; punitive damages are possible only in egregious cases.
Statute of limitations for breach of fiduciary duty in New York
In New York, the deadline is usually three years when you seek money damages (CPLR 214(4)) and six years when you seek equitable relief such as an accounting or a constructive trust (CPLR 213(1)).
The Court of Appeals explained in IDT Corp. v. Morgan Stanley Dean Witter & Co., 12 N.Y.3d 132 (2009), that courts look at the substance of the request, not its label, and that the claim generally accrues when damages are sustained. Two other rules can apply:
When fraud is essential to the claim, the greater of six years from accrual or two years from when the fraud was or reasonably could have been discovered, under CPLR 213(8). See fraud and misrepresentation claims.
Six years for a corporation's action, including a derivative suit, against directors, officers or stockholders for an accounting, waste or injury to corporate property, under CPLR 213(7).
Because a court may read the claim either way, and a written agreement can set a shorter deadline (CPLR 201), plan around three years from the harm or any shorter contract deadline.
What to do if you suspect a breach
Get the governing agreement and the financial records first, and avoid self-help that could give the other side a claim against you:
Find the partnership, operating or shareholders' agreement, bylaws or employment agreement.
Request the books and records in writing and keep a copy. Useful records include bank statements, the general ledger, tax returns and K-1s, and contracts with related companies.
Save emails, texts and documents you already have lawful access to.
Do not lock out the other side or move company money; self-help can create claims against you.
Write down when the conduct happened and when you first learned of it. The deadline usually runs from when the harm occurred, not from when you found out.
If you are accused of breaching a fiduciary duty
If you are a partner, manager, officer, executive or employee accused of disloyalty, the defense starts with the documents: whether you owed the duty, whether the agreement allowed what you did, whether the deal was disclosed and approved, and whether the claim is timely.
In a New York State court case, you generally must answer or appear within 20 days after the summons is delivered by hand to you or, for a company, to its officer or agent. It is 30 days after service is complete when service was made through the Secretary of State or by most substituted methods, such as leaving it with someone at your home or business and mailing a copy (CPLR 320(a)). Federal court deadlines are different.
Choosing a fiduciary duty lawyer, and what it costs
Look for a lawyer who litigates business disputes in New York courts, reads your agreement and financial records before giving an opinion, and explains the cost up front.
At Yassi Law P.C., Reza Yassi handles each matter personally, and the first consultation is free. Fiduciary cases are usually billed hourly at $450, under a written engagement letter. Contingency or hybrid fees are possible only as an exception in special cases.
Guides on this topic
Is your LLC manager acting in bad faith?: what a managing member owes the LLC and its members, the common self-dealing patterns, and how members prove the claim.
LLC derivative actions in New York: how a member sues for the company when a manager diverts its money or opportunities.
Direct vs. derivative claims in New York LLC disputes: whether a claim belongs to you or to the company, and why the choice matters.
Temporary receiver for a New York LLC: how to ask a court to put company money under a receiver's control while the case goes on.
Frequently asked questions
What is the statute of limitations for breach of fiduciary duty in New York?
Three years for money damages (CPLR 214(4)) and six years for genuinely equitable relief such as an accounting (CPLR 213(1)). A corporation's own or derivative claim against its directors, officers or stockholders for an accounting, waste or injury to corporate property has six years (CPLR 213(7)). If fraud is essential, it is the greater of six years from accrual or two years from discovery (CPLR 213(8)).
Can an LLC member sue for breach of fiduciary duty?
Yes. A member can sue a manager or managing member who breaches LLC Law § 409. If the harm is to the company, the member usually sues derivatively on the LLC's behalf.
How do you sue for breach of fiduciary duty in New York?
Most cases start with a complaint in New York State Supreme Court, often in its Commercial Division, or in arbitration if the agreement requires it. Discovery reaches the bank records, ledgers and emails. If the other side is moving the money or property in dispute or using company information to take clients, a court can grant a temporary restraining order or preliminary injunction early, but only on a showing of a likely claim and harm money alone cannot repair (CPLR 6301).
Can you get punitive damages for breach of fiduciary duty?
Sometimes, but only when the conduct is especially egregious, such as intentional or malicious wrongdoing that goes beyond the breach itself. Courts describe the exact standard differently. In most cases the recovery is compensatory damages and the return of improper gains.
Can a third party be liable for aiding and abetting a breach of fiduciary duty in New York?
Yes. A third party, such as a related company that takes diverted business, can be liable if it actually knew of the breach and gave substantial assistance in carrying it out. You must also prove the underlying breach and resulting damages.
Is breach of fiduciary duty a crime in New York?
No, it is a civil claim, and a criminal case is a separate track. The same conduct can also be a crime, such as embezzlement or obtaining property by false pretenses, both forms of larceny under Penal Law § 155.05.
Is breach of fiduciary duty a tort or a contract claim?
It is a tort claim arising from the relationship of trust, though an agreement often creates the relationship. A fiduciary claim that only repeats a breach of contract claim is usually dismissed.
Is breach of fiduciary duty the same as fraud?
No. A fiduciary can breach the duty without any lie, for example by quietly dealing with themselves. When deception is essential to the claim, the fraud period in CPLR 213(8) can apply.
If a partner, LLC manager, director, officer or employee has put their own interests ahead of the business, or you have been accused of doing so, contact the office or call (646) 992-2138 for a free consultation with Reza Yassi.

