
Business Tort Lawyer in New York City
New York law on interference, unfair competition, conversion and deceptive practices


Business Torts
Yassi Law P.C. brings and defends business tort claims in New York: lawsuits over a rival who induced your customer to break a contract, sabotaged a deal through wrongful means or passed off goods as yours, and conversion claims over equipment, records, goods or money someone took or kept. Attorney Reza Yassi handles each case himself, throughout New York City and in Nassau and Suffolk Counties.
What is a business tort, and what is business tort litigation?
A business tort is a civil wrong that harms a company's contracts, customer relationships, reputation, property or position in the market. Business tort litigation is the lawsuit over that wrong, seeking damages, the return of property or an order to stop it. "Commercial tort claim" is a related, broader term: the Uniform Commercial Code uses it for almost any tort claim a company holds (UCC § 9-102(a)(13)). Common examples in New York:
Tortious interference with a contract: inducing someone to break a contract with you.
Interference with business relations: using wrongful means to sabotage a deal or customer relationship with no binding contract.
Unfair competition: passing off goods as yours, or exploiting your work and investment in bad faith.
Conversion: taking or keeping your personal property, such as equipment, goods or records, without authority, including a specific, identifiable fund of money.
Deceptive business practices under General Business Law § 349.
Fraud and misrepresentation claims and breach of fiduciary duty.
A broken contract is not a tort by itself: courts dismiss a tort claim that only restates a contract claim. So a tort claim against an outsider often travels with a breach of contract claim against the party who broke the deal.
These cases are part of our commercial litigation practice. Depending on the parties and the contract, a business tort case is heard in New York State Supreme Court (often in its Commercial Division), in federal court in Manhattan or Brooklyn (S.D.N.Y. and E.D.N.Y.), or in arbitration.
Can you sue someone for ruining your business?
Yes, if the person used a wrong the law recognizes. Losing customers to a rival who offers better prices or service is lawful competition, not a tort, unless the rival knowingly induces a customer to break a binding contract. The facts usually point to the claim:
Your customer or supplier broke a binding contract after a rival talked it into doing so: interference with contract.
A deal collapsed because someone lied to or threatened the other side: interference with business relations.
Someone sold goods as if they were yours, or deliberately exploited the fruits of your work in bad faith: unfair competition.
Someone took or kept your equipment, goods or records, or a specific, identifiable fund of your money: conversion. Failing to pay a debt is a contract claim, not conversion.
Trying to ruin a business is not enough on its own. To recover money, you generally must show the conduct actually caused a measurable loss.
What is tortious interference with contract? The elements in New York
Tortious interference with contract is when someone who knows about your contract intentionally gets the other party to break it, without justification, and you lose money as a result. In New York you must prove five elements (Lama Holding Co. v. Smith Barney Inc., 88 N.Y.2d 413 (1996)):
A valid contract between you and a third party.
The defendant knew about that contract.
The defendant intentionally procured the third party's breach, without justification.
The third party actually breached the contract.
You were damaged as a result.
Tortious interference is intentional: carelessness does not qualify, and without an actual breach the claim fails. If the customer or supplier could end the contract at will and simply ended it, the stricter wrongful-means standard below applies.
How to prove tortious interference
You prove tortious interference mostly with documents and timing, because defendants rarely admit knowing about the contract or intending a breach. Useful proof includes:
The contract and the breach notice or termination letter
Messages between the defendant and the party who breached
Evidence the defendant knew of the contract
How quickly the breach followed the defendant's contact
Sales records showing what the breach cost you
Tortious interference with business relations when there is no contract
When no binding contract was broken, or the contract could be ended at will, the law requires more. Under the Court of Appeals' decision in Carvel Corp. v. Noonan, 3 N.Y.3d 182 (2004), and the cases applying it, you generally must show:
You had a business relationship, or a likely deal, with a third party.
The defendant led that third party not to deal with you.
The defendant used wrongful means, generally a crime or an independent tort such as fraud, misrepresentation, physical violence or baseless lawsuits, or acted solely to harm you.
The wrongful conduct was aimed at the third party, not only at you.
You lost the relationship or deal as a result.
Persuasion alone and normal economic self-interest, such as offering your customer a better price, are not wrongful means.
Courts also call this interference with prospective economic advantage or prospective business relations. Interference with employment follows the same split: a breached employment contract uses the elements above; at-will jobs use the stricter test.
For a deal that was never signed, see tortious interference with prospective business relations in New York.
Unfair competition and deceptive business practices
New York common law recognizes two kinds of unfair competition. Passing off is selling one company's goods as another's, and it can apply even when the two businesses do not compete. Misappropriation is deliberately taking, in bad faith, the results of another business's skill, spending and labor, or goodwill or another commercial advantage that belongs to it, and using it to compete.
Stolen client lists and departing employees are covered on our trade secrets and unfair competition page.
General Business Law § 349 now lets the Attorney General act against unfair, deceptive or abusive practices. A private person or business injured by a deceptive act or practice may sue for an injunction, for actual damages or $50 (whichever is greater), or both. For willful or knowing violations, the court may increase damages up to three times actual damages, capped at $1,000. The court may also award reasonable attorney's fees to a winning plaintiff.
Courts have required deception that is consumer-oriented, with a broader impact on consumers at large, and misleading in a material way, and that actually caused your injury, so a private contract dispute between two businesses usually does not qualify.
Deadlines for business tort claims in New York
Most interference and conversion claims have three years, but each claim has its own clock:
Tortious interference: three years (CPLR 214(4)), starting when you actually sustain damages, which is often but not always the date of the breach, not when the defendant acted or when you found out. If the interference consisted of false statements that harmed your reputation, courts treat the claim as defamation, with the one-year deadline (CPLR 215(3)).
Conversion: three years (CPLR 214(3)).
Deceptive practices under General Business Law § 349: three years from when you were injured (CPLR 214(2)).
Fraud: the later of six years after the fraud or two years after you found it or should have (CPLR 213(8)).
Unfair competition: no single deadline; it depends on the claim and the relief sought.
If you are sued in New York State court: you have 20 days to answer or appear when personally served in New York, and usually 30 days after other service (CPLR 320(a)).
How much can you sue for? Damages and court orders
There is no fixed amount. You recover the losses you prove the wrong caused, such as lost profits on a broken contract or the value of converted property. Lost profits must be proved with reasonable certainty: for an unsigned deal, you must show it would have closed but for the defendant's wrongful conduct.
When the harm is ongoing, you can ask the court to stop it before trial with a temporary restraining order and a preliminary injunction (CPLR 6301). Courts generally require a likelihood of success, harm that money damages cannot repair (a loss easily measured in dollars usually does not qualify) and a balance of the equities in your favor. You must also post an undertaking to cover the defendant's damages if it is finally decided you were not entitled to the injunction (CPLR 6312(b)).
If your business is accused of a business tort
A business accused of a business tort can defend on several common grounds:
Lawful competition and economic self-interest are not wrongful means when no binding contract was broken.
No binding contract was actually breached, or you did not know of it.
The claim only restates a contract dispute.
The deadline has passed.
Do not let the answer deadline pass (in state court, CPLR 320(a)), and preserve your own records.
How Reza Yassi handles a business tort case, and what it costs
Reza Yassi handles each step himself. Most commercial matters are billed hourly ($450 an hour) under a written engagement letter. The usual steps:
Review the contracts, messages and timeline to see which claims, if any, the facts support.
Preserve evidence and, where it helps, send a demand or cease-and-desist letter.
Seek emergency relief when customers, data or property are being taken now.
Negotiate, or litigate through discovery and trial.
Enforce and collect any judgment.
Contingency or hybrid fees are offered only as exceptions in special cases, and the first consultation is free.
Bring the contract, your messages with the lost customer or partner, and sales records from before and after the loss.
Guides on this topic
Tortious interference with contract in New York: how a business proves, or defends against, a claim that an outsider induced the other party to break its contract.
Tortious interference with prospective business relations in New York: what you must show when a competitor or outsider sabotages a deal that was never signed.
Conversion claims in New York: how to recover money, property or business assets someone took or kept without the right to.
Frequently asked questions
Is tortious interference a crime?
No. It is a civil claim for money damages or a court order. The wrongful means behind it, such as fraud or threats, can also be crimes, which a prosecutor handles separately.
What are the elements of tortious interference in New York?
A valid contract, the defendant's knowledge of it, intentional procurement of a breach without justification, an actual breach, and damages. Without a binding contract, or if it could be ended at will, you generally must show a crime, an independent tort or a sole purpose to harm you.
Does tortious interference require intent, and is it hard to prove?
Yes, it is an intentional tort; carelessness is not enough. It can be hard to prove because defendants rarely admit it, so the case is usually built from emails, timing and the breach itself.
What is the statute of limitations for tortious interference in New York?
Three years under CPLR 214(4), running from when you actually sustain damages, which is often the date of the breach but can be later. If the claim really complains of false statements that hurt your reputation, courts apply the one-year defamation deadline (CPLR 215(3)).
Can I sue someone for taking my company's money or property?
Yes, through a conversion claim, if someone took or kept your company's personal property (such as equipment, inventory or business records, including electronic records) or a specific, identifiable fund of your money without authority; an unpaid debt is a contract claim instead. If a partner, manager or employee took it, a breach of fiduciary duty claim may also apply. The deadline for conversion is three years (CPLR 214(3)).
Is tortious interference covered by insurance?
It depends on the wording of your policies. Give your carrier written notice as soon as you receive a demand or are sued, so coverage is not lost by delay.
If a rival has cost you a contract, customer or deal, someone has taken or kept your company's equipment, records or money, or your business stands accused of doing so, gather the key documents and a short timeline. Then contact the office or call (646) 992-2138 for a free consultation with Reza Yassi.

