top of page
  • Writer's pictureReza Yassi

Winning Justice for Hip Injuries: Understanding The True Value Of Severe Hip Injuries

An illustration depicting an elderly person sitting on the ground next to a tipped-over wheelchair, holding their hip in a gesture of pain. The setting is an outdoor environment, suggesting a calm and serene atmosphere despite the distressing situation. The person is dressed in comfortable, casual attire, suitable for their age, emphasizing the suddenness of the fall. The scene conveys a sense of urgency for assistance and care, rendered in a respectful and empathetic manner

Hip injuries requiring hip replacements are among the most undervalued cases in personal injury law, often because they predominantly affect elderly individuals. Unfortunately, the age of these individuals tends to unjustly decrease the perceived value of their judgments and the true value of hip Injuries. However, as the case of Romano v. Clove Lakes Health Care and Rehabilitation Center, Inc. vividly demonstrates, the consequences of a hip replacement can extend far beyond the surgery itself, leading to severe pain, suffering, and complex medical complications. These outcomes highlight a crucial aspect often overlooked: the profound impact on an individual's quality of life and the significant need for legal recognition and appropriate compensation. Through an exploration of this recent 2nd department case, we uncover the critical importance of advocating for the rights of those suffering from hip injuries and the role of specialized legal expertise in ensuring their voices are heard and respected in the courtroom.

Understanding The True Value of Hip Injuries: The Jury Decision

In Romano, the plaintiff suffered a life-altering injury that underscores the necessity of seeking an experienced hip injury attorney. At the venerable age of 85 and contending with Parkinson's disease, the plaintiff endured a catastrophic fall from a wheelchair while under the defendant's care, culminating in a hip fracture and the need for hip replacement surgery. The ensuing pain, loss of mobility, and a precipitous decline in life quality starkly underscore the dire consequences stemming from his healthcare provider’s alleged negligence.

The journey to justice for the plaintiff began in 2014, culminating five years later in a landmark jury verdict that awarded a substantial sum of $6 million for pain and suffering. This significant judgment acknowledges not just the monetary costs but also the profound physical and emotional toll that such injuries inflict. Despite the substantial verdict in 2019, which underscored the severity of the plaintiff's experience, the legal battle did not conclude there.

Understanding The True Value of Hip Injuries: The Lower Court's Modification

The defendant contested the jury's verdict as excessive under CPLR 4404 (a), prompting the Supreme Court to reassess the award. The court agreed with the Defendant that the verdict was excessive in nature and ordered a new trial unless Romano agreed to a reduced verdict of $500,000. However, The case's journey did not end with the Supreme Court's decision.

Understanding The True Value of Hip Injuries: Appellate Court's Modification

Both parties appealed to the appellate court in 2023 to review the lower court's modification, ultimately adjusting the award upwards but still below the jury's original decision. Specifically, the appellate court ordered a new trial unless the parties agreed to a stipulated reduction of the award to $1,000,000.

The appellate court's rationale — considering the extent of the decedent's injuries, the necessity of extensive rehabilitation, and the impact on quality of life — provides crucial insights for those embroiled in or considering legal action for hip surgery lawsuits.

Although the second department overturned the lower Court, the outcome of the case is still a major reduction of the Jury's original award of $6,000,000 to $1,000,000.00. Such a reduction not only undermines the jury's authority but also potentially devalues the extensive suffering endured by the plaintiff. It appears that older individuals, who are already more vulnerable to serious injuries like hip fractures, continue to face an uphill battle for fair compensation. This systemic issue suggests a prejudiced viewpoint, one that unjustly penalizes the elderly for their susceptibility to these life-altering injuries. It is a practice that is both unfair and inequitable, and it calls for a re-evaluation of how our courts assess damages in such cases, ensuring that every individual receives the justice and recognition they deserve.

If you or a loved one are seeking a personal injury attorney with specialized experience in handling hip injury cases, you are encouraged to reach out to Yassi Law. With expert knowledge and dedicated resources, Yassi Law is poised to navigate the complexities of your case. At Yassi Law, there is a deep understanding of the significant impact a hip injury can have on your life and the importance of securing the justice and compensation you are entitled to. Contact Yassi Law for adept advice and comprehensive support tailored to the effective handling of your unique situation.




Please be advised that the information provided in this article is for informational and educational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice or establish any attorney-client relationship through your use of this website and its content. While we have made every attempt to ensure that the information in this article has been obtained from reliable sources, we are not responsible for any errors or omissions or the results obtained from using this information. Any liability concerning actions taken or not taken based on the contents of this site is expressly disclaimed. We will not be liable for any losses, injuries, or damages from the display or use of this information.


slider 4.jpg
bottom of page