Before You Accept a Policy Limits Settlement in New York: Costly Mistakes to Avoid With Your Own Auto Policy


Eight months ago, a driver ran the red light at Hylan Boulevard and Richmond Avenue on Staten Island and plowed into your car. You spent weeks in the hospital with a fractured pelvis and a brain injury, and you still can't go back to work. Now the other driver's insurer calls with what sounds like good news: it will pay its full $25,000 limit if you sign a release. Before you accept that policy limits settlement, read one more document first: your own auto policy. One signature in the wrong order can cost you coverage you've paid for every month.
Key takeaways
Don't sign any release from the at-fault driver's insurer until your own auto policy has been reviewed.
Tell your own insurer in writing about a proposed full-limits settlement before you sign anything.
Phone calls and verbal heads-ups to the other side's lawyer don't protect your own coverage.
Notify your own carrier as soon as you learn the other driver's insurance looks too small.
Get medical care right away, because gaps in treatment weaken every part of the claim.
Why is signing the release before telling your own insurer the costliest mistake?
Signing first is the costliest mistake because it can wipe out your own underinsured motorist coverage, which is often the largest pool of money left in a serious injury case. A release is a document that ends your claim against the at-fault driver forever. Once you sign it, the driver is off the hook.
Here's why that matters. According to the New York State DMV, the minimum liability coverage a New York driver must carry is $25,000 for injury to one person. That doesn't come close to covering months in the hospital, years of lost wages, or a lifetime of care after a brain injury. The gap is supposed to be filled by supplementary uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage, usually called SUM. That's coverage you buy on your own policy to protect yourself when the other driver doesn't carry enough insurance.
SUM coverage comes with conditions. One of the most important protects your insurer's subrogation rights. Subrogation means your insurer's right, after it pays you, to step into your shoes and sue the at-fault driver to get its money back. If you sign a general release without protecting that right, you've given away something your carrier was counting on.
What happened when an injured driver signed first?
In Matter of Progressive Cas. Ins. Co. v. Lai, 2026 NY Slip Op 00134 (2d Dep't 2026), the injured woman settled with the at-fault driver for that driver's $100,000 policy limit and signed a release without her own carrier's written consent. She lost her SUM claim. The Appellate Division, Second Department found she couldn't show that her carrier had waived the consent requirement or gone along with the settlement, and the release didn't preserve the carrier's subrogation rights. The trial court had ruled for her. The appeals court reversed and permanently stayed her SUM arbitration.
What safe path have New York's courts recognized?
New York's highest court described the safe path in In re Arbitration between Central Mutual Insurance & Bemiss, 12 N.Y.3d 648 (N.Y. 2009). The standard SUM endorsement (the part of your policy that sets the rules for this coverage) contains a condition covering a full-limits settlement: you give your carrier written notice of the proposed settlement, and if the carrier doesn't respond within 30 days, you may go forward.
Avoiding this mistake is simple in principle. Don't sign anything the other driver's insurer sends until your own policy has been pulled and read, and until your own carrier has received written notice and the response window has run.
Why doesn't a phone call or a verbal heads-up protect your coverage?
A phone call doesn't protect you because courts look for written notice to your own carrier, or written release language that preserves its rights, and a conversation leaves neither behind. This mistake usually happens when everyone means well. The at-fault driver's lawyer knows a bigger claim is coming, someone says so out loud, and the release gets signed on the assumption that everyone understood.
That assumption failed in Davis v. New York Schs. Ins. Reciprocal, 2024 NY Slip Op 00998 (2d Dep't 2024). A bus driver settled with the at-fault driver for her $100,000 limit and signed releases before asking his own SUM carrier for consent. He had $1 million in SUM coverage, and he lost it. His lawyer had told defense counsel orally that a SUM claim would follow, but the court found that wasn't enough: "The plaintiff did not establish that there was an express limitation in the releases he executed in favor of the tortfeasors and their insurance carriers that preserved these subrogation rights."
Compare Matter of Progressive Northwestern Ins. Co. v. Valenti, 2019 NY Slip Op 2101 (2d Dep't 2019). There, the insured's lawyer sent the carrier a letter before settling. The Second Department held that "the letter unambiguously advised Progressive of the insured's intention to settle for the full amount of the tortfeasors' policy and invited Progressive to object." The carrier didn't respond within 30 days, so the insured could settle and still pursue SUM benefits.
To avoid this mistake, put it in writing and send it to the right place. The letter goes to your own insurer, not to the other driver's adjuster or lawyer. It should say plainly that you intend to accept the full policy limits and invite your carrier to object. Keep proof of mailing and delivery, then count the days before anyone signs. Be careful on the phone generally, too; our post on the recorded statement trap explains how casual words come back later.
Who decides whether you lost your coverage?
A judge, not the arbitrator, usually decides whether you forfeited your coverage. Under CPLR § 7503, a party may apply to a court to stay arbitration on the ground that a valid agreement "has not been complied with." In Lai, the Second Department said the policy's arbitration clause couldn't be read to cover whether coverage existed under a claimed exclusion. So the fight over a release signed too early happens in a courtroom, often before anyone discusses what your injuries are worth. The same statute says a party served with a notice of intention to arbitrate must apply for a stay within 20 days or be precluded from certain objections. That rule has limits, though, and it's no substitute for giving proper written notice in the first place.
Why does waiting until the settlement offer to notify your own carrier put your coverage at risk?
Waiting is risky because your carrier can disclaim, meaning formally deny, a SUM claim it says it heard about too late, and the clock may run from when you learned the other driver's coverage was low. Many people think they only need to call their own insurer once the other side puts a number on the table. By then, months may have passed.
That's what happened in Rekemeyer v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance, 4 N.Y.3d 468 (N.Y. 2005). The injured woman told her own carrier about her SUM claim roughly six months after she learned the at-fault driver had only $50,000 in coverage. The Court of Appeals agreed her notice was late. But because she had given her carrier timely notice of the accident itself, it held: "On the facts of this case, we hold that the carrier must show prejudice before it may disclaim coverage due to plaintiffs late notice of SUM claim." Prejudice means real harm to the insurer caused by the delay. The case went back to the lower court so the carrier could try to prove it.
Rekemeyer is a partial rescue, not a safety net. A fight over prejudice takes time, and you can still lose it. Our post on late notice disclaimers on New York SUM claims walks through how carriers make these arguments. The better course is to notify your own carrier in writing as soon as a police report, DMV record, or the other insurer's disclosure shows that the driver's coverage looks small next to your injuries.
Don't confuse notice deadlines with lawsuit deadlines. A claim under your own policy is a contract claim, and CPLR § 213 gives six years for "an action upon a contractual obligation or liability." That long window doesn't stretch the much shorter notice conditions in your policy. Your negligence claim against the driver who hit you generally has a three-year deadline of its own.
Why is it a mistake to treat the at-fault driver's policy as the only money available?
It's a mistake because a serious crash often involves more than one source of insurance, and each one carries conditions you can trip over. Accepting one policy's limits feels like the end of the case. It's often just the first step.
Bemiss shows the problem. The injured woman there had already collected one at-fault driver's full limits. She then settled with a second at-fault driver for less than that driver's limits, without her carrier's written consent and without preserving its subrogation rights. The Court of Appeals held that the conditions still applied, and she lost her SUM claim. The rules don't switch off after the first settlement. They follow every at-fault party.
Depending on the facts, other possible sources of recovery may include:
The vehicle's owner, if the driver was using someone else's car
An employer's commercial policy, if the driver was working at the time
Your own SUM coverage, and possibly a household relative's policy, depending on its terms
A rental or leasing company, in the narrow situations federal law still allows
That last route is limited; our post on the Graves Amendment and rental car liability explains when it applies. Each source matters because catastrophic injuries are expensive. NHTSA estimated that motor vehicle crashes in the United States cost $340 billion in economic losses in 2019, counting medical care, lost productivity, and property damage. The CDC explains that a traumatic brain injury can affect thinking, memory, movement, and emotions long after the crash. A $25,000 policy barely touches those costs. Our guide to UM and UIM rights in New York explains how your own coverage fits alongside the other driver's, and our GEICO claims warning covers one major carrier's claim habits.
Why does waiting to see a doctor weaken a claim that's already short on insurance?
Waiting to get medical treatment is a serious mistake, because the longer the gap between the accident and your first visit, the harder it is to prove the accident caused your injuries, and the less believable the claim becomes to an insurer or a jury. That's true against the at-fault driver. It's just as true later, when your own carrier values your SUM claim.
Picture a delivery worker rear-ended on the Bruckner Expressway in the Bronx. He feels dizzy but goes back to work, hoping it passes. Three weeks later, headaches and memory lapses finally send him to a neurologist, and every insurer reading his file will ask what else happened in those three weeks.
Medical records also drive New York's threshold rules. No-fault pays your own medical bills and lost wages up to set limits; under Insurance Law § 5102(a), "basic economic loss" covers up to $50,000 per person. To recover for pain and suffering against another covered driver, Insurance Law § 5104(a) requires a serious injury, and the fact-finder must now decide who was at fault before deciding whether the injury is serious. Fault matters more than it used to: for no-fault cases started on or after May 26, 2026, CPLR § 1411 bars recovery when your share of fault is greater than the defendants'. Prompt, consistent treatment records are your best proof on both questions.
Speed matters for evidence too. Almost every storefront in the city has a security camera, and footage is often recorded over within days or weeks. When contacted early, Yassi Law PC can use preservation letters, subpoenas, and FOIL requests (Freedom of Information Law requests to government agencies) to get the video before it's gone. Ask for the police report and 911 records, and ask nearby businesses in writing to save their footage.
What other questions do people ask about a policy limits settlement?
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I accept the at-fault driver's full policy limits and still claim under my own auto policy?
Often yes, if you follow your own policy's conditions first. In Bemiss, New York's highest court described a route for full-limits settlements: written notice to your own carrier of the proposed settlement, and no response from the carrier within 30 days. Have your policy reviewed before you sign so you know exactly what it requires.
What if I already signed a release from the other driver's insurer?
Speak with a lawyer right away and gather every document you signed and every letter you sent. In the 2026 Lai decision, the court looked at whether the carrier waived its consent rights or went along with the settlement, and whether the release preserved its subrogation rights. The answer depends heavily on the exact paperwork.
Does my own insurer pay an underinsured claim automatically?
No. You generally must give notice and prove your claim, and many New York policies send the value dispute to arbitration. If the carrier says you broke a policy condition, it can ask a court to stay that arbitration under CPLR 7503, so the coverage question is decided before your damages are.
How long do I have to act after a serious crash?
Your negligence lawsuit against the at-fault driver generally must be filed within three years, and a contract claim under your own policy falls under CPLR 213's six-year rule. Your policy's notice conditions are far shorter, and the Rekemeyer case shows that a six-month delay was found late. Notify your own carrier in writing as soon as the other driver's coverage looks too small.
A policy limits settlement offer can feel like the finish line, but in a serious injury case it's often the moment your own coverage is most at risk. Read your policy, notify your own carrier in writing, and let the response window run before you sign anything.
If you or someone you know has been offered the at-fault driver's policy limits after a serious New York crash, Reza Yassi at Yassi Law PC is ready to help. Call us today at 646-992-2138 for a consultation.
Written by Reza Yassi | LinkedIn
Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Although I am an attorney, I am not your attorney, and reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws vary by jurisdiction and may have changed since the publication of this article. For advice specific to your situation, consult a qualified attorney.


.png)