CPLR 3213 Summary Judgment in Lieu of Complaint: Myths About Fast-Track Collection on NYC Promissory Notes and Personal Guarantees


Many New York lenders and business sellers assume that collecting on a defaulted promissory note means filing a complaint, sitting through discovery, and waiting years for a trial. That isn't how it has to work. When the debt rests on the right kind of document, CPLR 3213 summary judgment in lieu of complaint lets the holder skip the complaint entirely and ask for judgment with the very first papers served. Guarantors often get a second surprise: the defenses they planned to raise were waived on the signature page of their personal guarantee.
Key takeaways
A CPLR 3213 motion skips the complaint and asks for judgment immediately, but only on instruments requiring the payment of money alone.
If proving the debt takes evidence beyond the document and nonpayment, the case usually goes to the regular litigation track.
An absolute and unconditional guarantee usually defeats fraudulent inducement defenses based on promises outside the document, and an express waiver clause usually bars setoff, so read it closely before you sign.
Narrow defenses still work, including payment, forgery, criminal usury and defective service, but each needs real evidence.
Waiting on promises to pay gives a debtor time to move assets, so act early on either side of the deal.
Can You Use CPLR 3213 to Collect Any Unpaid Business Debt?
No. Under CPLR § 3213, the shortcut is available only when the action is based upon an instrument for the payment of money only or upon a judgment. Everything else, from an unpaid invoice to a broken supply contract, goes through the ordinary process of complaint, answer and discovery.
The Court of Appeals set the test in Weissman v. Sinorm Deli, Inc., 88 N.Y.2d 437 (1996). A document qualifies if the plaintiff can make out its case with the instrument itself and proof that the payments it calls for weren't made. It doesn't qualify if the court needs outside proof, other than simple proof of nonpayment or a similar minor deviation from the face of the document. In Weissman, a corporation bought out one shareholder's interest and gave him a promissory note that only the corporation signed. When the note went unpaid, he sued the remaining individual shareholders on an indemnification agreement. That agreement covered unstated and future liabilities that could only be ascertained with evidence outside the document. The Court held the expedited procedure didn't fit.
In practical terms, qualifying instruments say: pay this amount, on these dates, no strings attached. Think of a $2.4 million seller-financing note signed by the buyer of a Queens wholesale food distributor, a $5 million term note from a regional bank to a Long Island City manufacturer, or an installment note given to buy out a departing partner in a Midtown accounting firm. Each is an unconditional promise to pay money, and nonpayment is the whole case.
Commercial leases, supply agreements and construction contracts usually don't qualify, because the right to payment is bound up with the other side's own performance. The same goes for a note whose payments depend on something happening under a related agreement. If a seller-financing note says payments drop when the business misses revenue targets, or the note is tied to an earn-out in the asset purchase agreement, the judge will likely have to look beyond the note. That generally ends the 3213 route.
Personal guarantees usually qualify, with one big caveat
An unconditional guarantee of payment of a fixed debt generally qualifies, because the lender can prove its case with the guarantee, the underlying note and evidence that no one paid. Trouble starts when the guarantor's liability can't be measured without digging into another contract. A good guy guarantee on a SoHo retail lease is a common example: whether the guarantor owes anything often turns on when the tenant surrendered the space and in what condition, which the guarantee itself can't prove.
Does a CPLR 3213 Motion Really Move Faster Than an Ordinary Lawsuit?
Usually, yes, because the motion is served with the summons and the whole case can be decided on the papers. With CPLR 3213 summary judgment in lieu of complaint, the plaintiff doesn't draft a complaint, the defendant doesn't serve an answer, and there's typically no discovery before the judge rules.
The statute sets the timing. The return date must give the defendant at least the time to appear under CPLR 320(a): 20 days after service when the summons is personally delivered within New York, and 30 days after service is complete for other methods. Those other methods include personal delivery outside the state, substituted service and nail-and-mail service under CPLR 308. A plaintiff who picks a later hearing date can require the defendant to serve answering papers in advance, up to ten days before the hearing. CPLR 3213 also bars a default judgment under CPLR 3215(a) before the hearing date, so a defendant who stays silent still faces a judge reviewing the motion rather than a clerk's default.
Compare that with the ordinary track. Under CPLR 3212(a), a party can't move for summary judgment until issue has been joined, and if the court sets no other date, the motion is due no later than 120 days after the note of issue is filed. In practice, that means months of pleadings and discovery in Manhattan or Brooklyn Supreme Court before a judge asks whether there's any real defense. With 3213, the question gets asked at the start.
Because a 3213 motion is a summary judgment motion, the court can also split the issues. CPLR 3212(e) permits judgment on part of a claim, such as the unpaid principal, with the rest severed or held in abeyance. Under CPLR 3212(c), if the only triable issue is the amount of damages, the court can order an immediate trial on that point. A fight over the attorney's fees owed under the note doesn't have to hold up judgment on the principal.
What happens if the judge says no?
If the motion is denied, the statute provides that the moving and answering papers are deemed the complaint and answer, unless the court orders otherwise. The case doesn't end. It moves onto the regular litigation track with the motion papers standing in as pleadings.
That rule has a consequence borrowers and guarantors tend to overlook. Your opposition papers may become your answer, so draft them like one. Objections to personal jurisdiction, defective service and affirmative defenses belong in those papers, because a defense left out of a document that later functions as your answer invites a waiver argument. On the lender's side, a return date that gives the defendant less than the statutory minimum is a recurring and avoidable reason these motions fail. Count from the date service is actually complete. For substituted service, that's ten days after proof of service is filed, not the day the process server rang the bell.
Can a Guarantor Defeat a 3213 Motion by Claiming Fraudulent Inducement?
Usually not, when the guarantee is absolute and unconditional and the guarantor is a sophisticated business party. New York's highest court has enforced that language for decades and treats the waiver as a deliberate bargain the guarantor made to get the loan.
The leading case is Citibank, N.A. v. Plapinger, 66 N.Y.2d 90 (1985). The guarantors claimed they signed because the bank orally promised additional financing that never came. The Court of Appeals held they couldn't use that alleged fraud to escape a guarantee they'd made absolute and unconditional, in a document that said nothing about the supposed promise. Sophisticated parties, the Court reasoned, can't sign away defenses in writing and then claim they relied on assurances the document didn't contain.
The Court returned to the point in Cooperatieve Centrale Raiffeisen-Boerenleenbank, B.A. v. Navarro, 25 N.Y.3d 485 (2015). It described a lender's burden on a guarantee as proof of the existence of the guaranty, the underlying debt, and the guarantor's failure to perform. It then held that the guarantor's broad waiver barred the defenses he raised. For a lender, that's a short list of proof. For a guarantor, it means the fight is over what the document says, not what the loan officer said at the closing table.
The same logic usually reaches setoff and counterclaims. Many commercial guarantees state that the guarantor waives any right of setoff or counterclaim. Say you guaranteed a $3 million loan to your Brooklyn restaurant group and believe the bank mishandled a related credit line. A clause like that typically means you'll pursue that grievance, if at all, in a separate action while the lender takes its judgment. This mirrors the rule that a specific disclaimer can defeat a fraud claim, covered in our post on enforcing a New York merger clause under the Danann Realty rule. For situations where a fraud claim does survive, see fraudulent inducement in New York contract disputes. Oral side deals also run into the parol evidence rule, which generally keeps earlier oral understandings from varying an unambiguous written contract.
The writing requirement cuts both ways. Under GOL § 5-701(a)(2), a special promise to answer for the debt, default or miscarriage of another person is void unless it, or some note or memorandum of it, is in writing and subscribed by the party to be charged. A lender can't hold you to a guarantee you only made orally. Once you sign, though, the written terms control.
Does an Absolute and Unconditional Guarantee Leave the Guarantor With No Defenses at All?
No, but the defenses that survive are narrow, and they need evidence rather than adjectives. Under CPLR 3212(b), the motion must be denied if any party shows facts sufficient to require a trial of any issue of fact. A conclusory affidavit saying the lender acted in bad faith won't get there. Documents and specific facts from someone with personal knowledge might. The defenses that most often send a case to the regular track are these:
Payment or discharge. Proof that the debt was paid, settled or released in writing.
You didn't sign it. A forged signature, or a signature by someone with no authority to bind you.
The instrument doesn't qualify. Liability can't be shown without outside proof under the Weissman test.
Criminal usury. The loan carried an effective interest rate above the criminal threshold.
No jurisdiction or defective service. The court never properly acquired jurisdiction over you.
Criminal usury deserves a closer look because it can wipe out the debt itself. Under Penal Law § 190.40, knowingly charging interest at a rate exceeding 25% per annum is criminal usury. In Adar Bays, LLC v. GeneSYS ID, Inc., 37 N.Y.3d 320 (2021), the Court of Appeals held that a criminally usurious loan is void ab initio when a corporate borrower successfully raises the defense. Short-term bridge loans built with steep fees and discounts can raise the question, though courts look hard at whether the deal was really a loan at all.
Disputes over the amount are a weaker defense than many guarantors expect. If the only real question is how much is owed, the court can grant judgment on liability and order a prompt hearing on the number. A genuine accounting problem, like proof that the lender misapplied payments, can still matter. It has to be shown with records.
Guarantors also argue that the lender and borrower changed the loan without the guarantor's consent. Under general guaranty law, a material change to the underlying obligation made without the guarantor's consent can discharge the guarantor. Most commercial guarantees, however, include advance consent to amendments, extensions and waivers, which is why this defense so often fails.
Should You Wait to See Whether the Borrower Pays Before You Sue on the Note?
No. Waiting almost always helps the debtor, not you. Note holders and lenders often get strung along by promises that a payment is coming next week or that a refinancing is about to close. Those promises rarely come true, and the delay gives the other side time to move assets out of the company or out of their own name before a lawsuit begins.
The statute of limitations isn't the real deadline. Under CPLR § 213(2), an action upon a contractual obligation generally must be commenced within six years. That's a long runway, but bank accounts and receivables don't sit still for six years. A seller who waits 18 months on a $4 million note from the buyer of his Nassau County HVAC business may find the buyer's operating company emptied by the time the court rules. A judgment is only as good as the assets it can reach.
The economics favor moving promptly, too. Under CPLR § 5001, interest is recovered on a sum awarded for breach of performance of a contract, computed from the earliest ascertainable date the cause of action existed. Where a note sets its own rate, that contract rate generally governs until judgment, as explained in our post on prejudgment interest in New York contract cases. Most well-drafted notes and guarantees also shift fees to the defaulting party; see recovering attorney's fees in New York contract cases.
When your gut tells you a deal is going south, act on it. Bringing in a lawyer early often sends the other side a clear message that the delays have to stop. Guarantors face an even tighter clock: once a 3213 motion is served, you may have as few as 20 days to put in sworn opposition that could become your answer.
What if the guarantor lives outside New York?
On larger deals, the General Obligations Law gives lenders a strong hand. GOL § 5-1401 lets parties to a transaction covering at least $250,000 choose New York law whether or not the deal bears a reasonable relation to the state. GOL § 5-1402 goes further: where the transaction covers at least $1 million, New York law was chosen under § 5-1401, and the non-resident agreed to submit to New York jurisdiction, the action can be maintained here. A Short Hills, New Jersey guarantor who signed that kind of guarantee for a Manhattan building loan will generally be answering the motion at 60 Centre Street. Our post on choice of law clauses in New York commercial contracts explains how these provisions work together.
What Else Do Lenders and Guarantors Ask About CPLR 3213?
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use CPLR 3213 to collect unpaid rent from a commercial tenant?
Usually not against the tenant, because a lease involves obligations running both ways and isn't an instrument for the payment of money only. A separate guarantee of the rent may qualify if it's an unconditional guarantee of payment, but guarantees whose liability depends on lease events, like good guy guarantees, often don't.
What happens if the court denies a 3213 motion?
The case continues. Unless the court orders otherwise, the motion papers become the complaint and the opposition becomes the answer, and the action proceeds through discovery like any other lawsuit.
How long does a lender have to sue on a defaulted promissory note?
Contract claims generally carry a six-year limitations period under CPLR 213. For installment notes, each missed payment typically starts its own clock, while acceleration can make the entire balance due at once. Waiting close to the deadline is rarely wise, since collectability tends to shrink over time.
Can a 3213 judgment be entered against an out-of-state judgment debtor?
CPLR 3213 also covers actions based upon any judgment, so a creditor holding a judgment from another state's court can use the expedited motion to obtain a New York judgment. The defendant still has to be properly served and subject to the court's jurisdiction.
CPLR 3213 summary judgment in lieu of complaint is a powerful tool, but it only fits instruments that promise money and nothing else. For lenders, the key is choosing the right instrument and getting the return date right. For guarantors, it's knowing that an unconditional guarantee waives most defenses, and building the narrow ones that remain with real evidence.
If you or your business holds a defaulted promissory note or personal guarantee, or you've been served with a CPLR 3213 motion, Reza Yassi at Yassi Law PC is ready to help. Call us today at 646-992-2138 for a consultation.
Written by Reza Yassi | LinkedIn
Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Although I am an attorney, I am not your attorney, and reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws vary by jurisdiction and may have changed since the publication of this article. For advice specific to your situation, consult a qualified attorney.


.png)