top of page

CPLR 4545 Collateral Source Hearing Mistakes: How New York Defendants Try to Cut Catastrophic Injury Awards After the Verdict

Writer: Reza Yassi
Reza Yassi
Nov 8
10 min read
CPLR 4545 Collateral Source Hearing Mistakes: How New York Defendants Try to Cut Catastrophic Injury Awards After the Verdict

A driver runs the red light on Northern Boulevard in Flushing and slams into your door. The crash shatters your pelvis and hip, and your surgeons warn that you'll need a joint replacement, revision surgeries, and years of therapy. After a two-week trial in Queens County Supreme Court, a jury awards you millions for future medical care, built line by line from your life-care plan. A month later, the defense asks the judge for a CPLR 4545 collateral source hearing, arguing that health insurance you don't even have yet will pay those bills and the award should shrink.


Key takeaways


  • The jury never hears about your insurance, because a judge decides any collateral source reduction after the verdict.

  • The defense must prove with reasonable certainty that a specific benefit will pay a specific item of your award.

  • Life insurance, benefits that a law requires to be paid back out of your recovery, and charitable gifts like a GoFundMe cannot be used to reduce your award.

  • A detailed, itemized life-care plan and careful economic testimony make future medical damages much harder to cut.

  • Settlements never go through a collateral source hearing, which is one factor in deciding whether to settle or go to trial.


Why is it a mistake to think the jury's verdict is the final number?


It's a mistake because New York lets the judge reduce parts of your award after the jury goes home. Under CPLR § 4545, when you seek the cost of medical care, custodial care, rehabilitation, lost earnings, or other economic loss, the defendant may offer evidence that those costs were or will be, "with reasonable certainty," replaced by a collateral source. A collateral source is money that comes from someone other than the defendant, such as a health insurer, a disability plan, or a pension.


The statute says any deduction is made by the trial court after the verdict. That's why the jury never hears about your insurance. You can prove every dollar of your losses at trial, and the insurance fight happens later in written motions and, sometimes, a separate hearing. Defendants often file this request alongside a motion under CPLR 4404 asking the judge to set aside the verdict or order a new trial.


Who has to prove that insurance will pay?


The defendant does, and the bar is high. In Oden v. Chemung County Industrial Development Agency, 87 N.Y.2d 81 (N.Y. 1995), the Court of Appeals held that the statute departs from the old common-law rule and must be read strictly. The court was direct: "The burden of establishing the requisite correspondence rests, of course, on the party seeking the CPLR 4545 (c) offset." That case applied an earlier numbering of the statute, but the burden still sits with the defense.


Pain and suffering isn't on the statute's list at all. The hearing can only reach economic categories, so the part of your verdict for physical pain, emotional harm, and lost enjoyment of life can't be cut this way.


A CPLR 4545 collateral source hearing only exists after a verdict. A negotiated settlement never goes through one, and that's a quiet factor in the choice between settling and going to trial. Most cases should settle, especially given how long New York cases take, and taking a little less now can be worth more than waiting years. But some cases are worth more than an insurer will pay without a trial. If yours is one of them, you need to be ready for a long fight that can continue months after the jury speaks.


After any reduction, CPLR § 5041(a) directs the court to apply set-offs and credits to the jury's findings before calculating what the defendant must pay. The hearing's outcome flows directly into how your judgment is structured.


Why does a vague life-care plan make your future medical award easier to cut?


A vague plan makes cutting easier because the law only lets the defense offset a benefit against the specific category of loss it actually replaces. In Oden, a disability pension was allowed to erase the jury's award for the worker's lost pension, but not the separate award for his lost future earnings. When the link between a payment and an item of loss is thin, the court said, "the purposes of the statute would not be served by applying the mandatory offset."


A life-care plan is a written roadmap, usually prepared by a nurse or physician planner, that lists every treatment, device, and service you'll need for life, how often, and at what cost. A strong plan separates future surgeries from medications, therapy, home health aides, equipment, and home modifications. When the verdict sheet follows those same lines, each one must be fought separately. In medical malpractice cases, CPLR 4111(d) requires the jury to itemize each element of damages and split it into past and future amounts.


Line-by-line matters because much of what a catastrophically injured person needs falls outside ordinary health coverage. Medicare.gov explains that Medicare doesn't cover long-term custodial care, meaning help with bathing, dressing, and similar daily tasks, when that's the only care you need. A defense economist who says "insurance covers it" has to show which policy pays for which line. A home aide in Bay Ridge or a wheelchair-accessible van in Hicksville may not fit any policy at all.


Recent appeals show how a solid plan holds up. In Dowdy v. Brooklyn Hosp. Ctr., 2026 NY Slip Op 02630 (2d Dep't 2026), the Second Department affirmed a $1.1 million future medical award supported by the plaintiff's life-care plan and agreed that no collateral source hearing was needed.


To avoid this mistake, the planner should build each line from your treating doctors' recommendations, because testimony from the surgeon who operated on you carries weight a hired reviewer can't match. For a closer look at how these plans are priced, see how a life-care plan prices decades of future treatment. Day-in-the-life videos can also show the jury why each line exists.


Why is it a mistake to assume an uninsured plaintiff can't face an insurance offset?


It's a mistake because defendants now argue that health insurance you could buy under the Affordable Care Act should shrink your future medical award, even if you've never owned a policy. In New York, those plans are sold through NY State of Health, the state's official marketplace. The defense theory is simple: you'll enroll, the plan will pay, and the defendant shouldn't have to.


That argument gained real traction in Liciaga v. New York City Tr. Auth., 2024 NY Slip Op 04257 (2d Dep't 2024), where an uninsured plaintiff had won $40 million for future medical care. The defendant submitted an affidavit from an insurance broker naming a specific Marketplace plan and one from an economist calculating an offset of roughly $3.75 million. The Second Department vacated the future medical award pending a hearing, holding that the defendant "should have been afforded the opportunity to offer evidence at a hearing to demonstrate why the plaintiff could be expected to obtain such coverage and whether doing so would, with reasonable certainty, reduce his out-of-pocket costs for future medical expenses." The court took no position on how that hearing should come out.


Generic claims don't get that far. In Sinera v. Bedford-Webster LLC, 2026 NY Slip Op 03649 (1st Dep't 2026), the First Department refused a hearing where the defendants relied on the plaintiff's Social Security number, which it called "insufficient as it does not demonstrate eligibility for any specific plan, actual enrollment, or extent of coverage." In Dowdy, the Second Department refused a hearing because the defendant offered no evidence that an ACA plan would lower the plaintiff's costs.


How do you answer an ACA offset argument?


You answer it with numbers. The statute requires the court to subtract the premiums you paid for the two years before the claim arose and the projected future cost of keeping the coverage. HealthCare.gov explains that an out-of-pocket maximum is the most you pay for covered services in a plan year, so it applies again every year. Over a 40-year life expectancy, premiums, deductibles, and annual out-of-pocket costs can eat deeply into any claimed savings. Your economist should run that math, and your life-care planner should flag services a Marketplace plan won't cover and specialists outside its network.


Why does letting the defense count benefits you must repay shrink your recovery twice?


It shrinks your recovery twice because you'd lose the money once to the offset and again when the benefit provider collects its repayment. CPLR § 4545 prevents that by excluding life insurance and "those payments as to which there is a statutory right of reimbursement." In plain terms, if a law gives the payer the right to be paid back from your recovery, the defense can't use that payment to cut your award.


Workers' compensation is the clearest example. Suppose you're a home health aide and a poorly maintained staircase collapses under you in a client's building in Long Island City, and you sue the building owner. Under Workers' Compensation Law § 29, the comp carrier generally has a lien on your recovery against that third party for the compensation and medical expenses it paid. Because that money goes back to the carrier, it shouldn't also come off your verdict. (Car crash cases follow special rules, because no-fault insurance changes how much of the carrier's payments it can recover.) In Kihl v. Pfeffer, discussed below, the Second Department described health insurance and workers' compensation benefits that carry no lien as the kind that can be offset, which is the other side of the same rule.


The statute also protects generosity. Under CPLR § 4545(b), voluntary charitable contributions are not a collateral source. If neighbors in Ozone Park raised money for you online, or your parish took up a collection, that money can't be used to reduce your award.


To avoid this mistake, collect every lien letter, reimbursement demand, and benefits statement before the hearing. Each one helps show which payments carry a repayment obligation. Yassi Law PC's guide to medical liens and why your settlement might be lower than expected explains how these claims affect what you actually take home.


Why is it a mistake to accept that today's health plan will cover you for decades?


It's a mistake because the defense must prove your coverage will last as long as your future care, and jobs, marriages, and family plans change. CPLR § 4545 says a court can find future costs will be replaced only if you are legally entitled to keep receiving the benefit under a contract or otherwise enforceable agreement, subject only to paying premiums and similar obligations.


Kihl v. Pfeffer, 47 A.D.3d 154 (2d Dep't 2007) shows how hard that is to prove. The plaintiff won $7.4 million for future medications, and her health coverage came through her husband's job. The court explained that reasonable certainty is close to the clear-and-convincing standard, meaning the reduction must be highly probable. It applied a two-step test: the defense must show you will receive the benefit, and that the benefit matches a specific item of the award. The defense couldn't show the husband would keep that job, or that the coverage would continue, for decades. As the court put it, "Absent the reasonable certainty of collateral source reductions, the statute, to the extent it departs from common law, prefers double recoveries in favor of plaintiffs over the polar alternative of depriving plaintiffs of a compensatory award for economic losses to which the trier of fact found them entitled."


Long careers with one employer are less common than many people assume. The Bureau of Labor Statistics employee tenure data shows the typical worker has been with the current employer for only a few years.


Children get the same protection. In Zhou v. Tuxedo Ridge, LLC, 2020 NY Slip Op 01206 (2d Dep't 2020), the defendants proved a $56,440.22 offset against past medical bills, but the court refused any offset against the injured child's future care because she can't stay on her parents' coverage forever. HealthCare.gov notes that young adults can generally stay on a parent's plan only until age 26. (The judgment in Zhou was reversed on separate liability grounds.) Past bills, already paid and documented, are simply easier to offset than costs stretching across a lifetime.


To avoid this mistake, your evidence should show exactly where your coverage comes from and how easily it could end. The same logic protects lost earnings: a disability benefit can only offset the earnings category it truly replaces, which is why vocational experts and economists who prove lost earning capacity matter at the hearing as much as at trial.


Frequently Asked Questions


No. CPLR 4545 says any collateral source deduction is made by the trial judge after the jury's verdict, and you're allowed to prove your full losses at trial regardless. The insurance question is handled afterward in motion papers and, if the defense makes a strong enough showing, a hearing.

No. The statute covers economic categories like medical care, custodial care, rehabilitation, lost earnings, and other economic loss. Damages for pain, suffering, and loss of enjoyment of life fall outside it.

A CPLR 4545 reduction is made by the court after a verdict, so a settlement doesn't go through that hearing. Separately, General Obligations Law 5-335 generally bars health insurers from seeking reimbursement out of a personal injury settlement, although it doesn't apply to Medicare, Medicaid, workers' compensation, or certain additional no-fault benefits, and some federally governed employer plans may follow different rules.

Courts require real evidence, not assumptions. In 2026 the First Department rejected a request based only on the plaintiff's Social Security number, while in 2024 the Second Department granted a hearing where the defense offered a broker's affidavit naming a specific plan and an economist's offset calculation. Even then, the defense would still have to prove its offset with reasonable certainty at the hearing.



A jury verdict for a catastrophic injury isn't always the final word, because a CPLR 4545 collateral source hearing gives the defense one more chance to argue that insurance should pay part of your future costs. The law puts the burden on the defense, demands reasonable certainty, and protects benefits that must be repaid. A detailed life-care plan, careful economic proof, and early attention to liens keep that burden where it belongs.


If you or someone you know has won a verdict for a catastrophic injury, or is deciding whether to take a serious injury case to trial, Reza Yassi at Yassi Law PC is ready to help. Call us today at 646-992-2138 for a consultation.




Written by Reza Yassi | LinkedIn


Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.


This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Although I am an attorney, I am not your attorney, and reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws vary by jurisdiction and may have changed since the publication of this article. For advice specific to your situation, consult a qualified attorney.


slider 4.jpg
Reza Yassi(author).png

Principal Attorney, Yassi Law P.C.
Reza Yassi is the principal attorney at Yassi Law P.C., representing clients in commercial litigation and personal injury matters. He is known for his aggressive yet tactical approach, combining strategic planning with clear client communication while serving individuals and businesses across New York and New Jersey.

bottom of page