top of page

Electrocuted on a NYC Construction Site: Live Wires, Missing Lockout/Tagout, and Labor Law § 241(6) Claims for Nerve Damage

Writer: Reza Yassi
Reza Yassi
5d
12 min read
Electrocuted on a NYC Construction Site: Live Wires, Missing Lockout/Tagout, and Labor Law § 241(6) Claims for Nerve Damage

In 2025, a New York appeals court reviewed the case of a laborer whose saw cut into a live electrical bus that nobody had shut off. In NG 645 Madison Ave LLC v. Vanguard Constr. & Dev. Co., Inc., 2025 NY Slip Op 03283 (1st Dep't 2025), the Appellate Division, First Department, agreed the building owners broke the state's electrical safety rules and held them legally responsible without a trial. If you were electrocuted on a NYC construction site, that ruling tells you how courts look at live power left on in a work zone. It also shows that an owner's own paperwork rules won't protect it when the power stays on and someone gets hurt.


Key takeaways


  • Live power left on in a work area can violate Industrial Code 23-1.13 and support a Labor Law § 241(6) claim.

  • Owners, general contractors, electrical subcontractors, and sometimes utilities can be responsible for failing to shut off power.

  • A building's internal shutoff paperwork does not excuse an owner who left the power on.

  • See a doctor right away, even if you feel fine, because nerve, heart, and memory problems can surface later.

  • Most injury lawsuits must be filed within three years, and claims against public entities need a notice within 90 days.


What Happened in the NG 645 Madison Ave Case, and Why Did the Worker Win?


The worker won because the owners never inspected the work area for live power, never shut it off, and never posted warnings, and the court found those failures caused his injuries. He was cutting with a saw when the blade struck an electrical bus. A bus is a heavy metal bar or enclosed duct that carries large amounts of electricity through a building. It was energized.


The owners had a defense ready. The building required contractors to send a written notice before any power shutoff, and no contractor had sent one. In the owners' view, that meant the blame belonged to someone else. The First Department rejected the argument. An owner's internal procedure for requesting a shutdown doesn't replace the owner's own legal duty to make the work area safe.


The court spelled out what the safety rule demands. It wrote that the relevant sections "require appropriate inspection of electrical systems in a work zone, precautionary steps to be taken around power equipment, including de-energizing such equipment, and the placement of warning signs where appropriate to alert as to electrical hazards present." It then found the owners failed to follow those measures and that "such failures constituted a proximate cause of plaintiff's injuries." Proximate cause simply means the failure was a real, direct reason the injury happened.


The worker received summary judgment on liability. In plain words, the court decided before any trial that the owners were responsible. What remains is a trial or settlement about damages: how badly the worker was hurt and what that harm is worth. For someone living with nerve damage and memory problems, that shift matters. The case stops being about who is to blame and becomes about what the injury has taken from your life.


What Does Industrial Code 23-1.13 Require Before Anyone Works Near Live Power?


Industrial Code 23-1.13 requires owners and contractors to check the work area for electrical hazards, shut off or guard live circuits a worker could touch, and post warnings where electrical dangers exist. The rule appears at 12 NYCRR 23-1.13. It's part of the Industrial Code, a set of detailed safety regulations issued by New York's Commissioner of Labor.


The rule matters because of Labor Law § 241(6). That statute says every area where construction, excavation or demolition work is performed must be "so constructed, shored, equipped, guarded, arranged, operated and conducted as to provide reasonable and adequate protection and safety" to the people working there. It lets the Commissioner make rules to carry out that duty, and it says owners, contractors and their agents "shall comply therewith." The only owners carved out are owners of one- and two-family homes who contract for the work but don't direct or control it.


To win a § 241(6) claim, you generally must point to a specific Industrial Code rule that was broken and show that the violation caused your injury. Broad language about "safe conditions" isn't enough. Rule 23-1.13(b) is specific, which is why it appears in electrocution case after electrocution case.


Failing to check for live wires is itself a violation


In Britt v. Levgar Equities Corp., 2024 NY Slip Op 02497 (1st Dep't 2024), an HVAC worker was shocked while installing an air conditioning coil unit. The First Department granted him judgment on liability because the defendants "did not ascertain whether there were live wires in the vicinity of plaintiff's work location, and failed to protect plaintiff against an electrical shock." Nobody had to prove the owners knew the wires were hot. Not looking was enough. The worker also won on his Labor Law § 240(1) claim, a reminder that a shock can set off a second kind of accident, like a falling object, that brings other protections into play.


Insulation alone may not satisfy the rule


Defendants sometimes argue that wiring was insulated or enclosed, so the worker was protected. In Wolodin v. Lehr Constr. Corp., 2019 NY Slip Op 8362 (1st Dep't 2019), an electrician was shocked while cutting high-voltage wiring to prepare an office for demolition. The court rejected the insulation defense because his job was to cut through the wires directly. He "was permitted to come into contact with an electrical circuit that had not been de-energized," and that violated the rule.


Where lockout/tagout fits in


Lockout/tagout means physically locking a disconnect switch in the off position and tagging it so no one turns the power back on while work is underway. Federal safety standards on the control of hazardous energy, described by OSHA, are built around that practice. A federal OSHA violation, standing alone, usually can't carry a § 241(6) claim, because the statute ties to New York's Industrial Code rather than federal regulations. OSHA findings can still help show what safe practice required, but the claim itself has to rest on a rule like 23-1.13.


The danger is real. Electrocution is a documented cause of death for construction workers. The Bureau of Labor Statistics tracks fatal work injuries caused by exposure to electricity every year in its Census of Fatal Occupational Injuries.


There's a safety violation on practically every New York City job site, but not every violation makes a case. What matters is whether the violation caused your injury and fits one of the Labor Law's protections. A missing guardrail on another floor won't help an electrocution claim. A live feeder in the ceiling you were told to open will.


Who Can Be Held Liable When the Power Isn't Shut Off?


Liability under § 241(6) can reach the property owner, the general contractor, and any subcontractor or utility acting as the owner's agent for the work, but usually not your direct employer. Each of these parties can carry its own insurance, which matters when the injuries are lifelong.


Owners, even utility owners


In Wittenberg v. Long Is. Power Auth., 2024 NY Slip Op 01329 (2d Dep't 2024), a lineman was hurt in an explosion during line work. He sued the Long Island Power Authority and PSEG entities, which had contracted for the work. The Second Department reinstated his § 241(6) claim, holding that the 23-1.13(b) rules, "which refer to the duty of employers, also impose a duty upon owners." The defendants hadn't shown the rules didn't apply or didn't cause the explosion. His common-law negligence and Labor Law § 200 claims came back too, because the defendants' motion to dismiss them was filed late. Section 200 sets a general duty to keep workplaces reasonably safe.


For a worker in Suffolk County or on Staten Island doing line or service work, that ruling matters. A utility that hires out work on its own system can be treated as an owner with the same Industrial Code duties as a building owner in the Bronx.


The electrical subcontractor that was supposed to "safe off" the circuit


In Higgins v. TST 375 Hudson, L.L.C., 179 A.D.3d 508 (1st Dep't 2020), the electrical subcontractor had authority over the electrical work. The court held it liable as the owner's statutory agent, meaning a party that stands in the owner's shoes for safety duties, because it "failed to warn of and de-energize or 'safe off' the junction box." So if you're a drywall installer on a Mott Haven high-rise and the electrician's crew left a box live, that electrical company may be a defendant even though it never employed you.


Overhead line contact raises similar questions. When a boom lift or crane load drifts into a line on a Hunts Point lot, the utility's role in de-energizing or covering that line can become part of the case. Our earlier post on suing Con Edison and site owners after high-voltage burns covers that scenario in more depth.


Your employer and workers' compensation


Under Workers' Compensation Law § 11, workers' comp is generally your only remedy against your own employer. You can't sue the company that signs your paycheck in most cases. The same section lets other defendants seek contribution from your employer only if you suffered a "grave injury," a short list that includes death, permanent and total loss of use of an arm, leg, hand or foot, and certain acquired brain injuries. Severe nerve damage that leaves a hand permanently useless can matter here.


You can collect comp benefits and still sue the owner, contractor, or utility. Workers' Compensation Law § 29 gives the comp carrier a lien, meaning a right to be repaid from your lawsuit recovery for what it paid, after a share of the legal costs is deducted. The section also requires you to notify the Workers' Compensation Board chair, your employer, and the carrier within 30 days after starting the lawsuit.


What If the Defense Says You Chose to Work on Live Equipment?


That defense often fails when the record shows no one actually arranged a shutdown or gave you a realistic, safe way to do the job. Defendants like to paint the injured worker as someone who decided on his own to work "hot." Courts look past that story to the facts.


In Rosa v. 47 E. 34th St. (NY), L.P., 2022 NY Slip Op 05144 (1st Dep't 2022), an electrician was fatally injured in an arc explosion while working on an energized bus duct. An arc explosion is a violent blast of heat and light when electricity jumps through the air. The building manager testified he had told the electrician to wait for a power-down. The lower court threw the case out. The First Department reinstated it, writing that "Rosa was placed in the position of coming into contact with the live bus duct." Questions remained about whether he was really the sole cause or was effectively forced to work on live equipment.


The paper trail that wins these disputes is often the one that doesn't exist. If an owner claims a shutdown was scheduled, there should be an outage request, a tenant notice, a lockout log, or a permit showing it. When none of that turns up, the claim that you were simply told to wait looks thin. In NG 645 Madison Ave, the missing shutoff notice hurt the owners, not the worker.


Your own share of fault can still come up. Unlike some other Labor Law claims, a § 241(6) recovery can be reduced by the percentage of fault a jury assigns to you under New York's comparative fault rule. But in Higgins, the court found no issue of comparative negligence at all, because the work area was supposed to be de-energized. A worker can't be faulted for trusting that the power was off when the system was designed to make it so.


Preserving the right evidence early helps answer the "cowboy" defense. The items worth securing usually include:


  • Photos or video of the panel, bus, junction box, or line, including any missing locks or tags

  • Names and phone numbers of coworkers and the foreman who gave instructions that day

  • Shutdown requests, tenant notices, outage tickets, and lockout logs, or proof none exist

  • Your clothing, tools, and gloves from the moment of contact

  • Any DOB, OSHA, or utility incident reports


How Do You Prove Nerve Damage and Cognitive Problems That Show Up Later?


You prove them with prompt medical records, objective testing such as nerve conduction studies and neuropsychological exams, and witnesses who can describe how you changed after the shock. These are the hidden injuries that drive the value of an electrocution case, and they're the ones defendants most often dispute.


Electricity travels through the body along a path, often hand to hand or hand to foot. The entry wound on the skin can look small while nerves, muscle, and the heart beneath it are damaged. The Cleveland Clinic describes how electric shock can cause irregular heart rhythms, nerve damage, and problems with memory and concentration. The Mayo Clinic advises that anyone who suffers a serious electrical shock should get medical care, because some damage isn't visible right away.


That delay is where many cases weaken. The biggest mistake is waiting to get medical treatment. The longer the gap between the accident and your first visit, the harder it is to prove the accident caused your injuries, and the less believable the claim becomes to an insurer or a jury. A worker in Riverhead who shakes off a shock, finishes the shift, and sees a doctor three weeks later for hand numbness hands the defense an easy argument.


The tests that make invisible injuries visible


Nerve damage is often documented with electromyography and nerve conduction studies. These measure how well nerves carry signals to the muscles. Cognitive injuries are measured with neuropsychological testing, a series of hours-long exams of memory, attention, and processing speed. Heart rhythm problems may be caught with extended monitoring, such as a wearable monitor worn for days at a time.


Timing matters for the tests too. A neuropsychological exam done months after the accident is stronger when earlier medical records already note headaches, confusion, or forgetfulness. Tell every doctor every symptom, even the ones that seem minor or embarrassing.


The people who knew you before


Lay witnesses carry real weight in brain and nerve cases. Your spouse can describe how you now lose track of conversations. A longtime coworker can explain that you used to wire a panel without a second look and now can't hold a screwdriver steady. Juries in the Bronx and Staten Island courthouses hear from doctors on both sides, so the plain words of people who know you can tip the balance.


Defense lawyers will usually send you to an independent medical exam with a doctor they choose. They may argue your symptoms come from stress, age, or an old injury. Our post on the hidden nerve and cardiac damage in electrocution cases explains the medicine in more detail. If a shock stopped your heart or cut off oxygen, the related post on anoxic brain injury after electrocution covers that path. When burns are part of the picture, see how electrical contact burn cases are valued.


Deadlines you can't miss


Even a strong case can be lost to the calendar. If you were electrocuted on a NYC construction site, these are the main time limits to know:


  • Three years from the injury to file most personal injury lawsuits, under CPLR § 214

  • 90 days to serve a notice of claim when a notice is required against a public corporation, under General Municipal Law § 50-e

  • One year and 90 days to sue a city, county, town, village, fire district or school district, under General Municipal Law § 50-i

  • 30 days after starting a third-party lawsuit to notify the comp board chair, employer, and carrier


Public projects deserve special care. A school renovation or a city agency building can trigger the 90-day notice rule, which is far shorter than the three years most people expect. For a look at how another Industrial Code rule drives § 241(6) claims, see our post on grinder eye injuries and Rule 23-1.8.


Frequently Asked Questions


Usually not. Workers' Compensation Law § 11 makes workers' comp your main remedy against your own employer, but you can still sue the property owner, general contractor, electrical subcontractor, or utility under Labor Law § 241(6) and related claims.

Get checked by a doctor anyway and tell them exactly what happened. Nerve damage, heart rhythm problems, and memory or concentration issues can appear days or weeks later, and early records help connect those symptoms to the accident.

Yes, it can. In Wolodin v. Lehr Construction Corp., an electrician whose job required cutting high-voltage wires won on liability because the circuit had not been de-energized, and the court rejected the argument that insulation alone was enough protection.

Most personal injury lawsuits in New York must be filed within three years under CPLR § 214. If a city, school district, or other public corporation is involved, you may need to serve a notice of claim within 90 days, so it's wise to act quickly.



The Bottom Line


The recent First Department decisions send a consistent message: owners and contractors must inspect for live power, shut it off or guard it, and warn workers, and their own internal paperwork won't excuse leaving it on. The value of these cases often rests on nerve, heart, and cognitive injuries that show up later, so prompt treatment and careful testing make all the difference.


If you or someone you know was electrocuted on a NYC construction site, Reza Yassi at Yassi Law PC is ready to help. Call us today at 646-992-2138 for a consultation.




Written by Reza Yassi | LinkedIn


Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.


This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Although I am an attorney, I am not your attorney, and reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws vary by jurisdiction and may have changed since the publication of this article. For advice specific to your situation, consult a qualified attorney.


slider 4.jpg
Reza Yassi(author).png

Principal Attorney, Yassi Law P.C.
Reza Yassi is the principal attorney at Yassi Law P.C., representing clients in commercial litigation and personal injury matters. He is known for his aggressive yet tactical approach, combining strategic planning with clear client communication while serving individuals and businesses across New York and New Jersey.

bottom of page