top of page

Housing Merchant Implied Warranty in New York: Suing the Builder Under GBL § 777-a for Defects in a New Townhouse or Low-Rise Condo

Writer: Reza Yassi
Reza Yassi
Nov 11
11 min read
Housing Merchant Implied Warranty in New York: Suing the Builder Under GBL § 777-a for Defects in a New Townhouse or Low-Rise Condo

You closed on a newly built condo unit in a four-story building off Steinway Street in Astoria about eighteen months ago. Last week the heat quit for the second time this fall, and a brown stain is spreading across the ceiling under the roof deck. The sponsor's superintendent keeps saying someone will come by. Now you're wondering whether you can still hold the builder responsible under New York's housing merchant implied warranty, or whether the clock has already run out.


Key takeaways


  • New York implies a builder's warranty into the sale of a new single-family home or a condo or co-op unit in a building of five stories or less.

  • Coverage runs one year for workmanship, two years for plumbing, electrical and HVAC, and six years for material structural defects.

  • Written notice must reach the builder no later than 30 days after the applicable warranty period ends, and courts dismiss late claims.

  • A builder's limited warranty replaces the statutory warranty only if it meets strict legal requirements, so read your contract's warranty pages now.

  • Promises to come back and fix things don't stop your deadlines, so put every complaint in writing and act early.


Is Your New NYC Home Covered by the Housing Merchant Implied Warranty?


You're covered if you bought a newly built single-family house, or a for-sale condominium or cooperative unit in a residential building of five stories or less, from the builder or sponsor. That definition comes from GBL § 777(5), and it describes much of the new construction on side streets in Bensonhurst, Flushing, Ridgewood and Staten Island's South Shore: attached townhouses, small condo buildings, and four-story walk-ups with a handful of units. A unit in a 20-story Long Island City tower falls outside the statute. So does a dwelling built solely for lease, or a house or unit the builder lived in or leased out continuously for three years or more after construction was completed.


One caution for buyers of two-family houses, which are everywhere in Brooklyn and Queens. The statute's text names single-family houses and units sold under a condo or co-op regime, so whether a two-family house sold as one parcel qualifies is a question to raise with a lawyer before you build a strategy around it. Your purchase contract may still give you separate rights.


Under GBL § 777-a(1), the warranty is implied in the contract for the sale of a new home and survives the passing of title. That's unusual. In most real estate deals, contract promises disappear into the deed at closing. Here they don't, and the warranty covers three periods measured from what the statute calls the warranty date:


  • One year: the home will be free from defects caused by a failure to build it in a skillful manner.

  • Two years: the plumbing, electrical, heating, cooling and ventilation systems will be free from defects caused by the builder's failure to install them in a skillful manner.

  • Six years: the home will be free from material defects.


Those terms have precise meanings. Under § 777(3), "constructed in a skillful manner" means workmanship and materials that meet or exceed the applicable building code (in the five boroughs, that includes the New York City Building Code) and, where the code is silent, locally accepted building practices. A "material defect" is far narrower than most buyers expect. Section 777(4) limits it to actual physical damage to load-bearing parts of the home, such as foundations and footings, beams, girders, lintels, columns, walls and partitions, floor systems and roof framing, caused by their failure and affecting their load-bearing function to the point that the home becomes unsafe, unsanitary or otherwise unliveable.


Your first job after closing is to write down your warranty date. Under § 777(8), it's the date title passed to the first owner for occupancy as a residence or the date of first occupancy, whichever came first. If the sponsor let you move in early, your clock may have started before you signed the deed. In Harris v. Whalen, 90 A.D.3d 708 (App. Div. 2011), the court applied that earlier-of rule and affirmed summary judgment for the builder because the buyers' written notice arrived about fourteen months after title passed, too late under a one-year limited warranty.


The walk-through matters too. Unless the contract says otherwise, § 777-a(2) excludes patent defects, meaning problems an examination ought to have revealed, when you examined the home as fully as you wanted before taking title or refused to examine it. It also excludes defects that don't stem from the builder's workmanship, the builder's materials, or a design by a professional the builder retained exclusively. Anything you can see at the walk-through belongs on a signed punch list before closing, much like the punch-list stage at substantial completion on a commercial project.


Did the Builder Replace the Statutory Warranty With a Limited Warranty?


Possibly, and you need to know the answer before a defect shows up, because a valid limited warranty changes both your coverage and your deadlines. New York lets a builder exclude or modify the housing merchant implied warranty only by offering a limited warranty that satisfies GBL § 777-b(3). Small-building sponsors frequently attach one to the purchase agreement, and condo offering plans filed with the New York State Attorney General often describe the sponsor's warranty program. Pull out both documents. The statute sets four conditions:


  • A written copy of the limited warranty's terms was given to you to examine before you signed the purchase contract.

  • The limited warranty is included in, or annexed to and incorporated in, the contract.

  • The contract conspicuously mentions the housing merchant implied warranty and states that the limited warranty excludes or modifies it.

  • The limited warranty meets or exceeds the standards in subdivisions four and five of § 777-b.


Those standards are demanding. Section 777-b(4) requires the warranty to be written in plain English, captioned "limited warranty" at the beginning, and to name every warrantor with an address. It must identify who's covered (it has to extend to the first owner and survive the passing of title), state what products or parts it covers, and clearly identify anything excluded along with the standards used to decide whether a defect exists.


Courts enforce these rules strictly in both directions. In Latiuk v. Faber Construction Co., 269 A.D.2d 820 (App. Div. 2000), the builder's shortened limited warranty failed because it didn't say what the builder would do when a covered defect arose or how quickly it would act, so the buyers kept their statutory claim. The court stated the rule directly: "The statutory housing merchant implied warranty may be excluded or modified by the builder of a new home only if the buyer is offered a limited warranty that meets or exceeds the standards provided in General Business Law § 777-b (4) and (5)."


The other side of the coin is Gallup v. Summerset Homes, LLC, 82 A.D.3d 1658 (App. Div. 2011). That limited warranty complied with § 777-b and displaced the statutory warranty. Because the buyers had missed written notice under the one- and two-year provisions, they could proceed only under the six-year structural coverage, and a severe mold problem didn't qualify. As the court put it, "While the mold infestation in plaintiffs’ home certainly rendered it “unsafe, unsanitary, [and] otherwise unlivable,” it did not affect the load-bearing functions of the home." Their warranty claims were dismissed, though a breach of contract claim based on other contract provisions survived.


A Defect Has Appeared: How Do You Give the Builder Written Notice?


Put the complaint in writing, make sure the builder receives it, and send it as soon as you spot the problem rather than waiting for the warranty period to wind down. Under § 777-a(4)(a), written notice of a warranty claim must be received by the builder before you start a lawsuit and no later than 30 days after the applicable warranty period expires. You must also give the builder a reasonable opportunity to inspect, test and repair the part of the home the claim involves.


Courts treat notice as a gate, not a formality. In Finnegan v. Brooke Hill, LLC., 38 A.D.3d 491 (2d Dep't 2007), condo owners who closed in 1999 didn't serve written warranty notices until 2005. The Second Department, the appellate court that hears appeals from Brooklyn, Queens, Staten Island and Long Island, dismissed the claim: "Thus, the notices of claim were untimely, which is fatal to the first cause of action since timely notice is a condition precedent to a cause of action alleging breach of the housing merchant implied warranty." The court added that the common-element defects at issue didn't make any unit unsafe or uninhabitable, so the six-year structural coverage couldn't rescue them.


Compare Furino v. O'Sullivan, 137 A.D.3d 1208 (2d Dep't 2016). A Queens couple's basement flooded the day after closing, and their lawyer sent the builder a letter about two weeks later. The court held that "the letter dated October 24, 2002, sent by the plaintiffs’ counsel provided him with timely written notice of their claims regarding the flooding in the basement." The builder disclaimed responsibility, but since he'd had a reasonable opportunity to inspect and repair, the buyers recovered. A strong notice letter usually covers these points:


  • The property address, your closing date and your warranty date.

  • A specific description of each defect, when you first noticed it, and photos or video.

  • A request that the builder inspect and repair, with dates you can provide access.

  • Proof of delivery, such as certified mail with return receipt plus email, sent to every warrantor address listed in the contract or limited warranty.


Then let the builder in. Refusing access hands the builder an argument that you didn't satisfy the statute. Keep a log of every visit, every promise and every repair attempt.


What if you only called? In Rich v. Orlando, 108 A.D.3d 1039 (4th Dep't 2013), the homeowners never sent written notice, but the builder made repairs after their oral complaints. The Fourth Department held the builder had waived the written-notice requirement, explaining that the statute's requirements, "including the written notice requirement, are implied in every contract for the sale of a new home as a matter of public policy" and may be applied by courts "to do justice and avoid hardship." That's a narrow, fact-bound escape hatch, and the timeliness of the suit still went to trial. A letter costs nothing and removes the argument entirely.


The Builder Keeps Promising to Fix It: How Long Can You Wait Before Suing?


Not long, because the warranty has its own lawsuit deadline that runs whether or not repairs are "scheduled." Under § 777-a(4)(b), an action for breach of the housing merchant implied warranty may be commenced before one year after the applicable warranty period expires, or within four years after the warranty date, whichever is later. For a workmanship or mechanical defect, that generally means four years from your warranty date. For a material structural defect, it means seven. Under Rich v. Orlando, a builder's repairs can also restart a one-year window to sue measured from the repair work.


Don't count on the six-year contract statute of limitations to save a late warranty claim. CPLR 213(2) gives six years for actions on contractual obligations, but it expressly carves out claims under article 36-B of the General Business Law, the article that contains the housing merchant implied warranty. The warranty runs on its own clock. What can run on the longer contract clock is a claim based on separate promises in your purchase agreement, such as a promised finish, a specified window package or an amenity in the offering plan, which is why a contract claim survived in Gallup. In Furino, by contrast, a contract claim that simply repeated the warranty claim was dismissed as duplicative.


The biggest mistake is waiting too long. Homeowners and business owners get strung along by promises to pay, to come back and fix the work, or to deliver the materials. Those promises rarely come true, and the delay gives the other side time to move assets out of the company or out of their own name before a lawsuit begins. That risk is sharp with new construction, because sponsors of small condo projects often hold the building through a single-purpose LLC, and once the last unit sells, that entity may have little left to collect from.


When your gut tells you the builder is stalling, act on it. Bringing in a lawyer early often sends the other side a clear message that the delays have to stop. If the builder genuinely wants more time to repair, a written tolling agreement that pauses your deadlines protects you far better than a handshake.


What Happens When You Sue the Builder, and What Can You Recover?


You'll usually sue the sponsor-builder in State Supreme Court, pleading breach of the housing merchant implied warranty along with any contract claims grounded in separate promises. Before filing, check the limited warranty and purchase agreement for an arbitration clause or a dispute-resolution procedure, since some builder warranty programs route claims away from court.


Expect the builder to attack on familiar grounds. It will argue your notice was late or never received, that a valid limited warranty replaced the statute, that the problem isn't a "material defect" (the argument that won in both Finnegan and Gallup), that the defect was patent at the walk-through, or that the damage came from your own alterations or maintenance rather than its workmanship. Each defense ties back to a document or a date, which is why your contract, punch list, notice letters and repair log matter so much.


Proof usually starts with a licensed engineer or architect. Because "skillful manner" is defined by the building code, an expert report that identifies the specific code standard the work failed to meet is far more persuasive than a general opinion that the work looks poor. Public records help too. The NYC Department of Buildings keeps records of permits, complaints, violations and certificates of occupancy, which can show whether inspections were signed off or work was done without permits.


Damages follow the warranty's purpose, which is fixing the home. In Furino, recovery was limited to repair costs and property damage, and the court excluded the buyers' inspection fee. Many cases resolve before trial with a written repair agreement or a payment toward repairs. If you settle for repairs, insist on a schedule, a scope of work and a clause preserving your claims if the builder doesn't finish.


Keep in mind that these rules apply to new homes. If your dispute is with a contractor renovating a home you already own, different law governs, starting with GBL Article 36-A's home improvement contract requirements and the broader rules covered in this guide to New York home improvement contract disputes.


Frequently Asked Questions


Does the warranty protect me if I bought the home from the first owner?

Often, yes. Under GBL § 777(6), "owner" includes each successor in title during the unexpired portion of the warranty period, so you can step into the remaining coverage. A valid limited warranty, however, may exclude subsequent owners, so check its terms.

Is a leaking roof or mold a "material defect" under the six-year coverage?

Usually not, unless the problem involves actual physical damage to load-bearing components that affects their load-bearing function. In Gallup v. Summerset Homes, mold made a home unlivable but didn't qualify because it didn't affect load-bearing functions. Leaks and mold generally have to be raised within the one- or two-year periods.

Are phone calls or texts to the sponsor's super enough notice?

Don't rely on them. The statute requires written notice received by the builder, and courts dismiss claims when it's missing or late. Rich v. Orlando found a waiver where the builder made repairs after oral complaints, but that's a narrow exception, not a substitute for a dated letter sent by trackable delivery.

Does this warranty apply to my renovation contractor?

No. The housing merchant implied warranty covers the sale or construction of a new home. Renovation disputes are governed by your contract, GBL Article 36-A, and related remedies, including the rules on contractor abandonment and mechanic's liens.


The housing merchant implied warranty gives buyers of new NYC townhouses and low-rise condo units real protection, but only if you identify your warranty date, check whether a limited warranty replaced it, and send written notice on time. Courts enforce these deadlines strictly, so the safest move is to act at the first sign of a defect.


If you or your business bought a newly built home or condo unit that's showing serious defects and the builder won't make it right, Reza Yassi at Yassi Law PC is ready to help. Call us today at 646-992-2138 for a consultation.



Written by Reza Yassi | LinkedIn


Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.


This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Although I am an attorney, I am not your attorney, and reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws vary by jurisdiction and may have changed since the publication of this article. For advice specific to your situation, consult a qualified attorney.


slider 4.jpg
Reza Yassi(author).png

Principal Attorney, Yassi Law P.C.
Reza Yassi is the principal attorney at Yassi Law P.C., representing clients in commercial litigation and personal injury matters. He is known for his aggressive yet tactical approach, combining strategic planning with clear client communication while serving individuals and businesses across New York and New Jersey.

bottom of page