top of page

What Is a Broken Hip Worth in New York? 2026 Settlement Data

Writer: Reza Yassi
Reza Yassi
Feb 24, 2023
9 min read

Updated: Nov 7



Updated October 22, 2026


The Answer is - It depends . . . but generally, in New York, reported hip injury settlements have ranged from $50,000 to over $1,000,000, depending on factors like surgical requirements, long-term mobility impact, and liability evidence. Every case is different, and past results do not predict the outcome of any other case. At Yassi Law PC, we focus on these specific injuries and the evidence that shows their full impact.


A hip injury can be a life-altering event, especially in a fast-moving city like Manhattan, causing severe pain, limitations on mobility, and a long road to recovery. If you've suffered a hip injury in New York due to someone else’s negligence, consulting a personal injury attorney Manhattan residents trust is crucial. Let’s explore the factors determining a hip injury's value and verdicts in hip injury settlement New York cases.

Key takeaways

  • A hip injury claim's value depends on surgery, recovery, age, lost income, pain and suffering, fault, and the defendant's insurance coverage.

  • If a city or government agency is responsible, you generally must file a Notice of Claim within 90 days of the injury.

  • Claims against private parties generally must be filed within three years of the accident.

  • Keep records of medical bills, lost wages, and changes to your daily life, because they shape how a claim is valued.

  • Appellate courts compare hip injury awards with similar cases and can change amounts they find unreasonable.

Factors that Determine the Value of a Hip Injury

What Factors Determine the Settlement Value of a Hip Injury in NYC?

The value of a hip injury case depends on various factors, including:


1. The severity of the injury: A severe hip fracture that requires surgery, extensive rehabilitation, and concurrent injuries will generally result in a higher settlement or verdict than a less severe fracture.


2. The victim's age: The age at which an individual sustains an injury significantly impacts the extent of their pain and suffering damages. Younger individuals are likely to experience greater levels of physical, emotional, and psychological distress due to the injury, primarily because they have a longer life ahead of them to endure the consequences of the trauma. Conversely, older individuals who suffer an injury are less likely to be awarded substantial pain, and suffering damages as the duration for which they will experience the effects of the injury is comparatively shorter.


3. Economic damages: The total amount of medical expenses, lost wages, and future medical costs will influence the value of a claim. The out-of-pocket costs you incur in connection with your injury can be claimed as part of your damages in a lawsuit or in settlement negotiations. Out-of-pocket expenses affect both your economic damages and non-economic damages.


4. Non-economic damages: Unlike economic damages, non-economic damages such as pain and suffering, loss of enjoyment of life, and emotional distress can be hard to quantify. This is where multipliers come in. Attorneys apply multipliers (generally 1x to 5x) to your economic damages to assess the value of your non-economic damages.


5. Liability: The degree of fault attributed to the defendant and their insurance policy limits will also affect the amount of compensation available.


6. Insurance Policy Limits: as the old adage goes, you cannot get blood from a stone. All of the above factors are irrelevant if the individual or entity you are suing does not have money to pay you. That is why assessing the defendant's insurance policy early on in litigation or during pre-litigation is crucial.


Most cases should settle, especially given how long New York cases take; taking a little less now can be worth more than waiting years. But some cases are worth more than an insurer will pay without a trial, and those clients need to be ready for a long fight.


How Long Do I Have to File a Hip Injury Lawsuit in New York?

The time you have to file a hip injury lawsuit in New York depends entirely on who was responsible for the accident.


  • If suing the City or a Government Agency:

    • 90 Days: You must file a formal Notice of Claim within 90 days of the injury.

    • 1 Year and 90 Days: You have this total amount of time to actually commence the lawsuit.


  • If suing a Private Party (Normal Negligence):

    • 3 Years: You generally have three years from the date of the accident to file your lawsuit.


Examples of Past Settlements and Verdicts in New York


In Rivera v. Kolsky, a 30-year-old male plaintiff suffered a fractured hip and a knee injury and aggravated a pre-existing back injury due to a motor vehicle accident. He underwent several medical procedures, including skeletal traction, open reduction internal fixation, and femoral fracture treatment, followed by weeks of hospital and nursing home stays. Despite physical therapy, the plaintiff still experienced pain and limited range of motion in his hip, ultimately requiring hip and knee replacement surgeries. The plaintiff could not work at his job at Home Depot for three years.


At trial, the plaintiff and his mother testified about the limitations of the plaintiff's activities. The plaintiff's physical therapist and orthopedic surgeon testified to the plaintiff's response to physical therapy and his need for a hip and knee replacement, respectively. The jury found the defendant liable and awarded the plaintiff a judgment of $1,865,305.43. The defendants appealed, but the court confirmed the lower court’s judgment.

Notably, the defendants argued that the plaintiff's obesity made his injuries worse. However, the Appellate Court found the argument unavailing because the fact that the plaintiff may have a physical or mental condition that makes him more susceptible to injury than a normal healthy person does not relieve the defendants of liability for all injuries sustained because of their negligence. The court further declined to instruct the jury concerning the plaintiff's duty to mitigate damages by failing to adequately lose weight, because the defendants failed to establish that the plaintiff was required to undergo elective weight loss surgery.


In Victor v New York City Tr. Auth., a 72-year-old woman, suffered a fractured hip that required surgery after subway doors closed on her, knocking her to the ground. The plaintiff underwent open reduction internal fixation surgery with screws and a steel intramedullary rod, followed by six days of hospitalization and two weeks of rehabilitation at a nursing home. She then had one month of physical therapy at home and continued as an outpatient for several months. Despite the post-accident treatment, the plaintiff's lifestyle was still changed, as she could not regularly travel to Manhattan to visit museums and attend cultural events and lectures.


At trial, the plaintiff's surgeon testified that she made a "very good or excellent recovery." At trial, the jury awarded the plaintiff a verdict of $850,000.00. The defendants appealed the verdict, but the Appellate Court ultimately upheld the jury's decision.

In Guss v. City of New York, the plaintiff, a 54-year-old woman, fell into a sinkhole in a street near her home and alleged that the City defendants were liable. Because of the accident, the plaintiff underwent hip replacement surgery. She had to stay in the hospital for nine days due to an infection that required the removal of the replacement hip and another surgery. She had multiple hip dislocations and needed two more surgeries to fix those issues, which required new hip replacements. The incident worsened the plaintiff's pre-existing osteoporosis, and she also experienced more anxiety and depression, which was also a pre-existing issue. After the fourth surgery, she was bedridden and had to live in a nursing home.


Sometimes, verdicts get adjusted by appellate courts or remanded back to lower courts to recalculate the damages.


At trial, the plaintiff called a rehabilitation expert. The jury found the defendants 100% at fault and awarded the plaintiff a verdict of $2,798,599 in damages for personal injuries.


The City defendants appealed, arguing that the verdict was against the weight of the evidence and that the damages were excessive. The appellate court upheld the verdict on liability but agreed that the award for future medical expenses was excessive. There was evidence that the plaintiff's future nursing home costs were tied to unrelated medical conditions. To the extent those costs were tied to the accident, they duplicated other items of future medical damages. The appellate court modified the judgment, vacating the damages for future medical expenses and ordering a new trial on that item unless the plaintiff consented to reduce it. Appellate courts can overrule verdicts and adjust damages if the Court finds that the evidence does not support the award, as was the case here.


In Fortune v. New York City Housing Authority, the plaintiff, a 70-year-old man, was working as a roofer installing a new water tank in an NYCHA building when a co-worker fell from the top of the tank – about 20 feet – onto the plaintiff, causing a severe injury to his hip socket, which required emergency surgery. He spent two weeks in the hospital and almost four months in a rehab facility. The plaintiff also underwent total hip replacement surgery and experienced a permanent left foot drop and a limb length discrepancy of almost two inches.


At trial, the jury awarded the plaintiff a 3-million-dollar verdict, which included 2 million dollars for past pain and suffering and 1 million dollars for future pain and suffering.


On appeal, the appellate court reduced the damages to 2 million dollars total, reducing both past and future pain and suffering by about a third each. The defense did not dispute the extent of the plaintiff's injuries but argued that fair compensation for their pain and suffering would be between $500,000 and $1 million, based on similar hip injury cases. Defendant also suggested that the foot drop injury would only slightly increase the compensation awarded. As the court explained in Fortune v. New York City Hous. Auth., 201 A.D.3d 705 (2d Dep't 2022), "The amount of damages to be awarded to a plaintiff for personal injuries is a question for the jury, and its determination will not be disturbed unless the award deviates materially from what would be reasonable compensation." Comparing similar cases, the court agreed that the awards for past and future pain and suffering deviated materially from reasonable compensation. The court also reduced the award for future lost earnings from $132,000 to $99,000, the amount the plaintiff himself had requested.

Appellate review can also work in a plaintiff's favor. In Romano v. Clove Lakes Health Care & Rehabilitation Ctr., Inc., 222 A.D.3d 1015 (2d Dep't 2023), the decedent "suffered an acute mildly displaced fracture to his left hip after he fell from his wheelchair" and needed hip replacement surgery. The jury awarded $6 million for past pain and suffering, and the trial court cut that to $500,000. The Second Department held that the trial court's cut went too far and set the award at $1 million. These figures reflect what happened in that case, not what any other case will bring.

If you've suffered a hip injury in New York, it's important to seek legal representation from a New York personal injury lawyer who can explain your options and guide you through the legal system. Yassi Law handles personal injury cases and is dedicated to helping our clients pursue the compensation the law allows. Find out more about our personal injury practice at https://www.yassilaw.com/personal-injury, and contact us for a free consultation.


Conclusion

The value of a hip injury case in New York depends on various factors, and providing an exact figure is challenging. However, you can estimate the potential value of your claim by considering the severity of the injury, the victim's age and health, economic and non-economic damages, liability, and insurance policy limits. Whether you're dealing with hospital bills, ongoing treatment, or lifestyle changes, seeking fair compensation for hip injury in NYC is essential.



FAQ

How much compensation can I get for a hip injury in New York?

There is no average compensation. Compensation can depend on whether it was a bad hip injury, whether surgery was involved, how much work you have missed, what your regular activities are like, and how this injury will affect you. Legal outcomes vary based on the details and the specific injury in your case.

There are many factors that will affect the value: the severity of the injury, the age and health of the injured person, the medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, and if the person or the entity that was at fault has insurance. All these factors help establish the final outcome.

Yes. For instance, young individuals may receive more consideration with regard to pain/suffering because they have more of their life left to live with the effects of their injury. Older adults may receive compensation. However, age could be reflected in a court's consideration of the long-term effects of the injury.

All cases are different. Some arise from workplace accidents, others happen in a public place or in traffic. The injury, the manner of the injury occurring, your treatment, and your usual activities all factor into the case. This is why there can be times with such wide-ranging results in hip injury cases.

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Disclaimer: Although I am a lawyer by profession, I am not YOUR lawyer. This article is for informational and educational purposes only, does not constitute legal advice, and does not establish any kind of attorney-client relationship with me. I am not liable or responsible for any damages resulting from or related to your use of this information.

slider 4.jpg
Reza Yassi(author).png

Principal Attorney, Yassi Law P.C.
Reza Yassi is the principal attorney at Yassi Law P.C., representing clients in commercial litigation and personal injury matters. He is known for his aggressive yet tactical approach, combining strategic planning with clear client communication while serving individuals and businesses across New York and New Jersey.

bottom of page