top of page

Lost Earning Capacity for an Injured NYC Union Construction Worker: Myths About Wages, Annuity, and Pension Proof

Writer: Reza Yassi
Reza Yassi
2 days ago
9 min read
Lost Earning Capacity for an Injured NYC Union Construction Worker: Myths About Wages, Annuity, and Pension Proof

Many injured tradespeople believe that once a doctor says they can never go back to the trade, a jury will simply multiply their union hourly rate by the years left until retirement. That isn't how lost earning capacity works in New York. Courts demand proof of what you actually earned, what your full union package was worth, how long you would have kept working, and what work you can still do. When a piece is missing or overstated, appellate judges cut the award or dismiss the claim. Every one of those pieces can be proved, but only with the right records and experts.


Key takeaways


  • Your union wage is only part of the loss; annuity, pension, and welfare fund contributions count too.

  • Your economist's numbers must match what your vocational expert and doctors actually say about your abilities.

  • Gather pay stubs, tax returns, and benefit fund statements now, while the records are easy to find.

  • Expect the defense to argue you can do a desk job, and make sure your doctors address it directly.

  • Workers' compensation replaces only part of your pay, and the carrier has a lien on any lawsuit recovery.


Will a Jury Automatically Award Your Full Union Wages Until Retirement If You Can't Return to the Trade?


No. A jury can only award future lost earnings that you prove with reasonable certainty, and being unable to return to your trade is not the same as being unable to work at all. New York appellate courts draw that line sharply, and they look closely at the assumptions behind every number.


In Harris v. City of New York, 2 A.D.3d 782 (2d Dep't 2003), the plaintiff could no longer do police work, but he was a college graduate who had held other jobs. His economist nonetheless assumed he could never earn a paycheck again. The Second Department dismissed the entire $1.5 million future-earnings claim. Because the evidence didn't support that assumption, the court held the expert's opinion was "of no probative value" and the claim was speculative.


A similar problem cut an award in Flores v. Parkchester Preservation Co., L.P., 42 A.D.3d 318 (1st Dep't 2007). The economist projected $915,168 in future lost earnings over 32.38 years, assuming the plaintiff could never work. But her own vocational rehabilitation expert admitted she was not totally disabled and estimated that, in a best case scenario, she had "lost fifty percent of her work life." The First Department reduced the $1 million future-earnings award to $425,000.


How Do the Vocational Expert and the Economist Divide the Work?


The vocational expert answers the human question. Given your permanent work restrictions, education, age, and skills, what jobs are realistically open to you, and what do they pay? This expert reviews your medical records, interviews you, often runs aptitude testing, and studies the job market where you live.


The economist answers the money question. Using the vocational expert's conclusions, the economist compares what you would have earned without the injury against what you can still earn, projects that gap across your remaining work life, adds expected wage growth, and discounts the total to present value. Present value simply means today's lump-sum equivalent of money you would have received in future years.


The order matters. Both experts should work from the same medical restrictions and the same assumptions before any report is exchanged, because the testimony that does the most damage in these cases often comes from a plaintiff's own witness conceding a point on cross-examination, as happened in Flores. Defense lawyers read every report side by side looking for the gap. For more on how these experts testify, see this post on vocational experts and economists proving a union ironworker's lost earning capacity.


Is Lost Earning Capacity Just Your Hourly Wage Times the Years You Had Left?


No. For a union tradesperson, lost earning capacity includes the entire compensation package, and the fringe benefits are often a large share of it. Under a collective bargaining agreement, your contractor pays you an hourly wage and also pays separate hourly contributions into union funds for your annuity, pension, and health coverage.


You can see this split in public records. The New York State Department of Labor publishes prevailing wage schedules for public work that list, trade by trade, both an hourly wage and a separate supplemental benefit rate. Union benefit funds are usually multiemployer plans, which federal law at 29 U.S.C. § 1002 defines as plans that more than one employer is required to contribute to, maintained under collective bargaining agreements.


New York courts measure the loss using the union contract itself. In Leto v. Amrex Chemical Co., 85 A.D.3d 1509 (3d Dep't 2011), a union plumber could still work as a self-employed plumber. The court found he earned $44,900 in wages and pension contributions in 2009, while the union contract would have paid $79,482 in wages and pension benefits. It multiplied the $34,582 difference by 21 years and replaced a $1.26 million award with $726,222. The defendant won a reduction, but notice the method: pension contributions counted on both sides of the comparison.


An economist valuing a union tradesperson's loss typically looks at:


  • The base hourly wage under the collective bargaining agreement, including scheduled raises

  • Overtime and premium-time hours supported by records

  • Annuity fund contributions

  • Pension fund contributions and lost pension credits

  • Welfare fund contributions that pay for health coverage


The same framework applies to other career-ending injuries, as this post on workplace vision loss and lost earning capacity explains.


Why Is Lost Pension Credit Its Own Category of Loss?


Every year you can't work in the trade is a year your union pension stops growing. In Caban v. City of New York, 46 A.D.3d 319 (1st Dep't 2007), a jury awarded an injured ironworker $0 for lost pension and too little for future earnings. The First Department upheld setting both aside. The evidence showed he was permanently unable to do iron work and would have worked at least until eligible for a full ironworker's pension. Even assuming only 10 more working years, given unrebutted testimony that his pension would have vested after five years, "he should have been awarded some amount for lost pension benefits."


Vesting means earning a permanent right to a benefit. Valuing that loss requires the plan's rules on vesting, credited hours, and benefit formulas, which your fund office can provide. A jury that isn't walked through it may leave the line blank, as the Caban jury did.


Can You Prove Your Overtime and Work History Just by Testifying About It?


Not reliably. Your own testimony matters, but courts want documents and witnesses that pin down how many hours, days, and weeks you actually worked.


The First Department made this point in Henriquez-Rodriguez v. 160 W. 118th St. Corp., 193 A.D.3d 645 (1st Dep't 2021). The plaintiff was paid a daily wage, but "there was no clear testimony or other evidence as to how many days he worked per week or per year." The court set aside both lost-earnings awards and recalculated them from the average gross income on his pre-accident tax returns. For a construction worker whose income swings with the season, a tax-return average can fall well below a full year at union scale with regular overtime.


Caban shows the better path. The ironworker's losses were proved through a union official, a journeyman ironworker who knew his work history, and an economist. Journeyman status means you finished your apprenticeship and earn the full trade rate. A coworker who ran jobs with you on a Mott Haven high-rise or a Suffolk County school project can tell a jury how much overtime the trade really offers, which jurors may not accept from you alone. The documents that usually carry this proof include:


  • W-2s and tax returns for several years before the accident

  • Pay stubs showing overtime and shift premiums

  • Annual benefit fund statements showing hours credited

  • Apprenticeship completion and journeyman status records


Work-life expectancy is the other half of the math. It's the number of years you would likely have kept working, not how long you'll live. Economists draw on government data such as the life tables published by the CDC's National Center for Health Statistics, then adjust for evidence specific to you, including your pension eligibility rules and your health before the accident. Caban tied work expectancy to the age of full pension eligibility, which gives a jury a concrete, documented endpoint.


Does the Defense's "You Can Still Do Sedentary Work" Argument End Your Claim?


No, but it can shrink your recovery if your own evidence supports it. Sedentary work means a seated job with little lifting, such as dispatching or security monitoring. Defendants almost always argue a former tradesperson can do something like that and that the award should drop by what those jobs pay.


In Berrios v. 735 Avenue of Americas, LLC, 103 A.D.3d 472 (1st Dep't 2013), a journeyman carpenter fell from a scaffold. The jury was instructed on his duty to mitigate damages, meaning an injured person must take reasonable steps, like vocational retraining, to reduce the financial loss. The First Department held that instruction proper because his own physician testified he was "able to work in a sedentary or part-time position," and it left the modest lost-earnings awards in place.


A good vocational expert answers this argument with labor-market reality. The question isn't whether desk jobs exist on Long Island. It's whether someone your age, with your education, restrictions, medications, and limited computer experience would actually be hired, and what that job pays next to your union package. The Bureau of Labor Statistics describes construction labor as physically demanding work, and skills built over 20 years on the tools rarely transfer neatly to an office. The injuries that end those careers are common, too; OSHA lists falls among the most common causes of serious work-related injuries and deaths, a pattern this post on NYC construction accident trends in 2026 also covers.


Why Do Your Treating Doctors' Records Matter So Much?


Your treating doctors set the restrictions the vocational expert builds on. So get treatment early, avoid gaps, and follow your doctors' instructions. Choose doctors who document carefully and are comfortable with the legal process, because the defense will send you to its own doctor, and those exams often conclude that your injuries are minor or unrelated to the accident. Your own doctors' records and reports are what answer that.


A note that just says "light duty" invites the Berrios problem. A note that spells out permanent limits on lifting, climbing, and kneeling, and explains why, gives the vocational expert something solid. Functional capacity testing, a structured measurement of what you can physically do, backs those limits up, and so can day-in-the-life videos.


Will Workers' Compensation and Union Benefits Already Cover Your Lost Wages?


No. Workers' compensation replaces only a portion of your wages, subject to a weekly cap, and it doesn't replace the annuity and pension contributions your contractor stopped paying. That's why the lawsuit against parties other than your employer is where full lost earning capacity is usually pursued.


Under Workers' Compensation Law § 11, your employer's comp liability is generally exclusive, so you usually can't sue your own employer. You can sue others, such as the owner or general contractor. Under Workers' Compensation Law § 29, you can take comp and still pursue that case, but the carrier gets a lien, meaning a right to repayment, on your recovery for the compensation and medical expenses it paid, after deducting reasonable expenses including attorney's fees. Defendants may also try to pull your employer in through a third-party claim, which the AVOID Act now limits in timing.


After a verdict, the defense may ask the judge to cut lost-earnings awards under CPLR 4545, which lets the court reduce economic awards replaced, with reasonable certainty, by a collateral source such as insurance. It excludes life insurance and payments carrying a statutory right of reimbursement, like comp benefits subject to the § 29 lien. You may still prove your full losses at trial, and union disability pension payments can become a fight at that stage, so get the plan documents early.


Frequently Asked Questions


Usually, yes. New York appellate courts have thrown out or cut future-earnings awards when an economist assumed total disability that the evidence didn't support. A vocational expert addresses whether any other work is realistically available, which is the question the defense will press hardest.

You may be able to, if the evidence shows with reasonable certainty that you would have advanced to journeyman. Apprenticeship records, attendance, and testimony from union or program officials help show that path. These claims tend to be more contested than claims by workers who had already reached journeyman status.

In personal injury cases governed by CPLR 5041, past damages and future damages up to $250,000 are paid in a lump sum. For future damages above that amount, the court enters judgment for the present value of an annuity contract that pays the rest in periodic installments.

It changes the math but doesn't end the claim. Courts subtract what you can still earn from what the union contract would have paid, as the Third Department did in Leto v. Amrex Chemical Co. Refusing all work when your own doctor says you can do something may invite a mitigation argument instead.



Lost earning capacity for a union tradesperson is far more than an hourly rate. It's wages, overtime, annuity, pension, and health contributions, proved through records, union witnesses, and experts whose assumptions match your medical restrictions. When those pieces line up, the claim rests on proof instead of guesswork.


If you or someone you know is a union tradesperson who can no longer work in the trade after a construction accident, Reza Yassi at Yassi Law PC is ready to help. Call us today at 646-992-2138 for a consultation.




Written by Reza Yassi | LinkedIn


Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.


This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Although I am an attorney, I am not your attorney, and reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws vary by jurisdiction and may have changed since the publication of this article. For advice specific to your situation, consult a qualified attorney.


slider 4.jpg
Reza Yassi(author).png

Principal Attorney, Yassi Law P.C.
Reza Yassi is the principal attorney at Yassi Law P.C., representing clients in commercial litigation and personal injury matters. He is known for his aggressive yet tactical approach, combining strategic planning with clear client communication while serving individuals and businesses across New York and New Jersey.

bottom of page