top of page

Non-Compete in the Sale of a Business in New York: Costly Mistakes With Seller Covenants and the Mohawk Duty Not to Solicit

Writer: Reza Yassi
Reza Yassi
1 day ago
9 min read
Non-Compete in the Sale of a Business in New York: Costly Mistakes With Seller Covenants and the Mohawk Duty Not to Solicit

In Mohawk Maintenance Co. v. Kessler, 52 N.Y.2d 276 (1981), New York's Court of Appeals held that when you sell a business and its goodwill, the law itself bars you from soliciting your former customers. No written covenant is required, and the duty has no expiration date. That rule sits underneath every non-compete in the sale of a business signed in New York, whether you're buying a Queens HVAC contractor or selling a Midtown accounting practice. The contract isn't the whole story. Courts look at what actually changed hands, and they treat a seller's promise very differently from an employee's.


Key takeaways


  • A non-compete tied to a genuine sale of goodwill gets a looser reasonableness test than an employee non-compete.

  • Calling a deal a sale won't help if no customers or goodwill actually transferred.

  • A seller of goodwill can't solicit former customers, even without a written covenant, and that duty has no time limit.

  • A narrow, short express non-solicit can replace the seller's permanent implied duty, so draft it deliberately.

  • Buyers seeking a preliminary injunction should move quickly and be ready to post an undertaking.


Why does labeling your deal a "sale" fail to protect a non-compete when no goodwill changes hands?


Because New York courts look past the label to what actually transferred, a covenant that isn't backed by a real transfer of goodwill gets judged as an ordinary employee restriction. That difference often decides the case.


An employee non-compete is disfavored. Courts enforce it only to the extent it's reasonably necessary to protect a legitimate employer interest, such as trade secrets, confidential information, or an employee's truly unique services, and only if it isn't unduly harsh on the worker or harmful to the public. If your real concern is a departing employee taking confidential data, the tools are different; see this guide to trade secret misappropriation in New York.


A non-compete in the sale of a business is treated far more favorably. The buyer paid for goodwill: the customer relationships, reputation, and expectation of repeat business that make a company worth more than its equipment. In Purchasing Associates, Inc. v. Weitz, 13 N.Y.2d 267 (1963), the Court of Appeals explained that a covenant ancillary to the sale of a business is enforceable if it's reasonable in time and space. The seller was paid for the customers, so the law lets the buyer keep them.


What happened in Purchasing Associates


The buyer in Purchasing Associates lost anyway. The deal was papered as a sale, but the defendant had transferred no customers or goodwill. “We must look behind and beyond the label to ascertain the true nature of the transaction,” the Court wrote. “What it really was, was a hiring of the defendant as an employee, plus the consequent elimination of the very short-lived partnership as a competitor.” Judged as an employee covenant, the restriction failed, and the buyer's injunction was reversed.


How to avoid it


If you're the buyer, build a record showing that goodwill really moved:


  • An allocation of part of the purchase price to goodwill and customer relationships, consistent with your tax filings.

  • A written assignment of customer lists, contracts, phone numbers, websites, and the trade name.

  • A recital that the seller's covenant protects the goodwill being sold.

  • Time and geographic limits that match where the business actually operates.


The paper trail matters elsewhere in the deal, too. If a business broker brought the parties together, General Obligations Law § 5-701(a)(10) makes an agreement to pay compensation for negotiating the sale of a business or its goodwill void unless it's in writing and signed by the party to be charged, with exceptions for attorneys, auctioneers, and licensed real estate brokers and salespeople. This overview of broker commission disputes in New York explains how fee claims are litigated.


Why is it risky to tie the seller's non-compete to a post-closing employment agreement?


Tying the covenant to the seller's job invites the argument that it protects an employment relationship rather than purchased goodwill, which is the argument that sank the buyer in Purchasing Associates. Many deals keep the seller on for a transition. Imagine the buyer of a Hicksville insurance agency who hires the founder as a consultant and folds the non-compete into the consulting contract, with the restricted period running from the day he leaves. Years later, when the founder opens a competing office in Garden City, the buyer has to prove the covenant was about the purchase, using documents that point toward the job.


Courts do apply the sale-of-business framework when the link to an acquisition is clear, even in less obvious structures. In Weiser LLP v. Coopersmith, 51 A.D.3d 583 (1st Dep't 2008), former partners of an accounting firm resisted their restrictive covenant. The First Department held the covenant was tied to a merger in which the firm acquired goodwill, so Purchasing Associates governed, and “That the former partners held only a minority interest in Lopez and Weiser does not render Purchasing Assoc. inapplicable.” The court reinstated the firm's covenant, liquidated-damages, and fiduciary-duty claims.


The fix is structural. Put the seller's covenant in the purchase agreement, state that it's given in exchange for the goodwill being sold, and handle salary, duties, and termination in a separate employment agreement. Sellers should understand that the way these documents are organized may matter years later, and get advice before closing.


Why do sellers wrongly assume they can call old customers because they never signed a non-compete?


Because the duty not to solicit comes from the law rather than the contract, a seller of goodwill who reaches out to former customers can be sued and enjoined even if the purchase agreement says nothing about competition. The Court of Appeals put it plainly in Mohawk Maintenance: “It is to prevent such an eventuality that the law imposes upon the seller a specific duty to refrain from soliciting his former customers after he has sold his business and the accompanying ‘good will’ to another.”


Two features make this duty unusually powerful. It isn't subject to the reasonableness limits that apply to express covenants, so there's no argument that it runs too long or covers too much territory. And it lasts indefinitely. In Mohawk, the Court affirmed an injunction with no end date barring the seller from soliciting his former customers.


Picture a seller who sold her Bayside commercial cleaning company with no non-compete at all, then, eight months later, starts calling her old office-building accounts from a new company. She may believe the deal left her free. Under Mohawk, those calls are exactly what the law forbids.


A buyout that follows a dispute still counts


Sellers sometimes argue the duty shouldn't apply because they didn't really want to sell. That failed in Hyde Park Products Corp. v. Maximilian Lerner Corp., 65 N.Y.2d 316 (1985). The seller received $525,000 in a buyout that followed an arbitration, and the Court of Appeals held it was still a voluntary sale. Soliciting former customers breached the implied duty. A truly involuntary transfer, such as a sale of the business by a bankruptcy trustee, can be treated differently, but reluctance or pressure from a dispute is not enough. If you're leaving a closely held company through a partner buyout, assume the duty follows you. If you want freedom to compete, negotiate it expressly.


Why do buyers overreach by trying to stop the seller from serving customers who come on their own?


Because the implied duty bars only solicitation, a buyer without an express covenant can't stop the seller from accepting business that former customers bring unprompted. Hyde Park drew that line: “Where such a covenant is not included, a seller is free to pursue his own economic interest and may accept his former customers’ trade. Likewise, the injunction should not prohibit ‘sales’ to Hyde Park customers; defendants should only be barred from improperly soliciting Hyde Park customers in the future.”


The buyer in Hyde Park won on liability, but its injunction was narrowed to solicitation, and the Court reversed a damages award measured by the seller's profits. A buyer who demands that a seller turn away every former customer, and claims every dollar the seller earned, is asking for more than the implied duty provides.


If you need protection against the seller doing any business with your customers, it has to come from an express covenant. Keneally, Lynch & Bak, LLP v. Salvi, 190 A.D.3d 961 (2d Dep't 2021), shows one that held. A lawyer sold his practice and its goodwill, agreed to a five-year, 15-mile non-compete, then opened an office about a mile away and contacted former clients. The Second Department upheld a preliminary injunction, finding that “the scope and duration of the covenant not to compete were reasonable and did not unreasonably harm the defendant or the general public.” Covenants that track the business's real customer base hold up better than sweeping ones; a statewide ban for a single Astoria storefront would invite a fight.


How can a narrow, short non-solicit clause cost a buyer the permanent protection the law already provides?


When buyer and seller specifically negotiate a limited non-solicitation clause, a court may hold that they agreed to replace the indefinite Mohawk duty with that narrower promise, leaving the buyer with nothing once it expires. That's what happened in CSI Group, LLP v. Harper, 153 A.D.3d 1314 (2d Dep't 2017). The seller sold his tax and accounting practice, worked for the buyer for five years, and served former clients only after his five-year non-solicit ran out.


The Second Department held that the implied restrictions recognized in Mohawk “are inapplicable, where, as here, the parties specifically negotiated and expressly agreed to impose a less onerous restriction upon the seller after the sale.” The express covenant there was limited in time and restricted to “tax clients.” The seller won summary judgment dismissing the buyer's claims and won liability on his counterclaim for the unpaid purchase price. (For how that procedural tool works, see this guide to summary judgment under CPLR § 3212.)


A clause that looks like extra protection on a term sheet, such as a three-year bar on soliciting “commercial accounts,” can work as a ceiling instead of a floor. Before signing, decide whether the express covenant should broaden the seller's obligations or narrow them, and draft so the answer is unmistakable. Language stating that the covenant supplements, rather than replaces, any duty implied by law is worth considering, though a court will still look at what the parties actually negotiated. And withholding purchase-price payments because you think the seller is competing is risky: if the court disagrees, you'll owe the balance anyway.


Why does waiting to act weaken a buyer's case against a seller who's soliciting customers?


Delay erodes the urgency that injunctive relief depends on, and every month of inaction lets the seller lock in relationships you paid for. The statute of limitations usually isn't the obstacle. Under CPLR § 213, an action upon a contractual obligation, express or implied, must be commenced within six years. The problem is practical: years later, the customers are gone, and proving what each lost account was worth is expensive.


The faster remedy is a preliminary injunction. Under CPLR § 6301, a court may grant one where the defendant is violating the plaintiff's rights in a way tending to render the judgment ineffectual, and a temporary restraining order may issue pending the hearing when immediate and irreparable injury will otherwise result. CPLR § 6312(a) requires that showing by affidavit and other evidence, so gather the seller's emails, customer statements, and deal documents before filing.


Budget for the bond. Under CPLR § 6312(b), before a preliminary injunction is granted, the plaintiff must give an undertaking, in an amount the court fixes, to pay the defendant's damages and costs if it's finally determined the plaintiff wasn't entitled to the injunction. The buyer in Keneally won its injunction but had to post one. For more on emergency relief, see this guide to preliminary injunctions and TROs in New York, and if the seller is moving assets to dodge a judgment, review prejudgment attachment under CPLR § 6201.


Check the purchase agreement for an arbitration clause first. Under CPLR § 7503, a party may apply to compel arbitration, and a party served with a proper notice of intention to arbitrate must move to stay it within 20 days or lose the right to object that no valid agreement was made or complied with.


Frequently Asked Questions


How long can a non-compete in the sale of a business last in New York?

No statute sets a fixed maximum. Courts ask whether the covenant is reasonable in time and space given the goodwill sold. In Keneally, the Second Department upheld a five-year, 15-mile covenant, but each case turns on its own business and market.

If a former customer calls me after I sell, can I take the work?

If your deal has no express non-compete, generally yes. Hyde Park held that without an express covenant a seller may accept former customers' trade and may be barred only from soliciting them. An express covenant can go further, so read yours carefully.

Does the sale-of-business standard apply if I only owned a minority stake?

It can. In Weiser, the First Department applied the sale-of-business framework to former partners with minority interests because their covenant was tied to a merger in which the firm acquired goodwill. What matters is whether goodwill actually transferred.

Can a buyer sue for damages instead of an injunction?

Yes. A claim on an express covenant is a contract claim with a six-year limitations period under CPLR § 213. Damages must be measured carefully, though; in Hyde Park, the Court of Appeals reversed an award based on the seller's profits.


A non-compete in the sale of a business is among the strongest restrictive covenants New York recognizes, but only when real goodwill changed hands and the documents show it. Sellers carry a permanent duty not to solicit unless they negotiate otherwise, and buyers can lose protection by drafting a narrow clause or waiting too long to act.


If you or your business is buying or selling a company, or facing a seller who's soliciting customers you paid for, Reza Yassi at Yassi Law PC is ready to help. Call us today at 646-992-2138 for a consultation.



Written by Reza Yassi | LinkedIn


Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.


This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Although I am an attorney, I am not your attorney, and reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws vary by jurisdiction and may have changed since the publication of this article. For advice specific to your situation, consult a qualified attorney.


slider 4.jpg
Reza Yassi(author).png

Principal Attorney, Yassi Law P.C.
Reza Yassi is the principal attorney at Yassi Law P.C., representing clients in commercial litigation and personal injury matters. He is known for his aggressive yet tactical approach, combining strategic planning with clear client communication while serving individuals and businesses across New York and New Jersey.

bottom of page