top of page

Prior Written Notice in Suffolk County: How Islip and Brookhaven Road Laws Can Sink a Motorcycle TBI Claim

Writer: Reza Yassi
Reza Yassi
9 hours ago
12 min read
Prior Written Notice in Suffolk County: How Islip and Brookhaven Road Laws Can Sink a Motorcycle TBI Claim

In 2026, the Appellate Division, Second Department, dismissed an injury claim against both the Town of Islip and Suffolk County in Bazarewski v. Town of Islip, 2026 NY Slip Op 03418 (2d Dep't 2026). The injured person blamed a pothole in a parking lot. Each government showed it had a written notice law and had never received a written complaint about that pothole, and the plaintiff offered no proof of an exception. If you ride a motorcycle on Long Island, that ruling matters to you. Prior written notice in Suffolk County can end a brain injury case against a town or the county before a jury ever hears it, and the Court of Appeals has recently explained the exceptions that can keep a claim alive.


Key takeaways


  • Towns and Suffolk County generally can't be sued over a road defect unless the right official got written notice of it first.

  • A claim can still survive if the town or county created the dangerous condition through its own work.

  • Online pothole complaints may count as written notice, so request those records early.

  • You generally have 90 days to serve a notice of claim on a town or the county.

  • Photograph the defect and get an expert to the scene before road crews repair it.


What happened in Bazarewski v. Town of Islip, and why did the town and county win?


The town and county won because each proved it had a prior written notice law and had received no written notice of the pothole, and the injured person had no evidence that fit an exception. A prior written notice law is a rule that says a local government can't be sued over a broken road, sidewalk, or similar defect unless someone first told the right official about it in writing.


The Second Department named the specific laws involved. In the court's words, "the Town and the County have each enacted a prior written notice law ( see Town Law § 65-a[2]; Code of Town of Islip § 47A-3[A]; Suffolk County Charter § C8-2[A][2]), and each established, prima facie, that it had not received any written notices regarding the allegedly defective condition of the parking lot." "Prima facie" simply means the town and county put in enough proof to win unless the injured person answered it.


That is where the claim fell apart. The Court of Appeals explained the order of proof years ago in Yarborough v. City of New York, 10 N.Y.3d 726 (N.Y. 2008). Once a municipality shows it had no prior written notice, the burden moves to you to prove that an exception applies. In Bazarewski, nothing filled that gap, so the claims against both governments were dismissed.


The case involved a parking lot, but the same reasoning applies to a town road. Picture a rider heading home through Holbrook or Selden when the front wheel drops into a broken trench patch. A car would take that hit as a jolt. A motorcycle can pitch its rider headfirst onto the pavement.


The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration reports that motorcyclists are far more likely than people in passenger cars to die in a crash per mile traveled, and it identifies helmets as the most effective way to reduce head injuries. Even with a helmet, the brain can be badly hurt. The CDC explains that a traumatic brain injury disrupts how the brain normally works and that moderate and severe injuries can cause lasting problems with thinking, memory, movement, and mood.


When the road itself caused a single-vehicle crash, there's often no other driver and no other insurance policy to turn to. The town or county may be the only defendant. That is why the notice law, and its exceptions, decide so many of these cases.


Who has to receive written notice of a road defect in Suffolk County?


It depends on who owns the road: for a town road, written notice generally has to reach the town clerk or the town superintendent of highways, and for a county road it has to reach the officials named in Suffolk County's own notice law.


Town roads in Brookhaven, Islip, and the other Suffolk towns


Under Town Law § 65-a, no civil action may be maintained against a town for injuries caused by a defective, unsafe, or dangerous highway unless written notice of the condition was actually given to the town clerk or the town superintendent of highways, and the town then failed to fix it within a reasonable time. Subdivision 1 also contains language allowing a claim, in the absence of written notice, where the condition existed so long that it should have been found and fixed. Towns also adopt their own local notice laws, as the Islip code cited in Bazarewski shows, so the local code has to be read alongside the state statute before you count on that language.


The statute also tells you where the paper trail lives. The highway superintendent must send every written notice to the town clerk within ten days. The town clerk must keep an indexed record of written notices, organized by the location of the defect, and preserve each one for five years. That index is the first thing to request when a crash happens on a town road in Brookhaven, Islip, Babylon, Huntington, or Smithtown.


County roads


Suffolk also maintains county roads, such as Nicolls Road (County Road 97). Under Highway Law § 139, a county that has charge of a road can be liable for injuries caused by its defective condition, but only if a notice of claim is served and the suit is filed on time. The same section lets a county pass a local law requiring prior written notice to the clerk of its governing body or the county highway superintendent. Suffolk has one; Bazarewski cited Suffolk County Charter § C8-2(A)(2).


State roads are a different case


Sunrise Highway and Jericho Turnpike are state routes. The town and county notice laws discussed here don't govern them, and a claim against New York State goes to the Court of Claims, where a judge decides the case without a jury. That process is covered in this post on suing New York State for a dangerous roadway.


Road ownership on Long Island can change from one intersection to the next. A road with a local street name may be a county road for part of its length, and a crash near a corner may involve pavement owned by two governments. When ownership is unclear, notices of claim are often served on every entity that might own the spot, the way the plaintiff in Bazarewski named both the town and the county. Fixing a missed owner later means asking a court for permission to serve a late notice, and that permission isn't guaranteed. Nassau riders face a similar problem with an extra layer of village governments, as explained in this post on the prior written notice trap in Nassau County.


Can a motorcycle TBI claim survive without prior written notice?


Yes, a claim can survive if you prove that the town or county created the dangerous condition through its own work, or that it made a special use of the spot. Courts call the first one the affirmative-creation or affirmative-negligence exception, and it's the one that matters most in road cases.


Calabrese: a motorcycle crash and a botched repair


The leading recent case involved a motorcyclist. In Calabrese v. City of Albany, 2024 NY Slip Op 06289 (N.Y. 2024), a rider crashed on Lark Street in Albany. The Court of Appeals let the case go forward on two separate grounds.


First, the court held that reports typed into the city's online complaint system could count as prior written notice to the official named in the city's law. The court wrote that "the SCF reports at issue here could constitute prior written notice." Second, the rider's expert attacked the city's earlier excavation repair, while a city official said the patched hole was flat and even with the surrounding road. That conflict in the evidence raised a real question about affirmative negligence that a jury had to decide.


Why a repair that wears out over time usually fails


The exception has a firm limit. In Yarborough, the city may have patched the pothole poorly, but the plaintiff's own expert said the patch broke down over time from weather and traffic. The Court of Appeals pointed out that the expert "found that the deterioration of the asphalt patch—the condition that caused plaintiffs injury—developed over time with environmental wear and tear." That was fatal. The repair has to create a condition that is dangerous right away, not one that becomes dangerous later.


The Court of Appeals repeated that rule in Gurbanova v. City of Ithaca, 2025 NY Slip Op 07076 (N.Y. 2025). There, a city had installed a bollard (a short post) in a municipal parking lot 14 years before the accident. The court held that the notice law covered the bollard, and that the plaintiff's expert offered only conclusions without industry standards or data to back them up. The record suggested any defect came from environmental conditions over time. The court also noted that the condition must be immediately dangerous, but it doesn't have to be immediately obvious to the eye.


For a Suffolk rider, that distinction can decide the case. A town crew that paves over a trench and leaves a sharp lip, or a resurfacing job that leaves a steep drop-off at the shoulder, may have created a hazard the day the work ended. A patch that slowly sank over several winters is a much harder claim.


Casiano: when the government built the hazard


The exception also works when the government installs something dangerous. In Casiano v. City of New York, 2024 NY Slip Op 00222 (1st Dep't 2024), the city had installed a raised traffic device right next to a crosswalk, and photographs showed the condition hadn't changed. The court held that "a factfinder could reasonably determine that the City's installation of a raised device mere inches from a busy pedestrian crosswalk could create an immediately dangerous tripping hazard for pedestrians." The case went forward. Raised markers, castings, and other road hardware a town installs can raise the same question for a motorcycle.


The special-use exception


The second exception, special use, applies when the government got a special benefit from the spot beyond the public's ordinary use of the road. It comes up far less often in pothole and pavement cases, but it's worth checking when the defect sits at a town facility entrance or a spot the town used for its own purposes. You can read how courts upstate have applied these exceptions in this post on how the prior written notice exception is saving roadway defect claims.


How can FOIL requests and road-repair records help or hurt your claim?


FOIL requests can uncover proof of written notice or a bad repair, but the same records can also sink a claim, so they need to be gathered early and read carefully before anyone takes a position. FOIL is New York's Freedom of Information Law, which gives the public a right to see government records.


Under Public Officers Law § 87, each agency must make its records available for public inspection and copying, except records that fall within listed exemptions. Paper copies generally can't cost more than 25 cents per page. The state's Committee on Open Government publishes guidance and advisory opinions on how FOIL works, which helps when a town is slow to respond.


After Calabrese, the reach of these requests matters more. If an online complaint can count as written notice, then emails, app submissions, and online service requests about the spot may be as important as letters in the clerk's file. A focused FOIL request to a Suffolk town or the county often asks for the following:


  • The town clerk's indexed record of written notices for the crash location, covering five years.

  • Online complaints, emails, and service requests mentioning the road segment.

  • Work orders, paving logs, and inspection reports for repairs at that spot.

  • Street-opening permits issued to utilities or contractors who dug there.

  • Paving contracts and the specifications the crew was supposed to follow.


Repair records cut both ways. In Acevedo v. City of New York, 2026 NY Slip Op 01120 (1st Dep't 2026), city records showed potholes at the location were fixed weeks before the accident, which defeated the claim of prior written notice. The plaintiff's expert also never inspected the site and relied on photographs of unknown origin. The court found that affidavit "was not probative of the accident site's condition on the date of the accident, given that the engineer never inspected the accident location." In plain words, an expert who never went there couldn't prove what the road looked like that day.


The lesson is about timing. In a road case, records get updated, defects get patched, and memories fade, so the proof has to be locked down early. Make sure a police accident report is made, get the report number, and keep copies of anything you send to the town or county about the crash. A written report made after the crash won't serve as prior written notice of the defect, since it comes after the fact, but it fixes the date, place, and cause on paper. And as Acevedo shows, an engineer needs to see the actual spot before it changes.


Report the accident right away. Almost every storefront has a security camera, and that includes the delis, gas stations, and strip malls along Suffolk's town roads. Footage is often recorded over within days or weeks. When Yassi Law PC is contacted early, it can use preservation letters, subpoenas, and FOIL requests to get the video before it's gone.


What should you do in the first weeks after a Suffolk County motorcycle crash with a brain injury?


You should serve a notice of claim within 90 days, preserve evidence of the road before it's repaired, and document the brain injury thoroughly. Each of those steps has its own deadline or risk.


Under General Municipal Law § 50-e, a notice of claim against a town or county must be served within ninety days after the claim arises. It must be sworn and must state the time, place, and manner of the accident and the injuries claimed so far. For a town or Suffolk County, the notice must not state a dollar amount of damages. This post on the 90-day notice of claim trap explains how that deadline ends cases.


Here are the main deadlines once a town or county is involved:


  • 90 days after the crash to serve the notice of claim, under GML § 50-e.

  • 90 days after filing the notice for the town or county to demand a 50-h examination.

  • At least 30 days after serving the notice before the lawsuit may be filed.

  • One year and 90 days after the crash to start the lawsuit, under GML § 50-i.


The 50-h examination, allowed by General Municipal Law § 50-h, is a sworn question-and-answer session about the accident and your injuries, and it can include a physical exam by a doctor. You have the right to a lawyer there. The lawsuit deadline comes from General Municipal Law § 50-i.


Evidence of the road disappears fast. Towns often patch a defect soon after a serious crash. Dated photographs with a ruler or a coin for scale, video of the area, and an early inspection by an engineer can make the difference that the plaintiff in Acevedo lacked.


Brain injuries are easy to understate early on. The Mayo Clinic notes that some TBI symptoms appear right away while others may not show up for days or weeks. The Brain Injury Association of America describes brain injury as a chronic health condition, not a single event. Tell every doctor about memory gaps, headaches, light sensitivity, and mood changes, and keep a simple daily journal. Expect the defense to send you to its own doctor, a topic covered in this post on the defense medical exam after a New York motorcycle crash.


Expect the town to blame your riding too. Under Vehicle and Traffic Law § 1250, a motorcyclist has all the rights and duties of any other driver. A town lawyer will ask about your speed, your lane position, and whether you should have seen the defect, so your own account should be careful and consistent from the first day.


Frequently Asked Questions


It can. In Calabrese v. City of Albany, the Court of Appeals held that reports typed into a city's online complaint system could count as prior written notice to the official named in the law. Whether a particular Suffolk town's system qualifies depends on its local law and whether the report reached the right official, so those records should be requested early.

Prior written notice laws protect towns, villages, cities, and counties. They don't shield a private utility or paving contractor that opened or patched the road. Street-opening permits obtained through FOIL can identify who worked at the spot, and that company may be a separate defendant.

You generally must serve a sworn notice of claim within 90 days of the crash, and the lawsuit itself must be filed within one year and 90 days. A court can sometimes allow a late notice of claim, but that permission isn't guaranteed. Waiting also gives the town time to repair the defect and erase the physical evidence.

Yes. When it isn't clear who owns or maintains the spot, notices of claim are often served on every government that might be responsible, as the plaintiff did in Bazarewski v. Town of Islip. Each one needs its own timely notice of claim, and each will look for whether it received prior written notice of the defect.



Prior written notice in Suffolk County is a real barrier, and Bazarewski shows that a claim with no evidence of an exception will be dismissed against both a town and the county. But Calabrese, Gurbanova, and Casiano show that online complaints, a repair that was dangerous from day one, or a hazard the government installed can keep a brain injury case alive. The difference usually comes down to how fast the records, the scene, and the expert proof are secured.


If you or someone you know suffered a brain injury in a motorcycle crash caused by a broken road in Brookhaven, Islip, or anywhere in Suffolk County, Reza Yassi at Yassi Law PC is ready to help. Call us today at 646-992-2138 for a consultation.




Written by Reza Yassi | LinkedIn


This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Although I am an attorney, I am not your attorney, and reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws vary by jurisdiction and may have changed since the publication of this article. For advice specific to your situation, consult a qualified attorney.


slider 4.jpg
Reza Yassi(author).png

Principal Attorney, Yassi Law P.C.
Reza Yassi is the principal attorney at Yassi Law P.C., representing clients in commercial litigation and personal injury matters. He is known for his aggressive yet tactical approach, combining strategic planning with clear client communication while serving individuals and businesses across New York and New Jersey.

bottom of page