Splitting a Wrongful Death Settlement in New York After a Crane Collapse: Costly Mistakes With Allocation, Children's Shares, and Liens


New York law does not automatically divide a wrongful death settlement equally among a family. Under EPTL § 5-4.4, the money is "exclusively for the benefit of the decedent's distributees" and is shared "in proportion to the pecuniary injuries suffered by them," as decided after a court hearing. That rule catches grieving families off guard, especially after a crane collapse kills a worker or a passerby and the case resolves for a large sum. If you're about to receive a wrongful death settlement in New York, the way it's divided, approved for your children, and reduced by liens can matter as much as the headline number.
Key takeaways
Wrongful death money in New York is divided by each family member's financial loss, not automatically in equal shares.
A court must approve the settlement and decide each person's share after a hearing.
A child's share is usually held in a court-controlled account or annuity, not handed to a parent.
Workers' compensation, Medicaid, Medicare, and union health plans may claim repayment, so ask about liens early.
Save records of support, contact, and closeness with your loved one, because that proof drives each share.
Why is assuming the money will be split equally a costly mistake?
Assuming an equal split is a mistake because New York courts divide wrongful death proceeds by each family member's own financial loss, not by headcount. The law calls this "pecuniary loss," which simply means the money, support, household services, and parental guidance a person can show they lost because your loved one died.
Crane work is dangerous enough that OSHA maintains a dedicated safety standard for cranes and derricks in construction, and the Bureau of Labor Statistics' injury and fatality data consistently places construction among the industries with the most fatal work injuries. When a collapse does happen, the family is left with grief and, eventually, a settlement to divide.
Picture a tower crane collapse at a high-rise going up in Long Island City, Queens. The rigger killed was 46. He leaves a wife, a 9-year-old daughter, a 15-year-old son, and a 24-year-old son from his first marriage who lives in New Jersey. After the case against the crane owner and the rigging contractor settles, nearly everyone at the kitchen table expects four equal shares. That expectation is often wrong.
The First Department said it plainly in Matter of Dixson, 2021 NY Slip Op 02870 (1st Dep't 2021): "The proceeds of a wrongful death action belong to the statutory distributees of the decedent and not to the estate; therefore, the law does not presume equal distribution of shares." In that case, a Surrogate gave one distributee 50% without first holding a hearing on pecuniary loss. The appellate court reversed and sent the case back for that hearing.
The Kaiser formula, and why it isn't the final word
Many lawyers start with a calculation known as the Kaiser formula. It gives each dependent a share based on how many years that person would have relied on the decedent's support. A young child, with many years of dependency ahead, can end up with a much larger share than a teenager. In the Long Island City example, the 9-year-old would likely come out ahead of her 15-year-old brother under that math.
But the formula isn't mandatory. In In re Acquafredda, 189 A.D.2d 504 (2d Dep't 1993), the Second Department held that "there is no imperative for the automatic application of Kaiser" and that the Surrogate "is vested with discretion and with equitable powers" over allocation. The court affirmed equal one-third shares for a widow and two children, and the Surrogate was allowed to consider the widow's remarriage when dividing the money. Remarriage doesn't shrink what a defendant owes. It can, however, affect how the family splits it.
Adult children aren't shut out, either. In In re the Estate of Duffy, 208 A.D.2d 1169 (3d Dep't 1994), the youngest of nine children asked for 95.5% of the proceeds under the Kaiser formula. The court instead set aside $10,000 off the top for her remaining months of minority support and split the rest equally among all nine, noting that adult children "may state a claim for pecuniary injuries based upon the loss of a parent’s guidance." So the 24-year-old son in our example has a real claim, even though he no longer lived at home.
The way to avoid this mistake is to assume nothing about shares until each person's loss has been documented. For a deeper look at who qualifies as a distributee, our guide on how a New York wrongful death settlement is divided among a spouse, children, and estranged relatives walks through the basics.
Why is going into the allocation hearing without proof of the relationship a mistake?
It's a mistake because the allocation hearing is decided on evidence, and the family member with the stronger record of closeness and support usually receives the larger share. Family stories and strong feelings don't carry much weight on their own. Documents, neutral witnesses, and specific facts do.
Consider In re the Estate of Ellers, 309 A.D.2d 1055 (App. Div. 2003). A son died, and his divorced parents were the only distributees. The court affirmed a 90% to 10% split in the mother's favor, based on evidence of the father's abuse, the son's estrangement from him, and the son's closeness with and help to his mother. As the court put it, "There is no strict mathematical formula to determine this proportion," and "divorced parents who are the sole distributees will not necessarily receive equal shares."
Some things don't count at all. In In re the Estate Cassar, 188 A.D.2d 946 (App. Div. 1992), a mother received 74% partly because she had driven the lawsuit after her child's death. The appellate court changed the split to an equal division, holding that "the relative participation of each party in this litigation after the death can play no role in the distribution." The relative who sat through every deposition doesn't earn a bigger share for it. Loss is measured as of the death.
EPTL § 5-4.4 also directs the court deciding shares to resolve any question about whether a parent or surviving spouse is disqualified from sharing at all. New York law can, for example, bar a parent who abandoned or failed to support a child. If an absent parent surfaces after a crane death in Astoria or Bushwick, that question gets decided in the same proceeding.
One evidence trap deserves attention. The Ellers decision flags problems under New York's Dead Man's Statute, a rule that can block a family member with a financial stake from testifying about personal conversations with the person who died. That means your own memories of what your loved one said may not come in. Proof from outside sources becomes far more important, and it helps to start collecting it early:
Pay stubs, union records, and tax returns showing what your loved one earned and who depended on it.
Bank transfers, Zelle records, or receipts showing money sent to specific relatives.
Texts, call logs, and photos showing regular contact with each family member.
School, sports, and medical records showing a parent's involvement in a child's life.
Names of neutral witnesses, such as coworkers from the union hall, neighbors, coaches, or clergy.
Why does confusing the wrongful death claim with the pain and suffering claim cost families?
It costs families because those two parts of a settlement follow different legal paths, and mixing them up can send money to the wrong people. The wrongful death claim compensates the family's financial loss. The conscious pain and suffering claim, often called a survival claim, compensates the pain and fear your loved one experienced before dying, and it belongs to the estate.
Under EPTL § 5-4.3, wrongful death damages are the "fair and just compensation for the pecuniary injuries" resulting from the death. The statute also allows reasonable medical, nursing, and funeral expenses paid by the distributees, adds interest from the date of death, and permits punitive damages if they would have been recoverable had the decedent survived. Those funds are divided by pecuniary loss, as described above.
The survival portion works differently. Cassar confirms that pain and suffering money passes through the estate under the rules of intestacy, meaning the default inheritance rules when there's no will. Under those rules, a spouse with children generally takes the first $50,000 plus half of the remainder, and the children share the rest. If there is a will, it controls instead. Because that money is an estate asset, it can also be exposed to the decedent's debts and the costs of administering the estate.
Think about how that plays out after our crane collapse. If the rigger lived for 40 minutes trapped under steel before he died at a nearby hospital, part of the settlement may be assigned to his conscious pain and suffering. How the settlement is allocated between the two claims changes what the widow, the young children, and the adult son each receive. That split should be a deliberate, documented decision, not an afterthought. Our article on conscious pain and suffering in New York wrongful death cases explains how that claim is proven.
Deductions come out before anyone's share, too. EPTL § 5-4.4(b) lets the court fix and deduct the reasonable expenses of the action or settlement, plus medical and funeral expenses if they were included in the recovery, and the Surrogate may fix the personal representative's commissions. For an overview of every category a family can pursue, see our guide to what families can recover in a New York wrongful death lawsuit.
Why is treating a child's share like an adult's share a mistake?
It's a mistake because a minor's share can't simply be handed to a surviving parent; New York requires court oversight of how a child's money is approved, held, and eventually paid out. That protection exists even when the parent is loving and responsible.
The process starts with court approval of the settlement itself. Under EPTL § 5-4.6, when the personal representative applies to the court where the wrongful death action is pending, the court must, within 60 days, look into the merits and the proposed amount and either approve or disapprove the compromise. The defendant pays into an interest-bearing escrow account for the distributees. Court-approved expenses come out first, and the attorney's approved fees are payable once proof is filed that a petition for allocation and distribution has been filed in Surrogate's Court.
When a distributee is a child, EPTL § 5-4.6(b) requires the court to decide whether a guardian ad litem is needed before any payments are made. A guardian ad litem is a lawyer the court appoints to protect the child's interests in the case. That matters because a surviving spouse and the children can have competing interests at the allocation hearing. A larger share for the widow means smaller shares for the 9-year-old and the 15-year-old.
Once shares are set, CPLR 1206 controls how a child's money is held. The court may order it deposited in an insured bank account or invested in insured or guaranteed government securities, with withdrawals allowed only by court order. It may also order a structured settlement, with future installment payments funded by an annuity from a qualified insurer approved by the state's superintendent of financial services. For property worth $10,000 or less, the court can let the person the child lives with hold it.
Here's a detail many parents never hear about. Under CPLR 1206(c), once the child turns 18, the bank pays over the entire blocked account without any court order, unless a court has directed the bank to keep holding it. An 18-year-old in Ozone Park could walk out of a branch with the full balance. A structured settlement can instead spread payments into the child's twenties, timed for college tuition, a first apartment, or later milestones, and the statute says the child's ability to speed up those payments after 18 is governed by the agreement's terms. Our post on structured settlements in New York catastrophic injury cases explains how annuities are set up.
If a child also has a personal injury claim of their own, such as a child struck by falling debris on the sidewalk, that claim needs its own infant compromise. CPLR 1208 requires sworn papers from the child's representative describing the proposed distribution and whether family members made their own claims from the same event. It also bars any attorney with a conflicting interest from representing the child.
Why is waiting until the check arrives to deal with liens a costly mistake?
It's a costly mistake because liens are paid before your family receives its shares, and a lien discovered late can freeze the money for months or quietly reduce every person's piece. A lien is a legal claim to be repaid out of the settlement.
In our practice, many clients are surprised that workers' compensation, Medicaid, and Medicare can be entitled to repayment from a settlement for the treatment they paid for. We explain these liens early so the net recovery isn't a surprise. After a crane death, the common ones look like this:
The workers' compensation carrier, for death benefits and medical bills paid to or for the family.
Medicaid, for care provided after the injury, through the local social services district or the state.
Medicare, if your loved one was enrolled and Medicare paid for treatment.
A union welfare fund or employer health plan governed by ERISA, the federal benefits law.
Workers' compensation is usually the largest lien when the person killed was on the job. Under Workers' Compensation Law § 29, dependents can collect death benefits and still sue a third party, such as the crane owner or a subcontractor who wasn't the employer. The carrier then has a lien on the recovery, after deducting reasonable litigation expenses including attorney's fees, for compensation awarded or estimated and medical expenses. The family can ask the court to apportion those litigation costs equitably between the family and the carrier, which makes the carrier carry its fair share of the legal fees. Section 29 also requires notice of the lawsuit within 30 days to the Workers' Compensation Board chair, the employer, and the carrier. Separately, New York law generally requires the carrier's consent or a court order before settling a third-party case, or the family's future death benefits can be put at risk.
Medicaid's rights come from Social Services Law § 104-b. It gives the public welfare official a lien up to the amount of assistance provided on and after the date of injury, but the lien isn't effective unless written notice is served before any money is paid. You can learn more about the program through the New York State Department of Health. Medicare's repayment rights come from the federal Medicare Secondary Payer law, 42 U.S.C. § 1395y, which makes Medicare's payments conditional when another party is responsible.
Health plans are where families get blindsided. New York generally protects injured people from reimbursement claims by insured health plans. Many union welfare funds in the building trades are self-funded plans governed by ERISA, however, and federal law can override that state protection. Under the U.S. Supreme Court's decision in US Airways, Inc. v. McCutchen (2013), a plan's written reimbursement terms generally control. Plans sue to enforce those terms under 29 U.S.C. § 1132. Requesting the actual plan document early, not just the summary booklet, is often the first step to reducing that claim. Our guide on Medicare, Medicaid, and ERISA liens on a New York catastrophic injury settlement covers negotiation in more detail.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does a family have to file a wrongful death case after a crane collapse in New York?
Under EPTL 5-4.1, a wrongful death action generally must be started within two years after the death. If a criminal action is brought against the same defendant over the same event, the family has at least one year from the end of that criminal case. Other notice rules can apply depending on who is sued, so it's wise to speak with a lawyer well before the deadline.
Can a stepchild or an unmarried partner share in a New York wrongful death settlement?
Wrongful death proceeds go to the decedent's distributees, which are the relatives who would inherit under New York's intestacy rules. An unmarried partner is not a distributee, and a stepchild generally is not one unless legally adopted. Those relationships can still matter in other ways, so ask your lawyer about your specific family situation.
Who decides how much each family member receives?
A judge decides, not the jury and not the family. Under EPTL 5-4.4, the shares are set after a hearing by either the court handling the lawsuit or the Surrogate's Court in the county that issued letters to the personal representative. Family members can agree on a proposed split, but the court still has to approve it based on each person's pecuniary loss.
Is a wrongful death settlement taxable?
Under federal tax law, damages received on account of a personal physical injury or death are generally not counted as income. Punitive damages and interest can be taxable, and the survival portion paid to the estate may raise estate tax questions in larger cases. A tax professional should review the settlement before the money is distributed.
Dividing a wrongful death settlement in New York is a court-supervised process, not a family vote. Shares follow proven financial loss, children's money stays under court protection, and liens come off the top. Building the evidence, structuring the children's shares, and resolving liens early is how families protect what the settlement is meant to provide.
If you or someone you know lost a family member in a crane collapse or another construction accident in New York, the team at Yassi Law PC is ready to help. Call us today at 646-992-2138 for a consultation.
Written by Reza Yassi | LinkedIn
Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Although I am an attorney, I am not your attorney, and reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws vary by jurisdiction and may have changed since the publication of this article. For advice specific to your situation, consult a qualified attorney.


.png)