top of page

The Implied Covenant of Good Faith and Fair Dealing in New York: A Guide for NYC Business Owners

Writer: Reza Yassi
Reza Yassi
Jun 1
11 min read

Updated: Nov 10

The Implied Covenant of Good Faith and Fair Dealing in New York: A Guide for NYC Business Owners

Updated October 23, 2026


You sign a ten-year exclusive distribution agreement to sell a manufacturer's products throughout the five boroughs. The contract gives the manufacturer sole discretion to approve your marketing plans. For five years, everything runs smoothly. Then the manufacturer's new owner decides it wants to sell direct in New York City, starts rejecting every marketing plan you submit, and uses your inactivity as grounds to terminate. The express terms of the contract look like they let the manufacturer do exactly what it did. You're not powerless. The implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing in New York is one of the most underused tools in commercial litigation, and one of the most misunderstood.


At Yassi Law PC, we handle $1M–$10M commercial disputes across Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx, Staten Island, Nassau County, and Suffolk County. The implied covenant comes up constantly in distribution agreements, joint ventures, condo sponsor disputes, requirements contracts, and any deal where one party has discretion over performance. Here's what every NYC business owner should understand before threatening, or defending against, an implied covenant claim.


Key takeaways


  • New York reads a promise of good faith into every contract, so neither side may destroy the other's right to the benefits of the deal.

  • An implied covenant claim must target conduct your contract's express terms do not already cover, or courts will dismiss it as duplicative.

  • If the other side has discretion over approvals, audits or terminations, it still may not use that discretion arbitrarily or to undercut your deal.

  • The covenant cannot rewrite your contract, add terms you never agreed to, or override clear express terms.

  • Plead specific facts about who decided what, when, and which benefit you lost, and track the contract deadline from the breach, which is generally six years but shorter if your contract is for the sale of goods.


What is the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing in New York?


The implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing in New York is a doctrine that reads an unwritten promise into every contract: neither party will do anything to destroy the other side's right to receive the benefits of the bargain. It exists in every commercial agreement governed by New York law, whether the parties wrote it down or not. You can't contract out of it.


Under New York law, when a contract grants one party discretionary authority, that discretion must be exercised in good faith, meaning the decision must be reasonable and non-arbitrary. The Court of Appeals put it this way in Dalton v. Educational Testing Serv., 87 N.Y.2d 384 (1995): the covenant works to ensure that a party with discretion "does not act arbitrarily or irrationally."


That principle now governs essentially every commercial contract in New York. In the New York Commercial Division, complex business cases routinely involve good-faith disputes alongside breach claims because the covenant fills the gaps that no contract drafter can fully anticipate. Think of it this way: the express terms are the skeleton; the implied covenant is the connective tissue that keeps a party from gaming the contract.


When does the implied covenant create an independent claim versus a duplicative one?


The implied covenant supports an independent claim only when the conduct you're complaining about is not already covered by a straight breach-of-contract claim. This is the doctrine's biggest trap. New York courts routinely dismiss implied covenant claims as duplicative when plaintiffs simply re-plead their breach claim under a different label.


It is well established that the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing can support a claim where one party's deliberate inaction (even absent an express contractual deadline) deprives the other party of a benefit they had bargained for. This principle applies, for example, where a condo sponsor sells an initial wave of units but then withholds remaining inventory, thereby preventing the building's transition to unit-owner control that early purchasers had reasonably expected.


Compare that with the typical losing case. You sue your supplier for failing to deliver under section 4.2 of the contract, then add a count alleging the supplier breached the implied covenant by failing to deliver. The second count goes nowhere. The Appellate Division, First Department, has repeatedly held that an implied covenant claim covering the same conduct and seeking the same damages as a breach claim must be dismissed. In BML Props. Ltd. v. China Constr. Am., Inc., 2024 NY Slip Op 02252 (1st Dep't 2024), for example, the court dismissed an implied covenant claim as duplicative because it arose from the same facts as the breach of contract claim and the conduct fell within the contract's best efforts obligation. Most NYC business owners miss that you cannot use the implied covenant as a backup theory for the same set of facts — it must reach conduct the express terms don't already address.


If you're considering an implied covenant theory, the threshold question is always: what conduct am I challenging, and is that conduct already captured by an express promise in the contract? If the answer is yes, plead breach and move on. If the answer is no, but you've still been deprived of a contractual benefit, the implied covenant may be your strongest theory. This analysis is similar in spirit to how courts approach pleading fraud alongside breach of contract: the second theory has to do real work that the first one can't.


How does the implied covenant apply to discretionary decisions in your contract?


The implied covenant has the most bite when one party holds discretion over how the contract gets performed. New York courts apply the covenant to prevent that discretion from being exercised arbitrarily, irrationally, or in bad faith. This is where substantial distribution disputes get decided. In Gutt v. North Am. Partners in Anesthesia, LLP, 2025 NY Slip Op 02326 (2d Dep't 2025), the Second Department held that a party can breach the implied covenant by exercising a contractual right, even an explicitly discretionary one, as part of a scheme to deprive the other side of the benefit of the bargain.


Common NYC scenarios where discretion-based good faith claims arise:


  • A franchisor with sole approval over new locations rejects every site you propose to push you out

  • A licensor sets royalty audit standards so onerous they swallow your margin

  • A lender with discretion over loan modifications denies relief to force a default

  • A buyer in a requirements contract suddenly buys nothing while continuing to sell the underlying product


An acquirer runs the business it bought in a way that undercuts the seller's earn-out targets


Under New York law, even where a party has contractual discretion, the implied covenant requires that discretion to be exercised consistent with the parties' reasonable expectations. Discretion is not a license to torpedo the deal.


New York's highest court has now made the same point. In 111 W. 57th Inv. LLC v. 111 W57 Mezz Inv. LLC, 2026 NY Slip Op 03376 (N.Y. 2026), the Court of Appeals reinstated an implied covenant claim that the Appellate Division had dismissed because the defendant held absolute discretion. The Court described the covenant as barring discretion exercised to frustrate the other side's rights under the contract.


For NYC business owners, the practical takeaway is this: if your contract gives the other side discretion over approvals, audits, terminations, allocations, or sourcing, that discretion comes with a built-in reasonableness check. When you draft, you should think hard about whether you want broad discretion (which invites good faith litigation) or specific objective criteria (which can be enforced cleanly). When you litigate, you should look for any contractual lever the other side pulled and ask whether the pull was rational.


The paper trail matters on both sides of a discretion dispute. If you hold the discretion, write down your business reasons when you make the call, not months later when a lawyer asks. If you are on the receiving end, ask for written explanations as decisions come in and keep every email that shows a pattern of rejections. The same care belongs in drafting. If your deal includes an earn-out, spell out how the business will be run during the earn-out period, such as hiring, marketing spend and how shared resources are divided. Define any "commercially reasonable efforts" standard instead of leaving it open.


Contracts drafted with AI tools can create disputes of their own. AI can produce a polished generic contract, but if you don't know what you need it to say, it may leave out the terms that protect you, and that gap has become a real source of litigation.


What are the limits of the implied covenant in New York?


The implied covenant has hard limits, and most failed claims fail because they push past them. The doctrine cannot rewrite a contract you regret. It cannot impose obligations the parties never agreed to. And it cannot override clear express terms.


It is well established under New York law that the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing cannot create independent obligations that contradict or add to the express terms of a contract. Where an at-will employment agreement permits either side to terminate for any reason, the implied covenant will not transform that into a for-cause requirement. The Court of Appeals applied that rule in Murphy v. American Home Prods. Corp., 58 N.Y.2d 293 (1983), dismissing an at-will employee's claim that his employer breached an implied duty to deal with him fairly and in good faith when it fired him.


The doctrine also will not bail you out when the contract is silent on price. Under UCC § 2-305, a sale-of-goods contract with an open price term can still be enforced at a reasonable price if the parties intended to be bound, and a price left for one party to fix must be fixed in good faith, but for non-goods commercial contracts in New York, courts won't use the covenant to manufacture pricing terms the parties never agreed on. You can't ask a judge to write the deal you wish you'd negotiated.


A few other guardrails worth knowing. The covenant doesn't apply to purely discretionary decisions where the contract makes clear the discretion is unfettered — for example, a "sole and absolute discretion" clause is harder (though not impossible) to attack. Look at whether a discretionary clause uses the words "sole," "absolute," or "in its discretion" without qualifiers. Those modifiers narrow the implied covenant but do not eliminate it. The conduct must still be neither arbitrary nor irrational. The covenant also cannot be used to recover punitive damages on its own, and it does not survive after a contract has been fully performed.


Don't expect to turn a good-faith dispute into a tort case, either. New York does not recognize a separate tort of bad faith in ordinary commercial contracts. Relabeling an implied covenant claim as fraud or a business tort will not, by itself, open the door to punitive damages, and a fraud count has to meet New York's stricter pleading rules. The two claims also look at different moments. The implied covenant covers bad faith while the contract is being performed. Fraudulent inducement covers false statements made to get you to sign in the first place. The two often appear together when a party lies to close a deal and then performs it in bad faith.


One more critical limit: the parol evidence rule still applies. If you're trying to introduce side conversations to prove bad faith, you face the same evidentiary hurdles that any contract claim faces. We covered those rules in detail in our post on the parol evidence rule in New York.


How should you plead and defend an implied covenant claim in a NYC commercial case?


If you're bringing an implied covenant claim, plead it as a separate count, identify a specific benefit of the bargain you were deprived of, and tie the conduct to discretion the contract granted the other side. Don't repeat the same factual allegations from your breach count and slap a new label on them.


Under CPLR § 3013, your pleading must be sufficiently particular to give the court and the defendant notice of the transactions and occurrences you intend to prove. That means concrete allegations: which decision was made, who made it, when, what discretion the contract gave them, what benefit you lost, and what damages flowed from the loss. Vague allegations that the defendant "acted in bad faith" will not survive a motion to dismiss under CPLR § 3211(a)(7).


If you're defending, your first move is the motion to dismiss. Argue duplication — that the same conduct underlies the breach count and the implied covenant count. Argue that the express terms permit the conduct (courts will not use the covenant to override clear express terms, though after the Court of Appeals' 2026 decision discussed above, a grant of sole or absolute discretion alone does not defeat the claim). And argue that no specific benefit of the bargain was lost because the plaintiff cannot identify what the contract was supposed to deliver beyond what it actually delivered.


Damages on an implied covenant claim track standard contract damages: you can recover expectation damages (what you would have received had the covenant been observed), subject to the foreseeability and reasonable certainty rules that apply to any breach claim. We walk through those rules in our post on lost profits damages in New York breach of contract cases. Consequential damages waivers in the contract will generally apply to good-faith claims too, which is why drafters often layer them in. Specific performance is theoretically available where damages are inadequate (see our discussion of specific performance in New York commercial contracts), but it's rare in pure good-faith disputes.


One strategic note on venue. Most commercial cases involving the implied covenant land in the Commercial Division of New York Supreme Court. The judges there see these claims constantly and have a low tolerance for duplicative pleading. If your implied covenant count looks like a re-skinned breach count, expect it to come out fast. If it's distinct, well-pleaded, and tied to a specific exercise of discretion, it gives the court a reason to let the claim move forward. Fee-shifting is generally not available unless your contract provides for it; we cover that ground in our guide to recovering attorney's fees in New York breach of contract cases.


Finally, watch the statute of limitations. Implied covenant claims sound in contract and are generally subject to the six-year limitations period under CPLR § 213(2), but claims under contracts for the sale of goods, such as many distribution and requirements contracts, fall within the statute's exception for Article 2 of the Uniform Commercial Code, which sets its own shorter deadline. The clock starts when the breach of the covenant occurs, not when you discover it — so don't sit on these claims hoping the discovery rule will save you.


Frequently Asked Questions


Can I sue for breach of the implied covenant if my contract has a strong integration clause?

Yes. An integration clause says the written contract is the complete agreement and bars extrinsic evidence of prior or contemporaneous side deals — but it doesn't eliminate the implied covenant, which is read into every New York contract by operation of law. The covenant lives inside the contract, not outside it, so integration doesn't reach it.

Yes, but with limits. New York courts apply the covenant to at-will distribution, dealership, and similar commercial arrangements, but the covenant won't override an express right to terminate at will. What it can reach is the manner of termination — for example, terminating right before a commission is earned to avoid paying it, or using sham reasons to mask a discriminatory motive that violates a separate contractual obligation.

Generally six years from the date of the breach, under CPLR § 213(2), unless your contract is for the sale of goods, which falls within the statute's exception for Article 2 of the Uniform Commercial Code and its shorter deadline. The covenant is treated as part of the contract for limitations purposes, so the contract statute of limitations governs, not the shorter tort periods. Don't assume you have longer because the conduct sounds tortious.

Not automatically. Even where a contract grants sole discretion, New York courts require the exercise of that discretion to be non-arbitrary and not designed to deprive the other party of the fruits of the bargain. The clause raises the bar, but it doesn't eliminate the implied covenant entirely.


The Bottom Line


The implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing in New York is a powerful but narrow tool. It rewards plaintiffs who identify a specific benefit of the bargain lost through the bad-faith exercise of discretion, and it crushes plaintiffs who try to use it as a duplicative backstop for a routine breach claim. Drafting carefully, pleading precisely, and choosing the right forum are what give a good-faith claim the chance to be heard on its merits instead of being dismissed at the threshold. Where a counterparty used its contractual discretion to strip away the benefit of your bargain, see how Reza Yassi handles implied covenant claims in New York.


If you or your business is facing a commercial contract dispute involving good faith, discretion, or a breach of express terms, Reza Yassi at Yassi Law PC is ready to help. Call us today at 646-992-2138 for a consultation.




This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Although I am an attorney, I am not your attorney, and reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws vary by jurisdiction and may have changed since the publication of this article. For advice specific to your situation, consult a qualified attorney.

slider 4.jpg
Reza Yassi(author).png

Principal Attorney, Yassi Law P.C.
Reza Yassi is the principal attorney at Yassi Law P.C., representing clients in commercial litigation and personal injury matters. He is known for his aggressive yet tactical approach, combining strategic planning with clear client communication while serving individuals and businesses across New York and New Jersey.

bottom of page