top of page

What Is an Erb's Palsy Case Worth in New York? Myths About Brachial Plexus Birth Injury Value, Lost Earnings, and Infant Settlements

Writer: Reza Yassi
Reza Yassi
Nov 7
10 min read
What Is an Erb's Palsy Case Worth in New York? Myths About Brachial Plexus Birth Injury Value, Lost Earnings, and Infant Settlements

Many parents believe that an Erb's palsy case is worth either a fortune or nothing, depending only on whether the doctor admits a mistake. That isn't how New York law works. The value of a brachial plexus birth injury claim turns on how much your child's arm actually recovers, what treatment it took to get there, and what the injury will cost over a lifetime of school, work and daily living. A toddler who regains full strength and a teenager who still can't lift her arm after failed nerve grafts sit at opposite ends of the same legal scale.


Key takeaways


  • The value of an Erb's palsy claim depends mostly on how much permanent arm weakness your child has, not on the diagnosis alone.

  • A newborn can claim lost future earnings, but the claim must rest on realistic evidence about education and work.

  • Your child's malpractice claim generally must be filed within 10 years of birth, and your own medical-bill claim within 2.5 years.

  • Any settlement of a child's claim needs a judge's approval, and the money is usually held for the child.

  • Medicaid's repayment claim is generally limited to the medical-expense portion of a child's settlement, not money for pain and suffering or lost earnings.


Is Every Erb's Palsy Case Valued the Same Way?


No. New York courts value brachial plexus birth injuries along a wide spectrum, and the single biggest factor is how much permanent loss of function your child is left with.


The brachial plexus is the network of nerves that runs from the neck through the shoulder and into the arm and hand. Erb's palsy is the name for weakness or paralysis that happens when the upper nerves in that network are stretched or torn, often when a baby's shoulder gets caught during delivery. According to the Mayo Clinic, brachial plexus injuries range from mild stretches that heal on their own to severe tears that can require surgery. The National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke notes that many babies hurt during birth improve or recover in the first months of life, while others are left with lasting weakness. When nerves don't come back, surgeons may try nerve grafts or nerve transfers, and each step on that path becomes proof of how serious the injury really was.


What does the lower end of the range look like?


In Charles v. Day, 289 A.D.2d 190 (2d Dep't 2001), the Second Department, which hears appeals from Brooklyn, Queens and Long Island among other places, reduced the award to $50,000 for past and $250,000 for future pain and suffering. Pain and suffering is the money meant to compensate for physical pain, lost abilities and the emotional toll of an injury. The child's arm was slightly weaker and smaller, but the court stressed what he could still do: "Despite his injury, the plaintiff is able to participate in nearly all school gym class activities, and to perform normal daily tasks with little or no difficulty. Moreover, the plaintiff’s social relationships have not been affected by this condition."


The First Department, which hears appeals from the Bronx and Manhattan, reached a similar result in Delgado v. Murray, 115 A.D.3d 417 (1st Dep't 2014). The child had mild Erb's palsy with no appreciable difference in strength between his arms. The court cut a $600,000 future pain and suffering award to $300,000, finding that it "deviates materially from reasonable compensation." That phrase is the test New York appellate courts use: they compare an award to what courts have approved for similar injuries and trim anything far out of line.


What does the higher end look like?


At the other end sits Skelly-Hand v. Lizardi, 111 A.D.3d 1187 (3d Dep't 2013), involving a teenager with a severe brachial plexus injury from shoulder dystocia. She had been through five surgeries, developed related scoliosis (a sideways curve of the spine), and would always need help with self-care. The Third Department upheld awards of $1 million for past and $1 million for future pain and suffering, explaining that "her continuing need for assistance with basic activities of daily living such as bathing, grooming and dressing will restrict her future opportunities and permanently limit her independence."


The court also noted that earlier decisions count for less when they don't describe how severe the injury was. Courts compare cases by their details, so a record showing exactly what your child can and can't do carries more weight than a diagnosis code.


On the damages side, a strong case comes down to three things: a real injury, real treatment, and real effects on daily life, such as no longer being able to do the things your child needs to do or loves to do. Proof that the delivery team departed from accepted practice and caused the injury is a separate requirement, discussed below. For a child, those effects show up in ordinary moments, like not being able to hang from the monkey bars at a Queens playground or sitting out of Little League in Massapequa. Therapy notes, school records and video of daily struggles turn those moments into evidence. For more recent figures, see this review of Erb's palsy verdicts and settlements in New York.


Can a Baby With No Work History Claim Lost Earnings?


Yes. New York lets an injured child recover for lost earning capacity, which means the money the child would likely have earned over a working life minus what they can still earn with the injury. Because a newborn has no paycheck to point to, this part of an Erb's palsy case is built on expert proof and reasonable predictions.


Courts watch those predictions closely. In Reid v. County of Nassau, 215 A.D.2d 466 (2d Dep't 1995), the Second Department cut an infant's $1,000,000 lost future earnings award to $200,000 and his $2,000,000 future pain and suffering award to $300,000. It held that the earnings figure rested on a speculative assumption that the child would not attend college or be employable. As the court put it, "The evidence in this case would support an award for lost future earnings in the sum of $200,000."


Compare Delgado, where the First Department left a $380,000 future lost earnings award in place even though the injury was mild. The difference is proof. The intuitive argument, that a disabled arm means a lifetime without a job, is often the weakest version of the claim, because a defense economist can point to desk work the child could still do. A claim tied to the specific careers the injury closes off tends to hold up better.


Education is the hinge in most of these calculations. Data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics shows that median weekly earnings generally climb with higher levels of education, so experts often look at the family's own schooling and careers to estimate where a child was headed. A vocational expert then explains which jobs need two strong arms, such as construction trades, nursing or the FDNY, and an economist puts a present-day value on the gap. This article on proving lost earning capacity with vocational experts and economists explains how that testimony works.


Two rules shape how this money is awarded. Under CPLR 4111(d), a malpractice jury must itemize its verdict, listing amounts for elements such as medical expenses, loss of earnings, impairment of earning ability and pain and suffering, split into past and future. Under CPLR 5031, 35 percent of the present value of future economic damages is paid in a lump sum and the rest through an annuity. Future pain and suffering of $500,000 or less is paid in a lump sum; for larger awards, the greater of 35 percent or $500,000 is paid up front and the rest over the period the jury set or eight years, whichever is less.


Does a Stuck Shoulder During Delivery Automatically Mean Malpractice?


No. Shoulder dystocia, where the baby's head is delivered but a shoulder catches behind the mother's pelvic bone, is an emergency that can happen even when everyone does their job well. The legal question is how the delivery team responded.


Medical malpractice means a doctor, midwife or nurse departed from accepted medical practice and that departure caused the injury. In Delgado, the jury found malpractice based on excessive lateral traction, which means pulling the baby's head sideways too hard, and the First Department let that finding stand. Hospitals often answer that the mother's own contractions stretched the nerves. Whether that defense works depends on the delivery note, the nurses' records and the pattern of nerve damage on later testing, as this post on the maternal forces of labor defense in Brooklyn deliveries explains. At trial, liability and damages are separate questions, and a jury reaches damages only after finding malpractice that caused the injury. In settlement talks, though, the strength of the liability proof has a major effect on what a case is worth.


Do You Have Until Your Child Turns 18 to File a Lawsuit?


No. In a New York birth injury case, the child's claim generally has to be filed within 10 years of the delivery, and the parents' own claim has a much shorter deadline.


The starting rule is CPLR 214-a, which requires a medical malpractice action to be commenced within two years and six months of the act or omission, or of the last treatment where there is continuous treatment for the same condition. CPLR 208 gives extra time to someone under a disability because of infancy, meaning under 18. When the normal deadline is less than three years, it's extended by the period of the disability, but in a medical malpractice case the extension can't run beyond ten years after the claim accrues.


Parents also have their own claim, often called a derivative claim, for the child's medical expenses and loss of the child's services. That claim belongs to you, so the infancy extension doesn't help it. In Pang v. Maimonides Medical Center-Maimonides Hospital, 105 A.D.2d 775 (2d Dep't 1984), an infant malpractice case against a Brooklyn hospital, the statute of limitations had already run on the parent's claim.


  • Parents' claim for medical bills and loss of services: two years and six months under CPLR 214-a.

  • Child's own claim: extended for infancy, but no more than 10 years after the claim accrues under CPLR 208.

  • Claims involving a public hospital: separate notice rules with much shorter deadlines can apply before any lawsuit.


Waiting to see how much the arm recovers is understandable. But a lawsuit can be filed while recovery is still unfolding, and missing the parents' deadline can erase the claim for years of medical bills.


Does Settlement Money for Your Child Go Straight to You?


No. In New York, any settlement of a child's injury claim must be approved by a judge, and the money is usually held for the child rather than paid to the parents.


Under CPLR 1207, a parent with legal custody can ask the court to approve a settlement when there's no guardian. If no lawsuit was filed, the request is made through a special proceeding started by petition. The court's order has the effect of a judgment and must approve the fee for the child's attorney. This is called an infant compromise, which simply means a court-approved settlement of a minor's claim.


CPLR 1208 spells out what the judge must see. The parent's affidavit (a sworn written statement) has to cover, among other things:


  • the circumstances of the claim and the nature and extent of the child's injuries;

  • each treating doctor, the medical expenses and the child's present physical condition;

  • the terms and proposed distribution of the settlement;

  • whether expenses were reimbursed from any source and whether any family member made a claim from the same event.


The lawyer must file an affidavit explaining why the settlement is recommended, and medical or hospital reports must be included. The parent, the child and the lawyer must appear before the judge unless excused for good cause. Judges commonly direct the money into a restricted account or a structured annuity the child can't reach until 18, so it's worth understanding how structured settlements work in New York birth injury cases before you sign. Fees are capped by Judiciary Law § 474-a on a sliding scale that starts at 30 percent of the first $250,000 and drops to 10 percent of anything over $1,250,000.


How do Medicaid liens reach an infant settlement?


If New York State Medicaid, administered by the Department of Health, paid for your delivery or your child's care, it can seek repayment, but generally only from the part of the settlement that compensates for medical expenses, not from money for pain and suffering or lost earnings. In Pang, the Second Department refused to cancel a social services lien but held that it reached only the portion compensating for medical expenses the agency paid. Because "the record is unclear as to what portion, if any, of the settlement of the infant’s claim represented compensation for past medical expenses which were paid by the DSS," the court ordered a hearing.


That makes the allocation in the settlement papers a real money issue, since it controls how much a lien can take from funds meant for your child's future. At trial, CPLR 4545 lets a court reduce an award for costs covered by collateral sources like health insurance, but it excludes payments that carry a statutory right of reimbursement. This guide to Medicaid and Medicare liens in catastrophic injury settlements explains the payback process.


Frequently Asked Questions


There is no fixed timeline, and these cases often take years to resolve. Part of the reason is medical, because the value depends on how permanent the injury is, which may not be clear until the child is older. The 10-year outer limit for a child's malpractice claim under CPLR 208 means waiting has limits.

Under CPLR 1208, the parent, the child and the attorney must appear before the judge at the settlement hearing unless the court excuses attendance for good cause. The appearance lets the judge see the child's condition firsthand before approving the terms.

Possibly, but the value is usually lower when a child regains most function. In Charles v. Day, an appeals court reduced the award to $50,000 for past and $250,000 for future pain and suffering because the child could do nearly all gym and daily activities. Any remaining weakness or size difference should be documented by specialists.

Most medical malpractice cases are handled on a contingent fee, meaning the lawyer is paid from a recovery, and Judiciary Law 474-a caps that fee on a sliding scale starting at 30 percent of the first $250,000. For a child's claim, the judge who approves the settlement must also approve the attorney's fee under CPLR 1207.



An Erb's palsy case in New York is valued by what the injury takes from your child over a lifetime, measured through medical proof, realistic earnings evidence and comparison to similar cases. Deadlines, court approval and Medicaid liens all shape what your child ultimately keeps, so understanding them early matters.


If you or someone you know has a child with Erb's palsy or another brachial plexus injury from a difficult delivery, Reza Yassi at Yassi Law PC is ready to help. Call us today at 646-992-2138 for a consultation.




Written by Reza Yassi | LinkedIn


Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.


This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Although I am an attorney, I am not your attorney, and reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws vary by jurisdiction and may have changed since the publication of this article. For advice specific to your situation, consult a qualified attorney.


slider 4.jpg
Reza Yassi(author).png

Principal Attorney, Yassi Law P.C.
Reza Yassi is the principal attorney at Yassi Law P.C., representing clients in commercial litigation and personal injury matters. He is known for his aggressive yet tactical approach, combining strategic planning with clear client communication while serving individuals and businesses across New York and New Jersey.

bottom of page