top of page

Account Stated Claims in New York: Myths NYC Vendors Believe About Collecting on Unpaid Invoices Without a Signed Contract

Writer: Reza Yassi
Reza Yassi
Nov 2
9 min read

Updated: Nov 6

Account Stated Claims in New York: Myths NYC Vendors Believe About Collecting on Unpaid Invoices Without a Signed Contract

Many NYC business owners believe that if they never got a signed master agreement, they can't sue a customer who stopped paying their invoices. That belief is wrong, and it costs vendors millions in unrecovered receivables every year. New York recognizes an "account stated" claim as a separate cause of action, and the First and Second Departments regularly grant summary judgment on account stated cases involving six- and seven-figure unpaid balances. If your customer received your invoices in the ordinary course of business, made some payments, and never objected in writing, you may already have a winning claim — even without a single signed contract in your file.


Key takeaways


  • Account stated lets a vendor sue for unpaid invoices in New York without a signed master contract.

  • You must show invoices sent in the ordinary course, delivery, and no timely objection by the customer.

  • Partial payment or a written promise to pay generally proves receipt and strengthens the claim.

  • Silence alone isn't enough; the surrounding business relationship must make objection expected.

  • The six-year statute of limitations generally runs from when the account was stated — typically the date of the last invoice or last payment — so acting quickly matters.


Do You Really Need a Signed Contract to Sue for Unpaid Invoices in New York?


No. An account stated claim lets you sue on the invoices themselves, without a signed master agreement, so long as you can show the invoices were sent, received, and left unchallenged. That rule is well-settled in New York, and recent First Department decisions have reaffirmed it in disputes over freight bills, supply contracts, and professional service engagements.


The elements are straightforward. You prepared and sent invoices to the customer in the ordinary course of your business, the customer received them, and the customer either paid part of the balance or sat on the invoices without a specific written objection. That's it. In Dape Consulting Inc. v. Next Trucking Inc., 2025 NY Slip Op 02128 (1st Dep't 2025), the First Department reversed a trial court and entered summary judgment for a freight vendor on exactly those facts: invoices sent in the ordinary course, partial payment that confirmed receipt, and no timely objection from the customer.


Oral and handshake deals are fine. In Stardom Brands, LLC v. S.K.I. Wholesale Beer Corp., 2019 NY Slip Op 4018 (2d Dep't 2019), the Second Department partly reversed a trial judgment for the buyer and awarded a beer importer judgment on one invoice against a buyer that had only an oral purchase arrangement. The buyer later said at trial that the shipment didn't match its order, but because it never raised that objection before the lawsuit began, the court treated the invoice as settled. The lesson is simple: once an invoice has sat in the customer's inbox for weeks without protest, the courthouse is a bad place to raise the issue for the first time.


The statute of limitations is six years under CPLR § 213(2), and it generally begins to run when the account is stated — typically the date of the last invoice or, if later, the date of the last partial payment on the account, though the exact accrual date can depend on the specific facts. Contracts drafted with AI tools can create disputes of their own. AI can produce a polished generic contract, but if you don't know what you need it to say, it may leave out the terms that protect you, and that gap has become a real source of litigation. When the written contract turns out to be useless or ambiguous, the account stated claim often becomes the vendor's cleanest path to a judgment.


Does a Customer's Silence Automatically Prove They Agreed to the Invoice?


Not quite. New York courts have never held that silence alone equals assent. In Townhouse Off. Park Assoc., Inc. v. Townehouse Off. Park of Nanuet Condominium, 2025 NY Slip Op 04929 (2d Dep't 2025), the Second Department reminded practitioners that "mere silence and failure to object to an account stated cannot be construed as an agreement to the correctness of the account," though in the right circumstances an implied account stated may still be found when objection is not made within a reasonable time.


What makes the difference is the surrounding commercial relationship. If you've billed a Midtown customer monthly for two years, they paid the first 18 invoices, and then they went quiet while continuing to accept services, their silence against that backdrop looks like assent. If you're sending a one-off bill to a stranger who never responded, the same silence looks like nothing. Judges want to see context — a continuing business relationship, consistent billing practices, and some acknowledgment from the other side.


Partial payment is the single strongest piece of context. It proves the customer received the invoices and it strongly suggests they examined them, because customers rarely pay bills they haven't looked at. The Dape Consulting court relied heavily on partial payment as proof of receipt. Written acknowledgments carry the same weight. An email that says "I know we owe you, we're working on cash flow" is often worth more at summary judgment than three signed contracts, because it comes from the customer's own hand and admits the debt without reservation.


Can Your Customer Defeat the Claim by Claiming They "Objected" Verbally?


Usually not. Vague oral objections almost never defeat an account stated claim at summary judgment, and after-the-fact affidavits that don't identify specific invoices or specific problems don't either. New York judges have seen too many of these and discount them accordingly.


In Wing Hon Precision Industry Ltd. v. Diamond Quasar Jewelry, Inc., 154 A.D.3d 550 (1st Dep't 2017), a jewelry supplier sued over unpaid invoices, including 33 invoices carrying an unpaid balance of roughly $245,000 plus three invoices for cufflinks. The customer claimed it had objected orally to the shipments, but the First Department granted the supplier summary judgment on 33 of those invoices. For three invoices covering defective cufflinks, the customer produced an email documenting a specific written objection, and the court let that narrow dispute go to trial. The pattern is clear: a specific written objection to a specific invoice can defeat account stated for that invoice, but a general oral grievance about "the quality of the stuff" doesn't move the needle.


Even clearer is what happens when the customer's affidavit conflicts with its own emails. In Perine International Inc. v. Bedford Clothiers, Inc., 143 A.D.3d 491 (1st Dep't 2016), the First Department granted a textile seller summary judgment because the buyer's opposition affidavits "failed to specify any objections made to any of the invoices" and were "not credible as a matter of law" because they conflicted with contemporaneous emails promising to pay the full amount billed. If your customer has emailed you promising payment at any point in the dispute, keep that email. It's often the piece of evidence that ends the case.


One strategic point commercial vendors frequently overlook: an account stated claim does not require you to prove the goods or services were actually delivered, conforming, or worth what you charged. The underlying debt is treated as settled by the account itself. That's why a defendant who wants to dispute delivery, defective work, or overcharging has to do it in a specific, timely, written objection before suit — not for the first time in a litigation affidavit a year later.


Should You Wait for a Customer Who Keeps Promising to Pay?


No, and this is one of the biggest mistakes commercial vendors make. Vendors and contractors get strung along by promises to pay, to come back and fix the work, or to deliver the materials. Those promises rarely come true, and the delay gives the other side time to move assets out of the company or out of their own name before a lawsuit begins.


Three concrete harms come from waiting. The first is the statute of limitations. Six years sounds like forever until you realize that in a long-running account relationship, the earliest invoices start aging out quickly, and if your receivable is spread across invoices stretching back several years, pieces of your claim may already be dead. The second is proof. Witnesses leave, inboxes get wiped, bookkeepers retire. A clean record today becomes a messy record in year four, and the burden of proving receipt and non-objection sits on you. The third harm, and the one that costs the most money, is collectability. By the time a dilatory customer finally refuses to pay, the operating company may be out of cash and the principals may have moved personal assets into trusts, their spouses' names, or newly formed entities.


New York gives you real tools against that scenario if you act in time. CPLR § 6201 allows prejudgment attachment when a defendant has assigned, disposed of, or secreted property with intent to defraud creditors, and attachment orders can lock down bank accounts, receivables, and real estate before a judgment is ever entered. Summary judgment under CPLR § 3212 is another tool: on an account stated claim with clean invoice and payment records, it can produce a judgment without a trial. The customer who's been promising to pay for a year often changes their tune the week after they're served with a motion.


Is an Account Stated Claim the Same as a Breach of Contract Claim?


No. They're independent causes of action with different elements, different proofs, and different strategic uses. In most invoice-collection cases, you'll plead both in the alternative, but the two don't rise or fall together.


A breach of contract claim depends on proving the terms of the deal, the vendor's performance, and the customer's failure to perform. That means putting the contract — written, oral, or implied by conduct — into the record and explaining it, and proving the delivered goods or services conformed to it. If the facts around material breach are complicated, the customer gets room to argue. An account stated claim bypasses most of that: once the invoice is received and not objected to in time, the balance is treated as agreed.


Why plead both? Because they protect different flanks. If the customer manages to produce a specific written objection to one invoice (as happened on the three cufflink invoices in Wing Hon), you still have the breach of contract theory to try on that piece. And if you want to recover lost profits or other consequential damages beyond the invoice amount, you need the contract claim. Account stated recovers only the unpaid invoice balance; it does not reach downstream losses.


Prejudgment interest on both theories is available under CPLR § 5001, calculated at New York's statutory rate under CPLR § 5004: 9% a year, or 2% in a consumer-debt case against an individual; our post on prejudgment interest walks through how courts calculate it. Attorney's fees are harder: the American Rule applies, and absent a contract clause or statute, you pay your own lawyer whether you win or lose. Our guide to recovering attorney's fees walks through the narrow exceptions that may apply even when your invoices don't include a fee-shift provision.


One tactical warning: don't let the customer drag the fight into a swearing match over oral side terms. New York's parol evidence rule can keep competing oral stories out of evidence when there's a written agreement, and an account stated claim similarly focuses the dispute on the four corners of the invoice and the response (or lack of one). Courts prefer that cleanliness, and so should you.


Frequently Asked Questions


How long do I have to sue on unpaid invoices in New York?

Six years from when the account was stated — generally the date of the last invoice or the date of the last partial payment on the account, whichever is later, though the exact accrual date can be fact-specific. CPLR § 213(2) governs. If your receivable is spread across invoices stretching back several years, parts of the oldest invoices may already be time-barred, so talk to a lawyer promptly rather than letting the clock run.

Can I add finance charges or late fees to my account stated claim?

Only if your invoices clearly stated those charges and the customer didn't object to them while paying earlier invoices. If your invoices showed "1.5% monthly service charge on past-due balances" for years and the customer paid them without protest, you have a strong argument that the finance charges are part of the account stated. If the late fees first appear only after the dispute began, courts are much more skeptical.

What if my customer disputes some invoices but not others?

You can still win on the undisputed invoices. The First Department's decision in Wing Hon Precision is the textbook example: the supplier recovered on 33 unobjected-to invoices even though three invoices for defective goods had to go to trial. Don't let a customer freeze your entire receivable by picking a fight over one disputed shipment.

Do I have to attach the invoices to my complaint?

Not strictly, but you should. New York judges deciding summary judgment motions want to see the actual invoices, the customer's partial-payment history, and the correspondence showing receipt without objection. A complaint that just alleges "a balance due" with no exhibits invites a motion to dismiss and signals a weak file to the judge from day one.


Conclusion


If your NYC business is owed six or seven figures on invoices and you never got a signed master contract, account stated is often the fastest and cleanest route to a judgment in New York. The claim rewards vendors who kept clean records and move promptly, and it punishes customers who tried to delay a reckoning by staying quiet. Waiting almost never helps; it is how winning cases turn into uncollectable judgments. Our New York debt collection and judgment enforcement practice covers both halves of that problem: getting the judgment and collecting it.


If you or your business is chasing a significant unpaid receivable from a commercial customer who never signed a formal contract, Reza Yassi at Yassi Law PC is ready to help. Call us today at 646-992-2138 for a consultation.



Written by Reza Yassi


Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.


This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Although I am an attorney, I am not your attorney, and reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws vary by jurisdiction and may have changed since the publication of this article. For advice specific to your situation, consult a qualified attorney.


slider 4.jpg
Reza Yassi(author).png

Principal Attorney, Yassi Law P.C.
Reza Yassi is the principal attorney at Yassi Law P.C., representing clients in commercial litigation and personal injury matters. He is known for his aggressive yet tactical approach, combining strategic planning with clear client communication while serving individuals and businesses across New York and New Jersey.

bottom of page