Sold Your LLC Stake to Your Co-Member Before He Flipped It? Pappas v. Tzolis and When an LLC Buyout Release Can Be Challenged in New York


Many minority members assume that if a co-member buys them out while quietly lining up a much bigger sale, the law will undo the deal because he owed them a fiduciary duty. In New York, that belief is often wrong. If your relationship had already turned adversarial and you signed an LLC buyout release or a “big boy” certificate, the Court of Appeals has held that you generally can't claim you relied on what your co-member said or didn't say. That doesn't make every buyout untouchable. It means the paperwork you sign on the way out matters more than the duties you assume will protect you.
Key takeaways
A signed release and non-reliance certificate can bar fraud and fiduciary duty claims after you sell your LLC interest.
Courts look closely at whether your relationship with the buyer had already turned hostile before the sale.
Before selling, demand written disclosure representations, a pending-offers warranty, and a clawback if the company is resold soon.
A release can usually be attacked only on narrow grounds, such as a separate fraud that induced the release itself.
Use your right to inspect company records before you sign, not after you learn about the flip.
Doesn't my co-member's fiduciary duty mean he had to tell me about a pending buyer?
Not always. Once the relationship has turned adversarial and you've signed a document disclaiming reliance on him, New York courts generally won't let you sue over what he kept quiet. The fiduciary duty is real, but it isn't unlimited, and the circumstances of the sale can shape what it requires.
Members and managers of a New York LLC typically owe duties of loyalty and care. The statute itself requires a manager to act in good faith and with the care an ordinarily prudent person in a like position would use under similar circumstances, under LLCL § 409. In a trusting relationship, a fiduciary who buys out someone he owes duties to is expected to disclose material facts. That's the rule most sellers have in mind when they first hear their old partner sold the company for many times what he paid them. For a broader look at these duties, see our overview of fiduciary duty claims against LLC managers.
The leading case cuts the other way. In Pappas v. Tzolis, 20 N.Y.3d 228 (2012), three members formed an LLC to hold a long-term lease on a Manhattan building. Disputes broke out over how one member, Tzolis, was running the business. The other two eventually sold him their interests for $1 million and $500,000, respectively. As part of the sale, they signed a certificate stating that they had performed their own due diligence, had been represented by their own lawyers, and that Tzolis owed them no fiduciary duty in connection with the transaction. The LLC, now controlled by Tzolis, later assigned the lease to a developer for $17.5 million. The sellers sued, claiming he'd been negotiating that deal behind their backs.
The Court of Appeals dismissed their fraud and fiduciary duty claims. It reasoned that the sellers were sophisticated businessmen represented by counsel, that their relationship with Tzolis was no longer one of trust, and that under those circumstances they couldn't reasonably rely on him as a fiduciary to volunteer what he knew. The certificate confirmed that both sides understood they were dealing at arm's length.
Why your own complaints can be used against you
The adversity the court relied on came from the sellers' own account of their fights with Tzolis. That has a consequence few sellers see coming. Your angry emails, your lawyer's demand letter, your accusation that your partner is self-dealing: all of it can later be offered as proof that you didn't trust him, and therefore couldn't have relied on him when you sold.
The warning signs that usually come before a buyout are the same facts a court may read as the end of trust. You're shut out of decisions, you can't get the books and records, communication stops, the expenses don't add up, or important promises were only ever made verbally. When those signs appear, treat the person across the table as a counterparty, not a partner. If you're already being pushed aside, our guide to fighting a minority LLC member freeze-out covers options that don't require selling at all.
Can't I always sue for fraud, since fraud undoes any deal?
No. If your release covers the fraud you're complaining about, New York courts will usually enforce the release and dismiss the claim. “Fraud vitiates everything” is a slogan, not the rule for sophisticated parties who signed a release.
The controlling framework comes from Centro Empresarial Cempresa S.A. v. América Móvil, S.A.B. de C.V., 17 N.Y.3d 269 (2011), a decision the Pappas court relied on. There, minority investors sold their stakes, signed a broad general release, and then sued, claiming they'd been deceived about the value of what they sold. The Court of Appeals held that a party who releases fraud claims can challenge the release as fraudulently induced only by identifying a fraud separate from the subject of the release. It also recognized that a sophisticated principal can release a fiduciary from claims, at least where the fiduciary relationship is no longer one of unquestioning trust.
Apply that to a typical flip. Your theory is that your co-member hid a pending buyer so he could buy you out cheaply. But the release you signed covered all claims arising from your membership and the sale, known or unknown. The hidden buyer is the very subject the release addressed, so it isn't a separate fraud. To get past the release, you'd need to point to a distinct lie that induced you to sign the release itself.
Why releases tend to end cases early
A release is one of the grounds listed in CPLR 3211(a)(5) for dismissing a claim at the outset, and a signed release is also the kind of paper that can support dismissal under CPLR 3211(a)(1) as a defense founded on documentary evidence. Timing is the real problem. A defendant can move to dismiss before any discovery happens, so you may have to plead a separate fraud in detail without ever seeing the emails that would prove it. New York already requires fraud to be pleaded with particularity, which means whatever you know about the hidden deal before filing has to be specific enough to survive on paper alone.
Isn't a “big boy” letter just boilerplate a court will ignore?
No. Between sophisticated parties represented by counsel, New York courts regularly enforce big boy letters and non-reliance certificates as written. The name reflects the idea that both sides are grown-ups who did their own homework and won't later claim they were misled.
A typical big boy provision says you're a sophisticated party, you've had access to the information you wanted, you've done your own due diligence, you've relied on your own advisers, and you aren't relying on any statement by the buyer except those written into the agreement. Some go further, as in Pappas, and state that the buyer owes you no fiduciary duty in connection with the sale. Each of those sentences closes a door you may later want open.
New York law has long distinguished a general merger clause from a specific disclaimer. A vague statement that the contract is the entire agreement may not defeat a fraud claim. A specific statement that you didn't rely on representations about the very matter you're now suing over usually will. The more precisely the certificate targets value, prospects, and third-party interest in the company, the harder it is to escape.
Your operating agreement's protections don't follow you out the door
Many members take comfort in LLCL § 417, which allows an operating agreement to limit a manager's personal liability but bars it from eliminating liability where a final adjudication establishes bad faith, intentional misconduct, a knowing violation of law, or that the manager personally gained a financial profit or other advantage he wasn't legally entitled to. That limit governs exculpation clauses in operating agreements. Don't assume it overrides a release you negotiate and sign when you exit. A buyout release is a separate, bargained-for contract, and courts analyze it under the Centro and Pappas framework.
Does signing an LLC buyout release end every possible claim?
No, but the paths around a release are narrow and fact-specific. Courts don't reopen buyouts because a seller regrets the price. They do it when something about the release, the relationship, or the deal documents gives a legal reason to.
A separate fraud: a lie that induced you to sign the release itself, distinct from the matters the release covered.
A relationship of genuine trust: Pappas turned on adversity and sophistication, so a passive investor who relied entirely on a manager, with no dispute pending, may stand differently.
Breach of the buyout agreement's own promises: a false written representation in the purchase agreement can support a contract claim if the release doesn't cover it.
Claims outside the release's scope: some releases reach only claims existing as of a certain date or arising from specific matters, so the exact wording controls.
Each of these is a contested fight. The trust argument depends on facts a defendant will dispute, such as whether you had a lawyer, whether you asked for documents, and whether you'd been feuding before the sale.
Watch the clock
Fraud claims carry their own limitations period. Under CPLR 213(8), an action based on fraud must be commenced within the greater of six years from when the claim accrued or two years from when you discovered the fraud or could have discovered it with reasonable diligence. When a breach of fiduciary duty claim is essentially a fraud claim, New York courts generally apply the same six-year period. Six years sounds generous. But if you ever need the discovery rule to extend it, the two years run from when you could have found the fraud, and a lease assignment or property sale in Manhattan or Nassau County often leaves a public record that a court may say you should have checked.
Can't I protect myself before signing just by asking the right questions?
Asking helps, but answers given in conversation won't protect you if you then sign a release and a non-reliance certificate. What protects you is getting those answers written into the purchase agreement as representations that survive the closing.
Most partnerships start between friends or trusted colleagues, and that trust is exactly what backfires when things go wrong. Trust, but verify, and put everything in writing, even with people you know well. In a buyout, that means converting every reassurance into contract language. Terms worth demanding include the following.
A disclosure representation: the buyer represents that he has disclosed all material facts about the company's value, assets, and prospects.
A pending-offers warranty: no offers, letters of intent, or negotiations for the company or its key assets exist or occurred within a defined look-back period.
A clawback or tail: if the company or a major asset is sold within, for example, 12 to 24 months, you receive a share of the price above your buyout valuation.
A release carve-out: the release excludes claims for breach of the buyout agreement itself, with a survival period long enough to matter.
An earn-out is a different tool. Rather than protecting you against a hidden flip, it pays you more if the business hits revenue or profit milestones after you leave. Either can bridge a gap over price, but a clawback triggered by any sale is the cleaner answer to the Pappas problem.
Use your inspection rights first
Before you negotiate price, use your statutory access to information. Under LLCL § 1102, any member may inspect and copy, at his or her own expense and for any purpose reasonably related to the member's interest as a member, the company's required records, its financial statements for the three most recent fiscal years, and other information about its affairs as is just and reasonable. Valuing your own stake is plainly related to that interest. Our post on forcing disclosure under LLCL § 1102 explains how that demand works when a managing member stalls.
If you can't get information and can't agree on a fair price, taking whatever you're offered isn't your only choice. A member can ask the Supreme Court to dissolve the company under LLCL § 702 when it isn't reasonably practicable to carry on the business in conformity with the articles of organization or operating agreement. The “not reasonably practicable” standard is demanding, but a pending petition changes the negotiating dynamic. For how judges price a stake, see our guide to LLC buyout valuation in New York, and for a side-by-side comparison of exits, read about choosing between dissolution, a court-ordered buyout, and a derivative suit.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Pappas v. Tzolis still apply if I didn't have a lawyer when I sold?
The Court of Appeals emphasized that the sellers were sophisticated businessmen represented by counsel, so the absence of a lawyer can help your argument. It isn't decisive on its own, particularly if you're a seasoned businessperson. Courts look at the whole relationship, including whether you'd been in a dispute before the sale.
How long do I have to sue if I think I was defrauded in a buyout?
Under CPLR 213(8), a fraud claim must be brought within the greater of six years from accrual or two years from when you discovered, or reasonably could have discovered, the fraud. Fiduciary duty claims that are essentially fraud claims are generally treated the same way. Don't wait, because the release defense will be raised immediately no matter when you file.
Can I undo the sale, or can I only get money?
A defrauded party in New York can generally seek either rescission, which unwinds the deal, or damages. Rescission usually requires acting promptly once you learn of the fraud and being prepared to return what you received. Either remedy still requires getting past the release first.
Does this rule apply only to LLCs?
No. Centro, the case Pappas built on, involved minority investors who sold their stakes in a corporate enterprise. The principle that sophisticated parties can release a fiduciary once trust has broken down applies across business forms, including partnerships and closely held corporations.
An LLC buyout release signed in the middle of a dispute is one of the hardest documents in New York business law to undo. Pappas v. Tzolis makes the moment before you sign the one that counts: get the records, get the representations in writing, and build in a clawback. If you've already signed, a narrow path may still exist, but it turns on the exact language and the history of your relationship.
If you or your business sold an LLC interest to a co-member and later learned about a deal you were never told about, Reza Yassi at Yassi Law PC is ready to help. Call us today at 646-992-2138 for a consultation.
Written by Reza Yassi | LinkedIn
Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Although I am an attorney, I am not your attorney, and reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws vary by jurisdiction and may have changed since the publication of this article. For advice specific to your situation, consult a qualified attorney.


.png)