top of page

Locked Out of Your NYC Storefront? When a Commercial Landlord Lockout Is Lawful and When RPAPL § 853 Treble Damages Apply

Writer: Reza Yassi
Reza Yassi
2 days ago
11 min read
Locked Out of Your NYC Storefront? When a Commercial Landlord Lockout Is Lawful and When RPAPL § 853 Treble Damages Apply

In Nolan v. Edison Prop. Investing, LLC, 2026 NY Slip Op 03175 (2d Dep't 2026), a restaurant tenant found its locks changed and sued the landlord for wrongful eviction and breach of contract. The Appellate Division, Second Department, upheld dismissal of both claims. The lease reserved a right to peaceably re-enter on a rent default, the tenant was behind, the landlord had demanded the rent, and the lock change happened without incident. If you run a business anywhere from Astoria to Hauppauge, that ruling matters because a commercial landlord lockout can be entirely legal in New York. When the landlord skips a step, though, the same lockout becomes an unlawful entry, and the tenant may be able to get back in and seek treble damages under RPAPL § 853.


Key takeaways


  • A New York commercial landlord can lock you out without a court order only if the lease expressly reserves a right of re-entry.

  • The landlord must also show you defaulted, any required demand went unanswered, and the re-entry was peaceful.

  • Unpaid rent alone doesn't justify changing the locks when the lease lacks a valid re-entry clause.

  • Treble damages for an unlawful lockout aren't automatic, so document every lost item and dollar right away.

  • In the five boroughs, the City's commercial tenant harassment law adds another layer of risk for landlords.


What happened in Nolan v. Edison Property Investing, and why did the landlord win?


The landlord won because it put proof before the court on every element of a lawful self-help re-entry, and the tenant had nothing to contradict it. The landlord moved for summary judgment, which is a request to decide the case on the papers because there's no genuine factual dispute that needs a trial. Its motion started with the lease itself, which reserved the right to peaceably re-enter if the tenant defaulted on rent.


The landlord also submitted evidence that the restaurant was in arrears, that the landlord had demanded the overdue rent, that the demand was still unpaid when the locks were changed, and that the re-entry happened peacefully. Once a landlord makes that showing, the burden shifts. The tenant has to come forward with admissible evidence, not argument, that raises a real question about one of those facts. The Second Department concluded the tenant didn't do that, so its wrongful eviction and contract claims stayed dismissed.


Nolan is a recent slip opinion, so its text may still be edited before it appears in the official reports. Its reasoning, though, tracks a long line of New York cases. In Jovana Spaghetti House, Inc. v. Heritage Co. of Massena, 189 A.D.2d 1041 (3d Dep't 1993), the Third Department affirmed the dismissal of a restaurant tenant's petition to be restored to possession. The lease allowed re-entry after notice for unpaid percentage rent and additional rent, the tenant admitted the default, and the landlord's manager padlocked the empty premises without force or threats. The tenant's opposition rested on an attorney's affidavit, which carries little weight on facts the lawyer doesn't personally know.


The lesson for tenants is blunt. If you believe a lockout was improper, your proof has to come from people with firsthand knowledge: the owner who paid the rent, the manager who was on site that night, the bookkeeper who keeps the ledger. A lawyer's summary of what happened won't create a fact question, and a case that could have been won on the facts can be lost on the paperwork.


When is a commercial landlord lockout lawful in New York, and when does it cross the line?


A commercial landlord lockout is lawful in New York only when the lease expressly allows re-entry, the condition that triggers re-entry has actually occurred, and the landlord retakes the space peacefully. Reading Nolan, Jovana and the related appellate decisions together, a landlord defending a lockout generally has to prove four things:


  • The lease contains a specific provision reserving the landlord's right to re-enter on the tenant's default.

  • The tenant actually defaulted on the obligation whose breach triggers re-entry under the lease, such as failing to pay rent.

  • Any demand, notice or cure period the lease requires was given and expired without a cure.

  • The landlord retook possession peaceably, without force or threats.


Fail any one of those, and the re-entry becomes vulnerable as a forcible or unlawful entry.


The re-entry right has to be express


The first element trips up more landlords than you might expect. In 1414 Holdings, LLC v. BMS-PSO, LLC, 116 A.D.3d 641 (1st Dep't 2014), a Manhattan office landlord argued that its lease let it use self-help. The First Department disagreed, holding that "the parties’ lease does not contain any specific provision allowing the owner to use self-help to evict the tenant," and that the article the landlord relied on "is not an express reservation of the right to re-enter." The tenant got a declaration that the landlord couldn't evict it without a court order, and it kept its preliminary injunction, which the court modified only to allow limited elevator work.


The Third Department stated the governing rule in Jovana: "If a lease makes specific provision therefor, a lessor may re-enter premises upon breach of a condition subsequent so long as it is done peaceably and without force, and need not resort to an action or proceeding to regain possession." Every phrase in that sentence does work. A general default article, or a remedies section that talks only about terminating the lease, may not qualify as a specific provision. Before anyone touches a lock, the exact lease language has to be read against that standard.


Peaceable means peaceable


In practice, a peaceful re-entry usually means a locksmith changing the cylinder while the space is closed and empty. A landlord who pushes past employees, argues with a manager at the door, or shows up with extra muscle at a busy Flushing storefront is creating the very facts a tenant needs to call the entry forcible. If the tenant's people are inside and refuse to leave, the safer course for a landlord is to walk away and go to court.


The clause's condition has to be met first


Patton v. Modern Asian, Inc., 208 A.D.3d 1491 (3d Dep't 2022), shows the timing problem. The landlord changed a restaurant's locks on the theory that the tenant had abandoned the space, which was the condition its re-entry clause turned on. The evidence didn't establish abandonment. The Third Department held that "even though the lease contains a reentry clause, plaintiffs did not follow the conditions set forth in this clause and were not permitted to engage in reentry of the premises." The result was concrete: the landlord couldn't recover rent for the period after the lockout.


That matters to any landlord looking at a dark storefront on Jamaica Avenue and assuming the tenant is gone. A closed door isn't the same thing as abandonment. A tenant that still has its equipment and inventory inside, keeps the utilities on, or keeps writing to the landlord about reopening has a real argument that it never gave up the space.


Unpaid rent alone isn't a license to change the locks


In Moran v. Orth, 36 A.D.3d 771 (2d Dep't 2007), the tenant hadn't paid rent and the landlord deliberately locked the tenant out. The Second Department's response was direct: "Although Moran failed to pay rent, Orth was not entitled deliberately to resort to self-help." The tenant stayed locked out for more than three months, until a judge ordered the keys returned, and the landlord threw out the tenant's property in the meantime.


Compare that with a court-ordered eviction. Under RPAPL § 749, after a judgment the court issues a warrant to a sheriff, marshal or constable, who must give at least fourteen days' written notice and execute the warrant on a business day between sunrise and sunset. The court can stay or vacate the warrant for good cause, and in a nonpayment case it must vacate the warrant if the tenant tenders the full rent due before execution, unless the landlord shows the rent was withheld in bad faith. Self-help skips every one of those protections, which is why courts hold landlords who use it to the exact terms of their leases.


One more limit applies when a space isn't purely commercial. RPAPL § 711 states that no tenant or lawful occupant of a dwelling or housing accommodation shall be removed from possession except in a special proceeding. If someone lives in the space, such as a live-work loft in Bushwick or an apartment behind a Bronx storefront, nobody should assume the commercial self-help rules apply.


How do you get back into your space and recover treble damages under RPAPL § 853?


You have three main tools: an emergency injunction, a summary proceeding to be restored to possession, and a lawsuit for damages that can include treble damages under RPAPL § 853. Which one fits depends on whether you want the space back, how fast you need it, and what you've already lost.


Restoration to possession under RPAPL § 713(10)


RPAPL § 713 lets a party bring a summary proceeding, the fast-track case New York uses for possession disputes, on grounds that don't depend on a landlord-tenant relationship. Subdivision 10 covers the situation where the person in possession "has entered the property or remains in possession by force or unlawful means," as long as that person, or a predecessor in interest, was not in quiet possession for three years before the forcible entry. A locked-out tenant can use it to ask the court to put the tenant back in. These proceedings are usually heard in the Civil Court in New York City and in local district, city, town or village courts in Nassau and Suffolk.


Jovana shows the other side of this tool. Because the landlord there had a valid re-entry clause, an admitted rent default and a peaceful padlocking of empty premises, the tenant's petition was dismissed. A restoration proceeding is only as strong as your proof that the re-entry broke one of the rules.


Emergency injunctive relief


If you're in a busy season, holding perishable inventory, or facing a landlord who's threatening a lockout or a utility shutoff, a motion for a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction in Supreme Court can move quickly. 1414 Holdings shows that tenants can obtain this kind of protection when the lease doesn't support self-help. If the landlord has served a notice to cure instead of changing the locks, the right move is often a Yellowstone injunction filed before the cure period runs out, because a court generally can't revive a lease that has already been terminated.


Treble damages under RPAPL § 853


Section 853 provides that if a person is "disseized, ejected, or put out of real property in a forcible or unlawful manner," or is kept out by force, threats of personal violence or "unlawful means," that person "is entitled to recover treble damages in an action therefor against the wrong-doer." Treble damages means the court multiplies your proven damages by three. On paper, $150,000 in proven losses becomes $450,000.


Two cases mark the limits. In Moran, the trial court refused to treble, and the Second Department held that refusal was an improvident exercise of discretion because the lockout was deliberate, lasted more than three months, and ended with the tenant's belongings thrown out. The award was increased to treble damages. Punitive damages, however, were properly denied. Treble and punitive damages are separate remedies, and getting one doesn't mean you'll get the other.


Patton is the cautionary tale. The tenant won on the improper lockout but lost its § 853 request because it didn't prove the value of the property it lost. Three times nothing is nothing. If you're locked out, start building your damages record the same day: photographs through the window, purchase invoices, inventory counts, point-of-sale reports showing what a normal week looked like, and written demands for access. New York requires lost profits to be proven with reasonable certainty, so a restaurant with three years of sales history is in a far better position than one that opened last month.


Watch your deadlines too. Under CPLR § 214, an action to recover a chattel or damages for taking or detaining one, and an action for injury to property, must be brought within three years. Claims based on the lease generally fall under the six-year contract period in CPLR § 213. Lockout cases often combine several theories, so don't assume the longest period covers all of them.


How does New York City's commercial tenant harassment law change the risk for landlords?


In the five boroughs, a commercial landlord lockout can expose the landlord to a separate claim under the City's commercial tenant harassment law, Admin. Code § 22-902, on top of any RPAPL § 853 claim. The law targets conduct meant to force a commercial tenant out of its space or into surrendering lease rights. Its list of prohibited tactics reaches lockout-style behavior, including removing a tenant's possessions and changing the entrance lock without supplying the tenant a key, along with threats and repeated interruptions of essential services. A tenant who proves harassment can ask a court for relief that can include damages, injunctions and attorney's fees.


This law stops at the city line. A landlord in Garden City or Huntington who locks out a tenant faces the common-law re-entry rules and RPAPL § 853, but not the City's harassment statute. A landlord in Long Island City doing exactly the same thing faces both. That geographic difference rarely appears in generic lockout advice, and it should shape how cautious a landlord is on either side of the Queens-Nassau border.


The City law also changes the calculation for landlords who believe they're technically in the right. A landlord with a clean re-entry clause and an unpaid rent demand may still face allegations that the lockout was part of a broader effort to clear the building, especially if it followed service cutoffs or a run of baseless notices. How the City law treats a re-entry that otherwise satisfies the lease is a fact-specific question. If you're a landlord weighing self-help, a nonpayment proceeding is slower but cleaner. Under RPAPL § 711(2), it begins with a written rent demand giving the tenant at least fourteen days' notice, and it ends with a marshal, not a locksmith. If the real goal is to end a tenancy whose term has expired, the proper route is a commercial holdover proceeding.


Tenants should think about who else is exposed, too. If your lease is backed by a good guy guarantee, the date and manner of the landlord's re-entry can affect what the guarantor owes, and landlords sometimes pursue guarantors through CPLR 3213 summary judgment in lieu of complaint. And if the claimed arrears came from disputed escalations or a year-end reconciliation, review those charges carefully; our guide to CAM charges and rent escalation explains how. A lockout built on rent that wasn't actually owed rests on a weak foundation.


What else do NYC business tenants and landlords ask about lockouts?


The questions below come up most often after the locks change.


Frequently Asked Questions


Can my NYC landlord change the locks if I'm just one month behind on rent?

Only if your lease specifically reserves a right of re-entry for nonpayment, any demand or notice the lease requires was given and ignored, and the re-entry is peaceful. Without an express re-entry clause, unpaid rent alone doesn't justify self-help, as the Second Department held in Moran v. Orth.

Do I owe rent for the time I was locked out?

If the lockout was improper, the landlord may lose its claim to rent for the period afterward. In Patton v. Modern Asian, the landlord couldn't recover post-lockout rent because it hadn't satisfied its re-entry clause's condition. If the re-entry was lawful, your lease may still leave you liable for damages, so read its default and survival provisions closely.

Are treble damages automatic under RPAPL § 853?

No. Courts have discretion, and Moran v. Orth shows they're most likely to treble when the lockout was deliberate and prolonged. You also have to prove actual damages first, which is where the tenant in Patton fell short.

Does New York City's commercial tenant harassment law protect businesses on Long Island?

No. It's part of the New York City Administrative Code and covers commercial space in the five boroughs. Tenants in Nassau and Suffolk rely on their lease, the common-law re-entry rules and RPAPL remedies such as § 853.


A commercial landlord lockout in New York is lawful only when the lease expressly allows re-entry, the triggering default and any required demand are real, and the landlord retakes the space peacefully. Miss any of those steps, and the tenant may be restored to possession and seek treble damages under RPAPL § 853, with the City's harassment law adding further exposure in the five boroughs.


If you or your business has been locked out of a commercial space, or you're a landlord deciding whether a re-entry would hold up, Reza Yassi at Yassi Law PC is ready to help. Call us today at 646-992-2138 for a consultation.



Written by Reza Yassi | LinkedIn


Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.


This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Although I am an attorney, I am not your attorney, and reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws vary by jurisdiction and may have changed since the publication of this article. For advice specific to your situation, consult a qualified attorney.


slider 4.jpg
Reza Yassi(author).png

Principal Attorney, Yassi Law P.C.
Reza Yassi is the principal attorney at Yassi Law P.C., representing clients in commercial litigation and personal injury matters. He is known for his aggressive yet tactical approach, combining strategic planning with clear client communication while serving individuals and businesses across New York and New Jersey.

bottom of page